Misplaced Pages

Černová massacre: Difference between revisions

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
Browse history interactively← Previous editNext edit →Content deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 22:26, 2 October 2019 view sourceKIENGIR (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users, Pending changes reviewers25,154 edits added plus source on the leader of the gendarmes which cannot be ignored, as well details explanded on the number of the whole unit and another circumstances← Previous edit Revision as of 22:27, 2 October 2019 view source KIENGIR (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users, Pending changes reviewers25,154 edits →Outline of the events: mNext edit →
Line 11: Line 11:
he ceremony was to take place on 27 October 1907. The official procession arrived at the village accompanied by a squad of 15 gendarmes. It was protested against by the locals, who attempted to block its way to the church to prevent Pazurik from consecrating. The demonstration was peaceful in nature <ref name="gleiman">{{cite book|last=Gleiman|first=Lubomir|title=From the Maelstrom: A Pilgrim's Story of Dissent and Survival in the Twentieth Century|year=2011|publisher=AuthorHouse|page=30|url=https://books.google.cz/books?id=bJQPu99K_d0C&pg=PA30&dq=cernova+hlinka&hl=en&sa=X&ei=Viq-UembGsbKtAav3oAQ&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=cernova%20hlinka&f=false}}</ref> <ref name="elMallakh">{{cite journal|last=El Mallakh|first=Dorothea H.|title=The Slovak autonomy movement, 1935-1939: a study in unrelenting nationalism|journal=East European Quarterly|year=1979|url=https://books.google.cz/books?id=c8hnAAAAMAAJ&q=cernova+hlinka&dq=cernova+hlinka&hl=en&sa=X&ei=jSq-UZeEDMnlswaQ_IG4DA&redir_esc=y}}</ref> although some accounts report stone-throwing at a member of the gendarme escort.<ref name="setonWatson"/> In panic<ref name="holec" /> the gendarme leader ] Ján Ladiczky,<ref>{{cite web |url=https://ujszo.com/velemeny/a-kilencvenot-eve-ujra-es-ujra-eldordulo-cernovai-sortuz |title=A kilencvenöt éve újra és újra „eldördülő” černovái sortűz |author=<!--Not stated--> |date=29 October 2002 |website=ujszo.com |publisher=ÚjSZÓ}}</ref><ref name="holec" /> an ethnic Slovak,<ref></ref> ordered his squad to open fire into the crowd without prior warning<ref name="setonWatson"/> killing 15 of the protesting villagers, seriously wounding 12 and lightly injuring 40.<ref>http://www.cernova.sk/sublinks/cernovska_masakra3.html {{sk icon}}</ref><ref name="nedelsky"/><ref name=holecSME>{{cite web|title=Historik: Ospravedlnenie Maďarov za Černovú by nebolo produktívne|url=http://www.sme.sk/c/6113458/historik-ospravedlnenie-madarov-za-cernovu-by-nebolo-produktivne.html|publisher=Petit Press}}</ref> he ceremony was to take place on 27 October 1907. The official procession arrived at the village accompanied by a squad of 15 gendarmes. It was protested against by the locals, who attempted to block its way to the church to prevent Pazurik from consecrating. The demonstration was peaceful in nature <ref name="gleiman">{{cite book|last=Gleiman|first=Lubomir|title=From the Maelstrom: A Pilgrim's Story of Dissent and Survival in the Twentieth Century|year=2011|publisher=AuthorHouse|page=30|url=https://books.google.cz/books?id=bJQPu99K_d0C&pg=PA30&dq=cernova+hlinka&hl=en&sa=X&ei=Viq-UembGsbKtAav3oAQ&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=cernova%20hlinka&f=false}}</ref> <ref name="elMallakh">{{cite journal|last=El Mallakh|first=Dorothea H.|title=The Slovak autonomy movement, 1935-1939: a study in unrelenting nationalism|journal=East European Quarterly|year=1979|url=https://books.google.cz/books?id=c8hnAAAAMAAJ&q=cernova+hlinka&dq=cernova+hlinka&hl=en&sa=X&ei=jSq-UZeEDMnlswaQ_IG4DA&redir_esc=y}}</ref> although some accounts report stone-throwing at a member of the gendarme escort.<ref name="setonWatson"/> In panic<ref name="holec" /> the gendarme leader ] Ján Ladiczky,<ref>{{cite web |url=https://ujszo.com/velemeny/a-kilencvenot-eve-ujra-es-ujra-eldordulo-cernovai-sortuz |title=A kilencvenöt éve újra és újra „eldördülő” černovái sortűz |author=<!--Not stated--> |date=29 October 2002 |website=ujszo.com |publisher=ÚjSZÓ}}</ref><ref name="holec" /> an ethnic Slovak,<ref></ref> ordered his squad to open fire into the crowd without prior warning<ref name="setonWatson"/> killing 15 of the protesting villagers, seriously wounding 12 and lightly injuring 40.<ref>http://www.cernova.sk/sublinks/cernovska_masakra3.html {{sk icon}}</ref><ref name="nedelsky"/><ref name=holecSME>{{cite web|title=Historik: Ospravedlnenie Maďarov za Černovú by nebolo produktívne|url=http://www.sme.sk/c/6113458/historik-ospravedlnenie-madarov-za-cernovu-by-nebolo-produktivne.html|publisher=Petit Press}}</ref>


The majority of the members of the ] gendarmes involved in the shooting were of ] origin (5 persons from the total seven), and the performed the shootings not because of any ethnic reason, but they were obligated to do so according the rules of their service.<ref name="holec"> Interview with Roman Holec, historian</ref><ref>{{cite journal| quotes = | author = Csapó Csaba| date = | year = 2010/I| month = | title = A csendőri szolgálat| journal = Rubicon| volume = XX| issue = 202| pages = 13| doi = | id = {{ISSN|0865-6347}}| url = | format = | accessdate = }}</ref> The majority of the members of the ] gendarmes involved in the shooting were of ] origin (five persons from the total seven), and they performed the shootings not because of any ethnic reason, but they were obligated to do so according the rules of their service.<ref name="holec"> Interview with Roman Holec, historian</ref><ref>{{cite journal| quotes = | author = Csapó Csaba| date = | year = 2010/I| month = | title = A csendőri szolgálat| journal = Rubicon| volume = XX| issue = 202| pages = 13| doi = | id = {{ISSN|0865-6347}}| url = | format = | accessdate = }}</ref>


==Consequences== ==Consequences==

Revision as of 22:27, 2 October 2019

The neutrality of this article is disputed. Relevant discussion may be found on the talk page. Please do not remove this message until conditions to do so are met. (October 2013) (Learn how and when to remove this message)

The Černová massacre (or Černová tragedy, Template:Lang-sk, Template:Lang-hu or Csernova Affair) was a shooting that happened in Csernova, Kingdom of Hungary (today Černová, part of Ružomberok, Slovakia) on 27 October 1907 in which 15 people were killed and many were wounded after gendarmes fired into a crowd of people gathering for the consecration of the local Catholic church. The shootings sparked protests in European and American press and turned world's attention to the treatment of minorities in the Hungarian part of Austria-Hungary.

Outline of the events

Pretext

On the initiative of Andrej Hlinka, the Slovak parish priest of nearby Rózsahegy (Ružomberok) and a native of Csernova (Černová), people of the city decided to raise money for the construction of a new church. The locals raised 80,000 crowns, and the collections received minor donations from Slovak Americans as well. The construction started in April 1907 and by the autumn, the church was ready for consecration.

The locals wanted the church to be consecrated by Hlinka, however, he was at the time suspended by bishop Sándor Párvy and sentenced to two years of imprisonment due to his pro-Slovak agitation during the election campaign of 1906 and the subsequent conviction of incitement. The people of Csernova (Černová) thus demanded the consecration to be postponed until Hlinka would be able to perform the ceremony. The bishopric denied their request and two Magyar speaking priests were appointed in his stead: first, Canon Anton Kurimsky, and after his refusal, Dean Martin Pazurik of Likavka.

he ceremony was to take place on 27 October 1907. The official procession arrived at the village accompanied by a squad of 15 gendarmes. It was protested against by the locals, who attempted to block its way to the church to prevent Pazurik from consecrating. The demonstration was peaceful in nature although some accounts report stone-throwing at a member of the gendarme escort. In panic the gendarme leader sergeant Ján Ladiczky, an ethnic Slovak, ordered his squad to open fire into the crowd without prior warning killing 15 of the protesting villagers, seriously wounding 12 and lightly injuring 40.

The majority of the members of the Hungarian gendarmes involved in the shooting were of Slovak origin (five persons from the total seven), and they performed the shootings not because of any ethnic reason, but they were obligated to do so according the rules of their service.

Consequences

Many attempted to capitalize politically on the events, Czech and Slovak nationalists in general, and Hlinka in particular. On the one hand, Hlinka's appeal against his 1906 verdict was rejected, thus, on 30 November 1907 Hlinka started to serve his jail term in the Csillagbörtön (Star Prison), Szeged. On the other hand, Hlinka appealed with success his suspension to the Holy See, so it was cancelled on 8 April 1909. When Hlinka left the prison, Bishop Párvy appointed him again to his Rózsahegy (Ružomberok) parish, and Hlinka consecrated the church in Csernova (Černová) with Párvy's consent. The tragedy sparked protests in the European and US press and it turned the world's attention to the attitude to the minorities in Hungary.

Today's Slovak politicians — especially the members of the Slovak National Party interpret the event as "Hungarian gendarmes shooting at innocent Slovaks". With many of their claims regarding the events, the Slovak National Party continues to perpetuate a "false myth of Černová". Some Slovak sources claim that the gendarmes were ethnic Hungarian. even though there was a very small number of ethnic Hungarians in the region where the gendarmes were recruited. According to Slovak historian Roman Holec, professor at Comenius University in Bratislava, the majority of the gendarmes were Slovaks from Liptó county. (According to the official 1910 census, over 90% of the population were ethnic Slovaks in that county.) They were nevertheless honored for the deed, because they were in the service of Hungarian state. Both the rioters and the gendarmes can be held responsible for the massacre. The rioters were violent from lack of fear of getting shot (i.e. that the sergeant would refrain from giving an order of fire or use blanks). The gendarmes were shooting in all directions instead of aiming for feet or into the air (most victims died due to their head and chest injuries).

See also

References

  1. Oakes, Elizabeth; Roman, Eric (2003). "Historical dictionary A-Z". Austria-Hungary and the Successor States: A Reference Guide from the Renaissance to the Present (European Nations). Facts on File. p. 456. ISBN 978-0-8160-4537-2.
  2. ^ Seton Watson, Christopher, Hugh (1981). The Making of a New Europe: : R.W. Seton-Watson and the Last Years of Austria-Hungría. Austria: Taylor & Francis. p. 53.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  3. http://www.cernova.sk/sublinks/cernovska_masakra1.html Template:Sk icon
  4. Kamusella, Tomasz (2009). The politics of language and nationalism in modern Central Europe. Palgrave Macmillan. p. 556.
  5. ^ Nedelsky, Nadya (2009). Defining the Sovereign Community: The Czech and Slovak Republics. University of Pennsylvania Press. p. 61.
  6. Gleiman, Lubomir (2011). From the Maelstrom: A Pilgrim's Story of Dissent and Survival in the Twentieth Century. AuthorHouse. p. 30.
  7. El Mallakh, Dorothea H. (1979). "The Slovak autonomy movement, 1935-1939: a study in unrelenting nationalism". East European Quarterly.
  8. ^ Roman Holec szerint egyes politikusok régi mítoszokat próbálnak újraéleszteni Interview with Roman Holec, historian
  9. "A kilencvenöt éve újra és újra „eldördülő" černovái sortűz". ujszo.com. ÚjSZÓ. 29 October 2002.
  10. Slota újabb kirohanása: tovább sértegeti a magyarokat
  11. http://www.cernova.sk/sublinks/cernovska_masakra3.html Template:Sk icon
  12. "Historik: Ospravedlnenie Maďarov za Černovú by nebolo produktívne". Petit Press.
  13. Csapó Csaba (2010/I). "A csendőri szolgálat". Rubicon. XX (202): 13. ISSN 0865-6347. {{cite journal}}: Check date values in: |year= (help); Cite has empty unknown parameters: |quotes= and |month= (help)CS1 maint: year (link)
  14. Seton-Watson, Robert (1908). Racial problems in Hungary.
  15. Egy elfelejtett sortűz nyomában A szóvivő Rafael Rafaj aláírásával ellátott dokumentum annak ellenére ápolja tovább csernova hamis mítoszát, hogy egy évtizede már komoly, a legendákkal, tévhitekkel leszámoló monográfia szól az esetről egy szlovák történész, Roman Holec tollából.
  16. Kirschbaum, Joseph M. (1978). Slovakia in the 19th & 20th centuries. Slovak World Congress. p. 464.

External links

Categories: