Misplaced Pages

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Jdforrester (talk | contribs) at 10:27, 22 July 2006 (→Members: Whoops, date.). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

This page documents an English Misplaced Pages policy.It describes a widely accepted standard that editors should normally follow, though exceptions may apply. Changes made to it should reflect consensus.

Shortcut ]

The Arbitration Committee exists to impose binding solutions to Misplaced Pages disputes. This solution may be anything up to and including a ban from editing Misplaced Pages for a period of time.

The Arbitration Committee is the last step in the dispute resolution process — it is a last resort to be turned to when all else has failed. Other steps, including discussion between users and, where appropriate, mediation, should be tried first. The Arbitration Committee exists to deal with only the most serious disputes and cases of rule-breaking.

Until the beginning of 2004, Jimbo Wales, the current head of the Wikimedia Foundation, which governs Misplaced Pages, dealt with all serious disputes and was the only person with the authority to ban users who were not engaging in simple vandalism (straightforward vandals can be blocked by any administrator). This role has now largely been passed to the Arbitration Committee. Jimbo wrote:

"The Arbitration Committee can impose a solution that I'll consider to be binding, with of course the exception that I reserve the right of executive clemency and indeed even to dissolve the whole thing if it turns out to be a disaster. But I regard that as unlikely, and I plan to do it about as often as the Queen of England dissolves Parliament against their wishes, i.e., basically never, but it is one last safety valve for our values."

• To request Arbitration, see Misplaced Pages:Requests for arbitration.
• The Arbitration policy details the rules involved.

Members

The number of active Committee members affects the number of Arbitrators needed to reach a ruling. For example, if seven Arbitrators are active, then four votes are needed to reach a majority decision. If ten are active, then six votes are needed, etc.. If an even number of members are active and there is a tie, then we will ask Jimbo Wales to give the tie-breaking vote; this situation has yet to happen, however.

By choice, we don't have a Chair.

AC status

Active - has participated in an AC case in the last month;

Away - on a temporary absence;

Inactive - has not participated in an AC case in the last month.

Active

As of 22 July 2006

• Fred Bauder - talk - fredbaud at ctelco.net (wiki e-mail)
• Sean Barrett aka "The Epopt" - talk - sean at epoptic.org (wiki e-mail)
• James Forrester aka "James F." / "Jdforrester" - talk - james at jdforrester.org (wiki e-mail)
• JayJG - talk - wiki e-mail
• Kat Walsh aka "Mindspillage" - talk - mindspillage at gmail dot com (wiki e-mail)
• Matthew Brown aka "Morven" - talk - morven at gmail dot com (wiki e-mail)
• Dmcdevit - talk - wiki e-mail
• SimonP - talk - wiki e-mail
• Theresa Knott - talk - theresaknott AT gmail DOT com (wiki e-mail)
• Mark, aka Raul654 - talk - wiki e-mail

Away

For weekend July 22-24

• Ben aka "Neutrality" - talk - wiki e-mail

Recovering from illness

• Filiocht - wiki e-mail

Holidaying until August

• Sam Korn - talk - sam dot korn at gmail dot com (wiki e-mail)

Until 10 August

• Charles Matthews - talk - charles dot r dot matthews at ntlworld dot com (wiki e-mail)

Inactive

(none)

Selection process

The original Arbitration Committee was appointed by Jimbo Wales, primarily chosen from people who volunteered to help with the mediation and arbitration processes. Arbitrators are chosen for appointment having been suggested through advisory elections; for temporary appointments to replace resignations, they are chosen after direct advice.

Arbitrators serve three-year terms on a rotating schedule, such that a "tranche" of five positions is up for re-appointment each year. In case of early departures, new Arbitrators are appointed to the partially-served, now empty, terms.

Alpha Tranche (Expires end-of-2007)

• Mark (Raul654)
• Ben (Neutrality)
• Simon P.
• Dmcdevit
• Fred Bauder

Beta Tranche (expires end-of-2008)

• James F (Jdforrester)
• Mindspillage
• Filiocht
• Charles Matthews
• Morven

Gamma Tranche (expires end-of-2006)

• JayJG
• Sean Barrett (The Epopt)
• Theresa Knott
• Sam Korn
• <Empty as of February 19, 2006>

It should be noted that while appointments are generally to specified terms, all Arbitrators serve at Jimbo's pleasure, and are not automatically removed at the expiration of those terms, but only by the appointment of a replacement or otherwise by Jimbo's will.

Former members

• UninvitedCompany (resigned, February 2004)
• James W. Rosenzweig, aka Jwrosenzweig (did not seek re-election, December 2004)
• The Cunctator (appointed to original committee, unsuccessful in election bid, December 2004)
• Gutza (resigned, December 2004)
• Martin Harper, aka MyRedDice (resigned, December 2004)
• Lee Pilich, aka Camembert (resigned, December 2004)
• Mark, aka Delirium (resigned, July 2005)
• Steven Melenchuk, aka Grunt (resigned, July 2005)
• Rebecca, aka Ambi (resigned, July 2005)
• Daniel Mayer, aka Maveric149 (resigned, September 2005)
• David Friedland, aka Nohat (resigned, September 2005)
• Sannse (resigned, November 2005)
• Kelly Martin (resigned, January 2006)
• David Gerard (did not seek re-election, January 2006)
• Fennec (did not seek re-election, January 2006)
• Mackensen (resigned, February 2006)

Member history

• Misplaced Pages policies
• Misplaced Pages dispute resolution
• Misplaced Pages Arbitration Committee
• Misplaced Pages functionaries