Misplaced Pages

User talk:A Contemporary Nomad

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Basp1 (talk | contribs) at 00:41, 24 May 2021 (→atlases and maps). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Revision as of 00:41, 24 May 2021 by Basp1 (talk | contribs) (→atlases and maps)(diff) ← Previous revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

vandalism

Hi . what you have don in this page is vandalism . you have deleted historical material all with references the language such as turkish persian and Arabic that you may not read it if you repeat it I should report you to the board . 06:44, 19 May 2021 (UTC) — Preceding unsigned comment added by Basp1 (talk • contribs)

Hey there @Basp1, reverting vandalism is not edit warring and I would advise you to re-read my RV summary on why I have reverted to the last stable version by @EdJohnston. Furthermore, if I were in your position I would tread carefully WP:PROXYING on behalf of banned editors is not permitted: Editors who reinstate edits made by a banned or blocked editor take complete responsibility for the content. and I find this canvasing call-to-action to be concerning as well. Hope that helps you, take care — ♾️ Contemporary Nomad 07:00, 19 May 2021 (UTC)
Hi . with respect to your interest on the Arabian peninsula issues , as you considered I did not revert what was don by previous banned editor I am just in favor of giving more information to the reader who can not read Arabic and persian and Turkic. no other intention, i had read the matter for many times I had cheqed the sources many times. i see it necessary the this information be on the page without Censorship . if you could help with another sources will much appreciated .first of all please answer the simple question what was wrong with the maps with different name of arabinan sea ?? — Preceding unsigned comment added by Basp1 (talk • contribs)
some maps with historical names Basp1
  • 17th century map depicting the locations of the Periplus of the Erythraean Sea 17th century map depicting the locations of the Periplus of the Erythraean Sea
  • Persian Sea. Persian Sea.
  • Asia. Sinus Persicus and the Mare Persicum in a very famous map published in many atlases in recent years]] Asia. Sinus Persicus and the Mare Persicum in a very famous map published in many atlases in recent years]]
  • Bahre Fars Bahre Fars
  • Soulier, E.; Andriveau-Goujon, MER ERYTHREE 1838. Soulier, E.; Andriveau-Goujon, MER ERYTHREE 1838.
  • 1658 Jansson Map of the Indian Ocean (Erythrean Sea) 1658 Jansson Map of the Indian Ocean (Erythrean Sea)
  • A horizontal Malabar Coast miniature, a reprint by Petrus Bertius, 1630 A horizontal Malabar Coast miniature, a reprint by Petrus Bertius, 1630
  • The western part of the Indian Ocean, by Vincenzo Maria Coronelli, 1693, from his system of global gores the south The western part of the Indian Ocean, by Vincenzo Maria Coronelli, 1693, from his system of global gores the south
  • Persian Sea Persian Sea
  • Persia 1747 Persia 1747
  • Map of the Iranian dynasties in the mid 10th-century. Map of the Iranian dynasties in the mid 10th-century.
  • A map of Iran under the Qajar dynasty in the 19th century. A map of Iran under the Qajar dynasty in the 19th century.
As stated in the summary: Some of the sources that you have cited are WP:QS, WP:CIRC, and others are listing the names of medieval books with no way to easily verify it (you haven't provided a link to those books other than the Arabic/Persian native names?). Another significant WP:QS issue is citing a book called ''Documents on the Persian Gulf's name: the eternal heritage of ancient time' (Author:Ajam, Muḥammad) with a broken link which appears to be a book that you have created a Misplaced Pages article for back in 2012 if I'm not mistaken(?) and got deleted in this Afd discussion in May 2012 which you were a part of. It also appears that there was an issue of sock puppetry in that discussion. Furthermore, in that discussion you wrote: yes my field of study and research is a little bit similar to Dr. Ajam but he is also a famous linguist but i am not. HE is this and i am another scholar which I assume here by Dr.Ajam you mean the author of the book that you've tried to cite in your edits, am I correct in that assessment? Here's hoping this doesn't also boils down to WP:COI because honestly it becoming more tedious to keep track of all the issue(s) in this WP:WAR.
Finally, regarding your statement that you don't want to revert the banned user edits but to provide an alternative name for the reader. Again, I advise you to re-read @Tamzin comments and advice to you on WP:POV pushing. You're free to contribute in the article with WP:V sources, I would even help you with that. But you don't do that by RVing and using deprecated sources or sources that are being disputed currently, if you want to advocate in favor of those citations perhaps it's best to start discussing the issue in the article talk page first. Hope that helps — ♾️ Contemporary Nomad 07:56, 19 May 2021 (UTC)

atlases and maps

Hi. I had asked a very simple question :" please answer the simple question what was wrong with the maps with different name of arabinan sea ?? can we keep this part in the text? do you think the fairy tale that you had wrote above is answer of my question?? why you are hiding the maps that have been published many times in different reliable books and atlases? thank you. 2- there are hundreds of books and atlases . I do not advise a single book or article. you can search the word "persian sea" in google but in Arabic alphabet not in English : بحر فارس you will find text of some of medieval Arabic books : i can send you more than 100 text but would you please send me a single text of arabic mentioned the arabian sea befor 18 century? it will be very useful if you show a text. among the many atlases I can refer you to Atlas of La Péninsule Arabique dans les cartes Européennes Anciennes (The Arabian Peninsula in Old European Maps).Paris, Monde Arabs institute and Tunisia university IMA & Khaled. Al Ankary, 2001. ۴۲۴ pp. contains ۲۶۰ maps with details about each map in 3 languages: Arabic, English and French. Almost all of these 260 maps have the correct name of Persian Gulf. Moreover, 10 maps have used both Persian Gulf for the persian gulf and also persian Sea (for the body of water which is now called Arabian sea) • Hi ,HELLO. please look at the page I tried to refer to other sources although there are many source in Arabic and persian and not in English. please help to make it better any how I will publish it at the end in the main page. 01:02, 20 May 2021 (UTC) — Preceding unsigned comment added by Basp1 (talk • contribs)


Hey there @Basp1. I apologize I'm currently unable to review or help you with the section edit. I would advise you to refer to the Teahouse and post it there to see if there are editors who are willing to review the edit and sources for you. I want to also clarify that it's ok to use Arabic and Persian sources they don't have to be in English. However the main issue with your previous edits were WP:CIRC (using Turkish, Persian and Arabic wikipedia as a source) and WP:QS the "Persian Gulf studies" website which doesn't seems to be WP:NPOV. It's ok to use Arabic or Persian medieval books but if you can please provide a link to access the book in question and if you can provide a direct qoute it would be 100% much better. Hope that's helpful — ♾️ Contemporary Nomad 09:27, 21 May 2021 (UTC)
Also please check this page you might find it very helpful: Misplaced Pages:Citing sources — ♾️ Contemporary Nomad 09:29, 21 May 2021 (UTC)
  • thank you so much, I wish you and others also help make it more reliable and precise.