This is an old revision of this page, as edited by 68.128.176.92 (talk) at 17:12, 7 May 2003. The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.
Revision as of 17:12, 7 May 2003 by 68.128.176.92 (talk)(diff) ← Previous revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)The song Happy Birthday was written by American sisters Patty and Mildred Hill in 1893 when they were school teachers in Louisville, Kentucky. The verse was originally intended as a classroom greeting entitled Good Morning To All. The lyrics were copyrighted in 1935, 11 years before Patty's death, and the ownership has swapped hands in multi-million dollar deals ever since; the copyright is currently owned by Warner Communications who bought the rights in 1985 and is scheduled to expire in 2021.
Happy Birthday is now among the top three most popular songs in the English language, along with "Auld Lang Syne" and "For He's a Jolly Good Fellow".
Happy Birthday a.k.a. Good Morning to All editorial by J. Byron, May 2003
There is a 1935 copyright registration for Happy Birthday, but the melody "Good Morning to All" was published in 1893 and is public domain by U. S. statute. (you just can't use the lyrics in public without paying) However, one site listed in this editorial claims possession of some early publications that nullify the copyright to even the lyrics.
My own comments do not constitute legal advice in any way. I am not a lawyer. This is the result of my own personal study. I accept no liability resulting from use/abuse.
There are many references to "Happy Birthday" on the Web. Most warn you of the copyright claim on it, and that the current owners rabidly defend it. Many of these "editorials" do not tell you about the song "Good Morning to all" - and the few that do, don't tell you about its undeniable legal status. Is this deliberate, or just ignorance of the facts? I don't know.
"Good Morning to All" included in: Song Stories for the Kindergarten, pub. 1893 Song Stories for the Kindergarten, revised ed., pub. 1896 Words: Patty Hill (-1946) Music: Mildred Hill (-1916)
The song "Good Morning to All" - from which "Happy Birthday" was allegedly derived - is free to use (words and music) by U. S. federal statute. (Published before 1923, and furthermore published before 1909) That "version" of the "birthday" melody may suffice for some people. (The law of other countries might affect the status outside the U. S.)
Allegedly, after the Hill's publication of "Good Morning to All" Robert Coleman sang the "birthday" lyrics with the "Good Morning to All" melody. Later the "Happy Birthday" lyrics combined with the Hill's published melody showed up on stage. The Hill family won a law suit granting them the 1935 copyright mentioned endlessly on the Web. (Which does not effect today's public domain status of "Good Morning to All.")
Except for the splitting of the first note in the melody "Good Morning to All" to accommodate the two syllables in the word hap-py, melodically "Happy Birthday" and "Good Morning to All" are identical. Precedence (regarding works derived from public domain material, and cases addressing similar musical works) seems to suggest that the melody as used in "Happy Birthday" would not merit additional legal protection for one split note. (As separated from the lyrics themselves.) A contact I made via the Web, claimed that someone at Warner acknowledged this much to him by phone. It would be the reader's own responsibility to verify that.
In summary, many people are unaware that the public domain status in the U. S. of the melody from "Good Morning to All" is not in question. Many of those who DO know about the public domain status of "Good Morning to All" nevertheless believe that splitting the first note of the melody as was done for "Happy Birthday" would merit protection and attract Warner's attention. My limited understanding of the law suggests otherwise, and if my Web contact was correct, the copyright owner acknowledges the melody to "Happy Birthday" as public domain.
Searching further, I found a music publisher specializing in public domain music who claims that he and others have publications of "Happy Birthday" - with the lyrics, that are not covered by the 1935 copyright. (Of course there is no public comment by Warner on this.) The Web page owner/publisher told me via email, that they know they would lose any challenge to his claim.
He states on his Web page:
"Happy Birthday Document (proving that it is "public domain".) A 1935 copyright is invalid according to us, double your money back if we are wrong. (Many people have been ripped off by this dilemma)"
- http://members.aol.com/katzmarek/pdmusic.htm
Sources for "Good Morning to All" sheet music:
http://www.pdinfo.com/rp/R002152.htm
http://music.netstoreusa.com/songs/7005/HL00502604~958965.shtml
Editorials about "Happy Birthday" - that are incomplete:
http://www.attachemag.com/archives/01-02/story2/story2.htm
http://www.snopes.com/music/songs/birthday.htm
Copyright and public domain in the U. S.:
http://www.unc.edu/~unclng/public-d.htm