19 December 2019
- 11:4011:40, 19 December 2019 diff hist +12 Max Winter another particular fact that needs a citation
- 11:3411:34, 19 December 2019 diff hist −6 Max Winter →top: changing tag until more sources are added
- 11:3311:33, 19 December 2019 diff hist −293 Max Winter →Biography: a media sharing site is not a reliable source... nor is a random person's Facebook post (which is what this reference points to) ... as such also removing outlandish claim and tagging with cn
- 11:3011:30, 19 December 2019 diff hist −185 Max Winter →Biography: no way to know without original research which ellis island entry refers to him or his family... thus removed and tagged with cn
- 11:2711:27, 19 December 2019 diff hist −137 Max Winter →Biography: no way to know without original research whether the census data was referring to him or his family... thus removed
- 11:2511:25, 19 December 2019 diff hist −218 Max Winter Find a Grave is not a reliable source ... removing reference and tagging with cn
- 11:2211:22, 19 December 2019 diff hist −653 Max Winter nowhere in the source provided does it state what his family was (parents could have had mixed backgrounds).. thus removing OR... and what without background on the question of religion or ethnicity becomes a WP:CAT/R violation... if you want to readd ethnicity/religious affiliation do so using multiple reliable sources to make it clear this is how a consensus of reliable sources has covered him and don't use "born into a X family" without using sources that state what his entire family was
- 10:5810:58, 19 December 2019 diff hist −645 Sid Hartman →Background and early career: in no source provided does it state what his family was (parents could have had mixed backgrounds) nor that they raised him.. thus removing WP:OR.. if you want to readd ethnicity/religious affiliation do so using multiple reliable sources to make it clear this is how a consensus of reliable sources has covered him and don't use "born into a X family" without using sources that state what his entire family was - do not readd without consensus WP:BLPREMOVE
- 10:3510:35, 19 December 2019 diff hist −695 Morris Chalfen nowhere in the source provided does it state what his family was (parents could have had mixed backgrounds).. thus removing OR... and what without background on the question of religion or ethnicity becomes a WP:CAT/R violation... if you want to readd ethnicity/religious affiliation do so using multiple reliable sources to make it clear this is how a consensus of reliable sources has covered him and don't use "born into a X family" without using sources that state what his entire family was
- 10:3210:32, 19 December 2019 diff hist −733 Ben Berger nowhere in the source provided does it state what his family was (parents could have had mixed backgrounds).. thus removing OR... and what without background on the question of religion or ethnicity becomes a WP:CAT/R violation... if you want to readd ethnicity/religious affiliation do so using multiple reliable sources to make it clear this is how a consensus of reliable sources has covered him and don't use "born into a X family" without using sources that state what his entire family was
- 09:5609:56, 19 December 2019 diff hist 0 Misplaced Pages:Articles for deletion/Jonas Max Ferris →Jonas Max Ferris: found another passing mention...
- 09:5309:53, 19 December 2019 diff hist +53 Misplaced Pages:WikiProject Deletion sorting/People Listing Misplaced Pages:Articles for deletion/Jonas Max Ferris.
- 09:5309:53, 19 December 2019 diff hist +1,357 User talk:Wtimrock Notification: nomination of Jonas Max Ferris at articles for deletion.
- 09:5309:53, 19 December 2019 diff hist +53 Misplaced Pages:Articles for deletion/Log/2019 December 19 Adding Misplaced Pages:Articles for deletion/Jonas Max Ferris.
- 09:5309:53, 19 December 2019 diff hist +53 Misplaced Pages:WikiProject Deletion sorting/Journalism Listing Misplaced Pages:Articles for deletion/Jonas Max Ferris.
- 09:5309:53, 19 December 2019 diff hist +53 Misplaced Pages:WikiProject Deletion sorting/News media Listing Misplaced Pages:Articles for deletion/Jonas Max Ferris.
- 09:5309:53, 19 December 2019 diff hist +2,983 N Misplaced Pages:Articles for deletion/Jonas Max Ferris Creating deletion discussion page for Jonas Max Ferris.
- 07:4007:40, 19 December 2019 diff hist −451 Mel Sembler Undid revision 931502482 by Patapsco913 (talk) - do read WP:BLPREMOVE before you revert again... this is the only actual protocol Tag: Undo
- 06:4406:44, 19 December 2019 diff hist −451 Mel Sembler →Early life and education: he appears to self-identify as Jewish, but nowhere in the source provided does it state his family was or that his family even raised him... thus removing OR per WP:BLPREMOVE... if you want to readd ethnic background do so in a "personal life" section and use multiple reliable sources to make it clear this is how he has been covered
- 03:3703:37, 19 December 2019 diff hist −33 Michael E. Horowitz →Personal life: entirely UNDUE... we do not list the religious affiliation of other people's weddings, so we should not be singling out one type... especially on a BLP... removing WP:LABEL violation - do not readd without consensus (WP:BLPREMOVE)
- 03:3203:32, 19 December 2019 diff hist −37 Sol Wachtler →Early life and education: that is not supported by the source provided - removing clear WP:LABEL/WP:BLP violation - do not readd without consensus (WP:BLPREMOVE)
- 03:2803:28, 19 December 2019 diff hist −41 George Blumberg removing violation of WP:CAT/R - do not readd without consensus
- 03:2703:27, 19 December 2019 diff hist −197 George Blumberg →Life: source does not provide evidence that this person identified this way, nor does it support that their family was all the same ethnicity (statement is thus OR)... needs more references if this is to be readded per WP:CAT/R and LABEL as there is not currently evidence a consensus of reliable sources has found this key to Blumberg's notability
- 01:3001:30, 19 December 2019 diff hist −835 Jon Avnet source does not speak to his family (currently an OR violation) the NYT source indicates this may be the persons ethnicity but still removing categories per BLPCAT as there is not a preponderonce of sources covering this way [and current sourcing does not fully indicate self-identification... find more reliable sources that confirm the subject identifies this way (or that mention it is part of their notability) to readd the subject's beliefs/ethnicity or get a consensus - (WP:BLPREMOVE)
- 00:3900:39, 19 December 2019 diff hist −47 Joe Roth removing clear WP:BLPCAT violation... do not readd without consensus
- 00:3900:39, 19 December 2019 diff hist −356 Joe Roth →Early life: the source absolutely does not say that... his father (Lawrence) idenified as an atheist albeit Lawrence (not Joe) was raised by a Jewish family... therefore this assertion is is not backed up by RS and is UNDUE to be mentioned in this WP:BLP... it is also a clear violation of WP:LABEL as it has not been widely used by reliable sources to describe the subject - do not readd without consensus (WP:BLPREMOVE)
- 00:1000:10, 19 December 2019 diff hist −456 Sarah Rose source does not speak to her family (so currently an OR violation) but it would normally qualify to list the person in the relvant categories (so leaving those) per WP:BLPCAT as the subject self identifies this way... find another way to readd the subject's beliefs/ethnicity if deemed necessary - (WP:BLPREMOVE)
18 December 2019
- 23:4823:48, 18 December 2019 diff hist −733 List of Jewish American businesspeople in media →Newspapers and publishing: not backed up by references used... UNDUE to mention and a violation of WP:LABEL and WP:CAT/R as the subject has not publically self idenfied this way nor been identifies as such according to a *consensus* of reliable sources - do not readd this without consensus
- 23:3423:34, 18 December 2019 diff hist −494 Norman Cahners →Early life: the source does not speak to his family.. and as such this is not sufficient to use for this claim (also removed another similar claim in the article that is unsourced)... this is also UNDUE to mention and a violation of WP:LABEL and WP:CAT/R as the article subject has not publically self idenfied this way according to a *consensus* of reliable sources - do not readd this without consensus
- 22:5022:50, 18 December 2019 diff hist −505 List of Jewish American businesspeople →top: that does not line up with our policies on WP:BLPCAT... the article subject must self-identify as this or be covered by a consensus of reliable sources this way or it is an absolute violation of WP:BLP and WP:LABEL
- 22:2522:25, 18 December 2019 diff hist −27 Joy Silverman removing clear WP:BLPCAT violation... do not readd without consensus
- 22:2422:24, 18 December 2019 diff hist −57 Joy Silverman →Biography: that is not backed up by the source provided... removing weasel wording and apparent OR, WP:BLPREMOVE - do not re add this
- 22:0522:05, 18 December 2019 diff hist +5 m Suicide of Jamey Rodemeyer Reverted edits by 97.101.193.162 (talk) to last version by Philip Trueman Tag: Rollback
- 22:0122:01, 18 December 2019 diff hist −57 Joy Silverman →Biography: after a thorough review of the sources provided (including St. Louis Post-Dispatch, where the term is not once used) it is clear this assertion is is not backed up by RS and is UNDUE to be mentioned in this BLP... it is further a clear violation of WP:LABEL as it has not been widely used by reliable sources to describe the subject (Wolfe's book's one mention of Silverman's father's background does not equal wide use) - do not readd without consensus (WP:BLPREMOVE)
- 21:0621:06, 18 December 2019 diff hist +899 User talk:Praxidicae →Revert back to previous edit on Claude Vonstroke: note to paid editor about COI
- 13:1713:17, 18 December 2019 diff hist +33 User:Coffee/Status sleeping... will return to task shortly
- 13:0213:02, 18 December 2019 diff hist −45 Max Blumberg removing violation of WP:CAT/R - do not readd without consensus
- 12:5512:55, 18 December 2019 diff hist −52 Max Blumberg →Biography: after a thorough review of the sources provided (including NYT via timesmachine) it is clear this assertion is is not backed up by the sources, and it is a clear violation of WP:LABEL as it has not been widely used by reliable sources to describe the subject - do not readd without consensus
- 12:2712:27, 18 December 2019 diff hist +52 Misplaced Pages:WikiProject Deletion sorting/Women Listing Misplaced Pages:Articles for deletion/Sabrina Sabbagh.
- 12:2712:27, 18 December 2019 diff hist +52 Misplaced Pages:Articles for deletion/Log/2019 December 18 Adding Misplaced Pages:Articles for deletion/Sabrina Sabbagh.
- 12:2712:27, 18 December 2019 diff hist +52 Misplaced Pages:WikiProject Deletion sorting/Journalism Listing Misplaced Pages:Articles for deletion/Sabrina Sabbagh.
- 12:2712:27, 18 December 2019 diff hist +2,781 N Misplaced Pages:Articles for deletion/Sabrina Sabbagh Creating deletion discussion page for Sabrina Sabbagh.
- 12:2712:27, 18 December 2019 diff hist +52 Misplaced Pages:WikiProject Deletion sorting/News media Listing Misplaced Pages:Articles for deletion/Sabrina Sabbagh.
- 12:2712:27, 18 December 2019 diff hist +1,354 N User talk:Infoandnews4u Notification: nomination of Sabrina Sabbagh at articles for deletion.
- 12:0112:01, 18 December 2019 diff hist +1,178 User talk:Patapsco913 →Discontinue violations of BLP: new section
- 11:3711:37, 18 December 2019 diff hist −558 List of Jewish American businesspeople in media clear BLP violation... first ref does not back up listing here... second ref used is incredibly not reliable (and appears to be primary at best), and does not indicate Shell self-identifies as this (a violation of UNDUE, BLPCAT and LABEL)... do not re-add this (WP:BLPREMOVE)
- 11:3011:30, 18 December 2019 diff hist −69 Jeff Shell removing clear WP:BLPCAT violations... do NOT readd without consensus
- 11:2611:26, 18 December 2019 diff hist −501 Brian L. Roberts another example of UNDUE weight being applied to this BLP for something the subject does not clearly self identify as, using nowhere close to a reliable enough source for this claim... A WP:LABEL violation as well as this has not been widely used by reliable sources to describe the subject.... removing categories that violate WP:BLPCAT as well - do not readd without consensus
- 11:1511:15, 18 December 2019 diff hist −22 Brian L. Roberts →Maccabiah Games: removing BLP violation that is not backed up by the sources provided - do not readd this
- 11:0811:08, 18 December 2019 diff hist −604 Brian L. Roberts →Personal life: the source does not back up the claim that he wants them to "embrace" such a heratige... nor does the source confer that the subject publically self-identifies this way (if anything the source shows Roberts keeps his private life private)... it is also UNDUE to be mentioning this on a BLP especially when dealing with his minor children... on top of that, the source also clearly shows that not all of his kids participated in this... - do not readd this without consensus
 |