This is an old revision of this page, as edited by 70.177.90.39 (talk) at 00:17, 15 June 2005. The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.
Revision as of 00:17, 15 June 2005 by 70.177.90.39 (talk)(diff) ← Previous revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff) Shortcut- ]
In order to get more input from the Misplaced Pages community on important questions, it is sometimes useful to conduct a survey of community opinion. This page lists surveys or polls that are currently being held on various talk pages.
You may also wish to see Misplaced Pages:Requested moves which is a list of active page move discussions.
Dispute resolution (Requests) |
---|
Tips |
Content disputes |
Conduct disputes |
Instructions for listing surveys
Please add new opinion surveys to the list under the appropriate heading. Add a short description of what the survey is about. Note the starting date of the survey and the date the survey will end, if applicable.
After a survey period ends, it may be removed from the list (however, it should remain for at least a short time after the survey ends, to allow anyone interested to view the results). If no closing date is indicated, the survey may be removed from the list when it appears the question is no longer being actively considered. Survey lists are not archived here; to find older surveys and polls, consult this page's history.
Purpose of surveys
Surveys may be used as part of dispute resolution, or to solicit opinions before making significant changes. They can be useful in developing consensus when community opinion is not immediately obvious in normal discussion. For example, a survey may bring in opinions from people who agree with one position, but don't join the discussion because they don't feel they have anything original to add.
For ideas on designing a survey, see Misplaced Pages:Survey guidelines. The results of a survey are not binding, and may be subject to interpretation. A survey may sometimes be called a poll, and it may involve voting for different options, but it is not the same thing as an election. For information on elections related to Misplaced Pages, see Misplaced Pages:Elections.
Opinion surveys should be used to determine whether a consensus exists, not to decide which side "wins". Successful surveys and polls generate consensus, because some people who disagree will nevertheless recognize and accept the consensus opinion of the community.
Current surveys
Most recent at top of each section. No signatures, please.
Policies and requirements
- Misplaced Pages:Stub types for deletion - A process for the deletion of stub templates and stub categories in one go set up by the Misplaced Pages:WikiProject Stub sorting. Last chance to comment before things start.
- Misplaced Pages talk:Remove personal attacks - the status of RPA is under debate; some people swear by it, others intensely dislike it. Please give your opinion on whether this should be policy, guideline, discouraged or forbidden.
- Misplaced Pages:Wikirules proposal & Misplaced Pages:Simplified_Ruleset - An attempt to simplify Misplaced Pages policy.
- Misplaced Pages:Arbitration policy/Proposals - discuss changes to arbitration policy here.
- Misplaced Pages:Categorization policy is a bold proposal to make WP categorization more consistent and stable.
- Misplaced Pages:Arbitration policy/Proposed amendment revote - attempting to solve the fiasco of Misplaced Pages:Arbitration policy/Proposed amendment ratification vote.
- Misplaced Pages:Votes for deletion/Policy consensus - contains a number of discussions meant to establish consensus over the suitability (or lack thereof) for certain groups of articles in Misplaced Pages.
- Misplaced Pages:Manual of Style (biographies)/Survey on Style-Prefixed Honorary Titles/Ratification - Should biographical entries in the Misplaced Pages follow the convention: "The formal style of address should always be provided in the introductory paragraph of the article, but only after the name is provided, and not otherwise prefixed." Please see Discussion of the initial vote for more information. Ratification votes will be collected through May 28.
Software and features
- Misplaced Pages:Proposal for intuitive table editor and namespace - Opinions wanted on a proposal for 1. A new Table: namespace, to unclutter the wiki markup and treat tables more like images. 2. New dedicated table editor(s) that will present the table as formatted but allow editing of individual cells, for ease of use in the wiki way.
Conventions and formatting
- Misplaced Pages:Language order poll - desired language order of multilingual lists
- Misplaced Pages:Standardize spellings - advocates standardization of spellings on Misplaced Pages.
- Misplaced Pages:Template standardisation – voting will end Sunday 1 May 2005 at 23:59
Article content and structure, and WikiProjects
- Talk:Feces Should Feces have a photograph of feces?
- Misplaced Pages:Poképrosal#Poll: WP:FICT and Pokemon - should the guidelines at WP:FICT be applied to Pokémon characters?
- Misplaced Pages talk:WikiProject Arcade games/Infobox - vote on best infobox to use throughout arcade game articles.
- Talk:List of famous gay, lesbian or bisexual people - vote on proposed changes to policy for inclusion in list
- Vote on a separate namespace for portals and lists Should lists and portals have their own namespaces? See also Misplaced Pages:Portalspace
- Talk:List of occultists#Poll: Inclusion of Biblical figures - Should Jesus, Solomon, and the Three Wise Men be listed as occultists? Attempt to settle a long-running revert war.
- Talk:Flemish Interest - Can a template be made for articles on political parties be made, containing a logical sequence of (neutral) facts, such as founding members, important dates, participation in elections, political spectrum to which the party belongs, etc... This so that NPOV disputes can be reduced significantly.
- Talk:Autofellatio#Poll: Should the image be shown inline, or as a link? - Autofellatio is oral sex performed by a (very limber, very determined) man on his own penis. The rest, you can work out for yourself.
- Template talk:Europe#Poll: Which items should be listed? - several polls regarding whether Kazakhstan, Georgia, Armenia, and Akrotiri and Dhekelia should be listed on Template:Europe. Keep scrolling way down to see all items to be voted for. No end date (polls will be closed when consensus is reached).
- Talk:Germany#Straw_poll - Long section on German history, vs. a shorter one. Attempt to help settle a long-running revert war, wider input would be appreciated.
- Talk:Theistic realism#Poll: which version is better? - Of the two versions of the article listed, which is better from an NPOV and research standpoint? Attempt to settle a long-running edit war.
Article title/move surveys
- Misplaced Pages talk:Naming conventions (use English)#Proposal and straw poll regarding place names with diacritical marks - An attempt to go from the Zürich to Zurich debate to a more comprehensive policy on diacriticals in place names.
- Misplaced Pages talk:Naming conventions (Chinese)/NPOV/Taiwan vs. ROC & Misplaced Pages talk:Naming conventions (Chinese)/NPOV - A vote on revising Misplaced Pages:Naming conventions (Chinese)#Political NPOV
- Talk:Zürich - Should this article be moved from Zürich to Zurich? This is a new poll after an inconclusive previous straw poll.
- Talk:Macedonian Slavs - Should the predominate ethnicity of the Republic of Macedonia be called "Macedonians" or "Macedonian Slavs"?
- Also check Misplaced Pages:Requested moves
Ongoing surveys
Deletions
- Votes for deletion - Article deletion
- Votes for undelete - Article undeletion
- Templates for deletion
- Categories for deletion
- Images for deletion
- Redirects for deletion
Article Improvement
Comments but no voting
- Peer review - review of articles, usually before submitting them as Featured article candidates
Other ongoing surveys
- Requested moves - moving articles to a new title
- Votes for adminship
- Requests for Comments - comments on article disputes, the behavior of editors, the behavior of administrators, and editor's user names