This is an old revision of this page, as edited by 61.24.85.136 (talk) at 17:50, 17 November 2005 (there is no need for infobox since it is about an identical language, why post an infobox then?). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.
Revision as of 17:50, 17 November 2005 by 61.24.85.136 (talk) (there is no need for infobox since it is about an identical language, why post an infobox then?)(diff) ← Previous revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)- 1.Moldovan = Romanian (redirect link to Romanian)
- 2.Moldovan (Latin alphabet: limba moldovenească, Cyrillic alphabet: лимба молдовеняскэ, formerly translated into English as "Moldavian" or sometimes "Moldovian") is an Eastern Romance language, the official language of Moldova and one of the official languages of Transnistria.
Presently the Moldovan language, in its official form, is practically identical to Romanian, the official language of Romania. According to the most recent Moldovan census, 1/3% of all mother language speakers of Romanian declared their native language to be "Moldovan", while the remaining 2/3 declared their native language to be "Romanian".
"Moldovan" can also refer to the speech of the historical region of Moldavia in Romania.
History and Politics
Start of the artificial creation of "Moldavian".Romanian language in Imperial Russia.
In the first years of Russian occupation (after 1812), because 95% of the population were Romanians who only knew their mother tongue, Romanian was admitted as an official language in the institutions of Bessarabia, used along with Russian.
Gradually the Russian language gained importance. According to the dates offered by the Department for ruling the Bessarabia from 1828, the papers from bureau were held only in Russian, and around 1835 it is established a term of 7 years time in which the state institutions would still accept acts in Romanian language.
Concerning education, Romanian was admitted as language of teaching only until 1842, after which it was taught as a separate subject. Thus, at the theological Seminary of Chişinău, the Romanian language was found on the list of required subjects, with 10 hours weekly, until 1863, when the department of Romanian was closed for good. At highschool no. 1 from Chişinău the pupils had the right to choose between Romanian and German or between Romanian and Greek until 9 February 1866, when the state counselor of the Russian government forbid teaching of the Romanian language, because the pupils "know this language in the practical mode, and its teaching follows other goals."
Around 1871, the tsar published an ukase "On the suspension of teaching the Romanian language in the schools from Bessarabia", because "In Russian Empire are not taught local speeches."
Beginnings of the Moldovan language
The territory of Bessarabia, which forms the present-day Republic of Moldova, historically the eastern part of the principality of Moldavia, was annexed from the Ottoman Empire by Imperial Russia in 1812 and remained its part until the Russian October revolution of 1917. In 1918 Bessarabia was united with Romania. Twenty-two years later, in 1940, the Soviet Union annexed Bessarabia. A year later, in 1941, Romania invaded the Soviet Union as part of Operation Barbarossa and retook Bessarabia (along with a large portion of Ukraine). These territories were taken back by the Soviet Union 3 years later in 1944, and remained under Soviet administration until the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991.
With the 1924 creation of the Moldavian ASSR within the Ukrainian SSR, the new authorities declared the variety spoken by the majority of Moldovans to be "Moldavian language", in order to stem the growth of Romanian nationalism, which was perceived by the USSR as a threat to its control of the territory. The Latin alphabet was officially replaced by the Cyrillic alphabet. To justify this, the government claimed that up until just 80 years prior, the language was usually written in Cyrillic. (See: Moldovan alphabet)
As a result of all its near-constant state of flux, along with deportations of ethnic Romanians and the encouraged migration of Russians and other slavs from the rest of the USSR into the MSSR, by the mid-20th century Bessarabia contained a large amount of Russian speakers. Also, during Soviet rule, Moldovans were coerced into learning the Russian language by way of economic and intellectual bottlenecks, such as Russian being a prerequisite for access to higher education, social status and party membership. These policies contributed to the proliferation of Russian loanwords into Romanian spoken in the MSSR.
Romanizators and Anti-Romanizators
At the time there were discusions between the supporters ("Romanizators" or "Romanists") and opponents ("Anti-Romanizators") of the convergence of so-called "Moldavian" and Romanian language use. In other words, there were those who supported the usurping of Romanian's place as the native spoken and written language by Russian and the Cyrillic alphabet and there were those who saw the Russification policies as a threat to their linguistic identity as Romanian speakers. It was an attempt to remove a degree of literacy and nuance from everyday political and social discourse of non-Russians in the region.
In particular, Anti-Romanizators strived to base the literary Moldavian language on local dialects. Missing technical and other special terminology was covered by neologisms. As a result, the textbooks, e.g., in botany or physics were barely readable.
In February 1932 Moldovan communists recevied a directive from the Communist Party of Ukraine, which called for a return to writing Romanian using the Latin alphabet. This was part of a massive campaign in the USSR of latinization of the alphabets of so-called lesser (in effect non-Russian) nationalities and linguistic groups, based on the theory of Soviet linguist Nikolai Marr that postulated the convergence to a single world language, expected to be a means of communication in the future classless society (communism). This directive was passive-aggressively sabotaged by the "Anti-Romanizators" majority, until Stanislav Kosior (General Secretary of the Ukrainian Communist Party) with some Moldovan communists visited Stalin where Stalin supposedly insisted on faster latinization with the purpose of the convergence of so-called "Moldavian" and Romanian cultures, hinting at the possibility that in future Moldova and Romania would be reunited. Nevertheless, the resistance to Romanization persisted, and since 1933 a number of prominent "Anti-Romanizators" were repressed, their books destroyed, and their neologisms banned.
After the infamous February-March (1937) VKP(b) Central Committee Plenum, which escalated the Great Purge, both Romanizators and Anti-Romanizators were declared "imperialist spies": Anti-Romanizators, because they sabotaged the Latinization, and Romanizators, because they were "agents of boyar Romania" ("Боярская Румыния").
In February 1938 Moldovan communsits issued a declaration calling for the latin alphabet to once again be replaced by the Cyrillic alphabet, which in August 1939 was ammended into the law of the republic. The motivation was that the Latinization was used by so-called "bourgeois-nationalist elements" to "distantance the Moldovan populace from the Ukrainian and Russian ones, with the ultimate goal of the separation of Soviet Moldova from the USSR".
In 1956, during the rehabilitation of the victims of Stalinist repression, a special report was issued about the state of the so-called "Moldovan language," which stated, in part, that the discussions of 1920-30s between the two camps were mostly non-scientific, since there were so few linguists involved and that the grammar and the basic lexicon of literary Romanian and Moldovan languages are identical, while differences are secondary and non-essential. Once again, the convergence of Romanian and the so-called "Moldovan" languages was approved.
Reversion to Latin script, and beyond
In 1989, and the pre-1992 Romanian version of the Latin alphabet was made the official script of the Moldavian SSR.
After the independence of Moldova in 1991, "Romanian" was declared the official language, but the 1994 constitution changed the name of the language to Moldovan.
A 1996 attempt by Moldovan president Mircea Snegur to change the official language to "Romanian" was dismissed by the Moldovan Parliament as promoting Romanian expansionism.
In 2002, the government of Moldova gave the Russian language the same privileges as "Moldovan," since after Soviet rule and the massive Russian and Ukrainian settlement it invited, a significant proportion of the population were mother-tongue speakers of Russian. It was declared to be a mandatory foreign language in schools. This created a wave of indignation among the Romanian-speaking majority of the population and rallies against this decision were organized in Chişinău and other major cities. They were largely attended by students and youths, perhaps an indication of future linguistic and political trends in the country. Just as the population of Russian-speakers in the Baltic States has been declining over the past 15 years, so as that of Moldova.
In 2003, a Romanian-Moldovan dictionary (Stati 2003) was published. The linguists of the Romanian Academy in Romania declared that all the Moldovan words are also Romanian words, although some of its contents are disputed as being neologism resultant of Russification. In Moldova, the head of the Academy of Sciences' Institute of Linguistics, Ion Bărbuţă, described the dictionary as "an absurdity, serving political purposes". Supporters of Stati, however, accused both of promoting "Romanian colonialism".
On the 2004 census, about two thirds of the Romanian-Moldovans, which are the majority population in the Republic of Moldova, declared their mother tongue to be "Romanian", and one third "Moldovan", which is, according to the press, why the release of the official census results was delayed.
Linguistic view
Romanian and Moldovan are essentially one language from the linguistic perspective, view supported by almost all linguists. Also, in their official forms are basically identical, excepting for a minor spelling issue.
The spoken language in Moldova is part of the Moldavian dialect, also spoken in Eastern Romania.
Official view
The constitution of the Republic of Moldova refers to the country's language as Moldovan rather than Romanian although "Romanian" was once officially declared the official language between 1991 and 1994. However, in practice it is often called "Romanian" or "the language of the state".
Romanian and "Moldovan" is an identical language from all linguistic perspectives. In schools, the language is called Romanian, and textbooks from Romania are used significantly in the Moldovan education system. The Academy of Sciences of Moldova calls the language Romanian .
Also, in 2004, the Moldovan Minister of Justice, Ion Morei, said that Romanian and Moldovan are the same language and that the Constitution of Moldova should be amended, not necessarly by changing the word Moldovan into Romanian, but by adding that "Romanian and Moldovan are the same language".
The Moldavian chronicler, Grigore Ureche (1590 - 1647), established in his "Letopiseţul Ţării Moldovei" (The Chronicles of the land of Moldavia) that the Moldavian and Wallachian dialects of the time were essentially the same language; and that Moldavians and Wallachians shared the same ethnicity.
Alphabet
Cyrillic was replaced by Latin as the official alphabet for the Moldovan language in 1989. Nearly all urban Moldovans can read the Latin alphabet, although many over 30 are more comfortable writing in Cyrillic, as it was compulsorily script of their education. In the countryside, many people over 30 — especially peasants — prefer Cyrillic, but may write in the Latin alphabet, though with difficulty.
Spelling
The Romanian characters â and î are both written as î in Moldovan. Although â and î sound identical in speech, the Romanian justification for using these two characters is to bring Romanian closer orthographically to other Romance languages, and that etymologically, â and î are separate. In the Moldovan language, only the word "română" (Romanian) and "România" (Romania) are written with â, officially.
Romanian sunt is written as sînt in Moldovan. However, in Moldovan Cyrillic, it is variably written sunt or sînt. Although it is actually pronounced sînt in both languages, the Romanian justification for writing sunt is that it is etymologically correct and that it brings Romanian closer orthographically to other Romance languages. Many Moldovans who use "î/â" spellings write sânt, which is not an officially accepted spelling in either country.
It must be noted that, before the 1990s, Romanian used the same orthography as Moldovan (with just the character î and sînt). The decision to change the orthography to the â/î/sunt format was made by the Romanian Academy in 1993.
However, in both countries, the official versions are not always respected. For example, some Romanian newspapers use the "î"/"sînt" spelling (Academia Caţavencu among others), while some Moldovan newspapers use "î/â/sunt" spelling. (Accente, Garda, Timpul etc).
Only very rarely are "română" and derivatives are written using "î", and most people from either country will consider it to be incorrect usage.
Comparison Romanian/Moldavian
The example below demonstrates that a formal text in Romanian and Moldovan may be completely identical, the only difference being the spelling of the î vowel in the word vântul. The colloquial languages show more difference, which varies over the area.
Moldavian |
Romanian |
English |
|---|---|---|
| Vocala este un sunet din vorbirea omului, făcut cu trecerea sonoră, liberă şi fără piedică, a vîntului prin canalul sonor (compus din coardele vocale şi întreaga gură) sau un semn grafic care reprezintă un atare sunet. | Vocala este un sunet din vorbirea omului, făcut cu trecerea sonoră, liberă şi fără piedică, a vântului prin canalul sonor (compus din coardele vocale şi întreaga gură) sau un semn grafic care reprezintă un atare sunet. | The vowel is a sound in human speech, made by the sonorous, free and unhindered passing of the air through the sound channel (composed of the vocal chords and the whole mouth) or a graphic symbol corresponding to that sound. |
| Aşa bunăoară, avem şase vocale ce se fac cu vîntul ce trece prin gură, unde limba poate să se afle într-un loc sau altul şi buzele pot să stea deschise un soi sau altul. | Aşa bunăoară, avem şase vocale ce se fac cu vântul ce trece prin gură, unde limba poate să se afle într-un loc sau altul şi buzele pot să stea deschise un soi sau altul. | This way, we have six vowels that are produced by the air passing through the mouth, where the tongue can be in one place or another and the lips can be opened in one way or another. |
| Vocalele pot să fie pronunţate singure sau împreună cu semivocale sau consoane. | Vocalele pot să fie pronunţate singure sau împreună cu semivocale sau consoane. | The vowels can be pronounced alone or together with semivowels or consonants. |
Second example is taken from the Constitution of Moldova and Romania. The identity is more than obvious.
| so called Moldavian |
Romanian |
English |
|---|---|---|
| TITLUL I: Principii Generale | TITLUL I Principii Generale | FIRST TITLE: General Principles |
| Articolul 1
Statul Republica Moldova |
Articol 1 Statul român | Article 1 (Romanian/Republic of Moldova State) |
| (1) Republica Moldova este un stat suveran şi independent, unitar şi indivizibil. | (1) România este stat naţional, suveran şi independent, unitar şi indivizibil. | (1) Romania/Republic of Moldova is a national, independent, unity and undestructible state. |
| 2) Forma de guvernămînt a statului este republica. | (2) Forma de guvernământ a statului român este republica. | (2) The form of the guvernment of the state is republic. |
| (3) Republica Moldova este un stat de drept, democratic, în care demnitatea omului, drepturile şi libertăţile ... | (3) România este stat de drept, democratic şi social, în care demnitatea omului, drepturile şi libertăţile ... | Romania/Republic of Moldova is a state of low, democratic, in which the human dignity, rights and liberties... |
| ] | ] | Links to the official page of Constitution for both countries |
External links
- Moldovan (Cyrillic) alphabet and pronunciation
- Few audio examples of amalgamation of Romanian and Russian or so called "jargon" (MP3)
- Constitutional Court of Transnistria site in Moldovan-Cyrillic (куртя конституционалэ)
Notes
- The Cyrillic script has not been in official use in the Republic of Moldova since independence 1989, but is official in Transnistria, and is still used by smaller groups elsewhere.
- World Bank, Reviews of National Policies for Education: Moldova, p. 51
- "Moldovan teachers perfect themselves in Galaţi, from Viaţa Liberă a Galaţi-based weekly (in Romanian)
- Academy of Sciences of Moldova website
- Language in Moldova - observations in streets and houses in the Republic of Moldova by Diana Nissler
- Grenoble 2003, pp 89-93
References
- Grenoble, Lenore A (2003) Language Policy in the Soviet Union, Springer, ISBN 1402012985
- Dyer, D. (1999). The Romanian Dialect of Moldova: A Study in Language and Politics. Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen Press. (ISBN 0773480374)
- Dyer, Donald Leroy, ed. Studies in Moldovan. New York: Columbia University Press (East European Monographs), 1996. (ISBN 0880333510)
- Stati, V.N. Dicţionar moldovenesc-românesc. Chisinau: Tipografia Centrala (Biblioteca Pro Moldova), 2003. (ISBN 9975782485)
- Ильяшенко, Татиьяна Павловна. Языковые контакты : на материале славиано-молдав, отношений. Moscow: "Наука" , 1970. (LCCN 78510414)
- Афтени, М.К., Батыр, Л.К., Богач, И.И. (1961). Молдавско-русский словарь. Moscow, USSR: Государственное издательство иностранных и национальных словарей. (LCCN 62045065)
- Ецко, И.И. (1987). Молдавско-русский словарь. Kishinev, Moldavian SSR: МСЭ . (LCCN 88112743)
- Баскаков, Н.А. (1973). Гагаузско-русско-молдавский словарь. Moscow, USSR: Unknown. (LCCN 73355147)
- Bruchis, M. (1982). One Step Back, Two Steps Forward. New York: Columbia University Press (East European Monographs). (ISBN 0880330023)
- Bruchis, M. (1984). Nations, Nationalities, Peoples. New York: Columbia University Press (East European Monographs). (ISBN 0880330570)
- Bruchis, M. (1988). USSR Language and Realities. New York: Columbia University Press (East European Monographs). (ISBN 088033147X)
- Dumbrava, V. (2004). Sprachkonflikt Und Sprachbewusstsein In Der Republik Moldova: Eine Empirische Studie In Gemischtethnischen Familien (Sprache, Mehrsprachigkeit Und Sozialer Wandel). Bern: Peter Lang Publishing. (ISBN 3631507283)
- Movileanu N. Din istoria Transnistriei (1924-1940), Revista de istorie a Moldovei, 1993, #2.
- Negru E. Introducerea si interzicerea grafiei latine in R.A.S.S.M, 1999, Revista de istorie a Moldovei, #3-4.
- http://www.contrafort.md/2002/90-91/338_7.html
- http://www.mnsu.edu/emuseum/cultural/oldworld/europe/moldavia.html
- http://www.east-west-wg.org/cst/cst-mold/
- Letopiseţul Ţărîi Moldovei
| Eastern Romance languages |
|---|
|
Vulgar Latin language Substratum Thraco-Roman culture |
| Romanian |
|
| Aromanian |
| Megleno-Romanian |
| Istro-Romanian |