Misplaced Pages

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Byzanz (talk | contribs) at 07:54, 24 April 2007 (what do we know about Andreas Klärner? Can he be regardet important and reputable?). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

The neutrality of this article is disputed. Relevant discussion may be found on the talk page. Please do not remove this message until conditions to do so are met. (Learn how and when to remove this message)

The Informationsdienst gegen Rechtsextremismus (IDGR) has been a German project on the Internet set up to counter anti-Semitism, right wing extremism and Holocaust denial with information about them. The IDGR was founded in 1998 by Margret Bezold-Chatwin , commonly known under the pen name Magret Chatwin. The service provided documents, sources and articles on these themes for first information, scholars and scientific research, somewhat like the Nizkor Project, but with a different policy. In fact, Chatwin was a contributor to nizkor too. On September 27, 2006 the editor stopped the service.

Chatwin blamed wikipedia and other projects to have stolen her Intellectual property.

Purpose

The intention of the IDGR-authors was to describe anti-Semitism and Holocaust denial and to provide reliable information about the Holocaust, its perpetrators, and its background . This included providing in-depth analyses of news reports and revisionist literature, as well as references to books or Internet pages, but not directly to right extremist pages. Unlike Nizkor, the IDGR did not give access to communication with Holocaust deniers, but rather described their biographies, evolution of thought and organisational connections.

Structure

The main part of the website was a regularly updated collection of texts dealing with different topics in the field of Nazism and extremism. One subsection of the homepage has been the "Lexicon of Right Wing Extremism", consisting of about 300 files. It contained detailed information about right-wing activists (such as Erich Priebke), organizations, (f.e. National Alliance), publications, and Holocaust deniers (f.e. Ernst Zündel, Germar Rudolf and David Irving).

Support

In 2002, the IDGR won an annual price of 5.000 Euro by the Bündnis für Demokratie und Toleranz, an initiative for supporting civil engagement against racism, extremism and antisemitism.

The IDGR also was suggested as a reliable source by Andreas Klärner, sociologist and author working among others for the Hamburger Institut für Sozialforschung of Jan Philip Reemtsma, in 2004. Klärner criticised the decision of the editor not to link to sources on right wing extremist pages.

Controversies

Not only persons associated with the German New Right (Neue Rechte) and the right wing of the Christian Democratic Union accused the IDGR of trying to defame democrats by linking them with right-wing extremism for ideological reasons. Claus Wolfschlag, an author of the weekly Junge Freiheit, has criticised the IDGR as serving mainly to expose and defame personalities on the political right. He and others also view some of the IDGR's authors as left-wing extremists.

IDGR was criticised for noncritically describing persons such as Silvio Gesell who was characterised to have been influenced by folkish nazi-ideology. IDGR also falsly claimed Gottfried Feder has embraced Gesells theories. Werner Onken, the editor of Gsells writings, criticised that to be a blatant misinterpretation

Closure

After some of the former co-authors had left the project and founded a new project called redok, Margret Chatwin closed the IDGR in September 2006. In her final statement she gave as reasons: The idea of the Internet to provide and exchange free information for everyone had been distortet and commercialised. Later, she added:

Im übrigen sei darauf hingewiesen, dass es kein wie auch immer geartetes "Nachfolgeprojekt" gibt. Tatsächlich hat sich der kleine Zirkel, der dies öffentlich behauptet, bereits vor Jahren aus eigener Entscheidung vom IDGR abgewandt, um ein gänzlich anderes Projekt zu realisieren. Mit dem IDGR hat dieses Projekt in keiner Weise zu tun, schließlich fehlt es diesem an der entscheidenden Substanz – den Inhalten, die zu etwa 90 Prozent von der einstigen Herausgeberin verfasst wurden.

Also it is to be noted that there is no follow-up-project in any way. In fact, the small circle claiming this in public has already decided on its own years ago to leave IDGR and founded a totally different project. This project has nothing to do with the IDGR, it lacks the essential substance of it - the contents which were written to about 90 percent by the former editor.

References

1. Claus Wolfschlag on Magret Bezold-Chatwin
2. Margret Chatwin was activ on Nizkor bevore establishing IDGR
3. According to the TAZ Margret Chatwin claims wikipedia has stolen her intellectual property. (in German)
4. Bildungsserver Land Brandenburg über den IDGR
5. Panorama, a German broadcast, on Margret Chatwin
6. Bündnis für Demokratie und Toleranz: Preisträger 2002
7. : Wir über uns
8. Andreas Klärner
9. Andreas Klärner: Recension about IDGR for H-Soz-Kult, 23. Januar 2004 (German)
10. Junge Freiheit author's list, March 3, 2006
11. Macht ihnen ihr soziales Umfeld zur Hölle, (make their social setting hell) by C.-M. Wolfschlag, February 28, 2003
12. Silvio Gesell im IDGR-Lexikon gegen Rechtsextremismus by Werner Onken (in German)
13. Final declaration of Margret Chatwin

Further reading

• Albrecht Kolthoff: Der Informationsdienst gegen Rechtsextremismus (IDGR). In: Stephan Braun, Daniel Hörsch (Hrsg.): Rechte Netzwerke - eine Gefahr. VS - Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, Wiesbaden, 2004, S. 231-242. ISBN 3-8100-4153-X (in German)

• Anti-neo-Nazi activism
• Holocaust denial