Misplaced Pages

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Samiharris (talk | contribs) at 23:28, 22 September 2007 (→Departures from the board: adding details on John Byrne, quoting MF). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Overstock.com (Nasdaq: OSTK) is an online retailer headquartered in Cottonwood Heights, Utah. Nearby Salt Lake City is commonly listed as the company's location in corporate filings and news accounts.

Business model

Overstock.com is an online E-commerce marketplace, in which Internet users purchase surplus and returned, as well as new merchandise. Overstock.com was founded in 1997 under the name D2: Discounts Direct, and changed its name to Overstock.com in 1999.

Overstock went public in May of 2002. From December 2004 with a high stock price of 77, its price fell to 28 by December 2005. Its CEO became convinced that this was due to naked short selling. Roughly 60% of Overstock.com merchandise is sold on behalf of third parties participating in Overstock's Partner Program - which mostly include wholesalers but includes some manufacturers, and smaller retailers that have standing business relationships with Overstock.com. Overstock's Partner Program began in 2000 and has over 700 partners. The remainder is purchased by or manufactured specifically for Overstock.com. The company also purports to manage the inventory supply for other retailers, and says that it enables small retailers to purchase stock at below-wholesale prices.

Overstock.com also functions as a marketplace for new merchandise at cut-rate prices.

Overstock.com says its main rivals are eBay, Amazon.com Marketplace and Yahoo! Auctions, however, Overstock's revenues, site traffic and marketshare currently lag far behind eBay and Amazon.

In addition to its direct retail sales, Overstock.com has also offered online auctions on its website since September 24, 2004. The auction services include several features intended to enhance security, social networking and convenience. It has hosted charity auctions to benefit various causes.

For the fiscal year 2006, Overstock suffered a 6% decrease in overall sales and lost over $100 million on less than $800 million in sales.

The company's distinctive television advertisements feature German actress Sabine Ehrenfeld. These advertisements feature double entendres, as they talk about the "O" and the "Big O", which means both "Overstock", and calls to mind "Orgasm".

Anti naked short-selling campaign

The company has received attention stemming from CEO Patrick Byrne's battle against alleged naked short selling of his company's shares. Byrne has said that his company's shares have been attacked by what he describes as "miscreants" in the stock market. Critics maintain that Byrne is seeking to divert attention from Overstock's share price declines and failure to turn a profit.

Byrne sued a hedge fund, Rocker Partners, for libel, unfair business practices and tortuous interference saying it colluded with a research firm, Gradient Analytics, in short-selling the company by paying Gradient Analytics to publish negative reports about Overstock.com and supplying pre-publication copies to Rocker. Petitions for Review by Gradient Analytics and Rocker Partners to the California Supreme Court were rejected in September 2007 , allowing the case to continue to trial. Naked short-selling was not alleged in that suit. A Securities and Exchange Commission investigation of Gradient was dropped in February 2007

Byrne's campaign has been widely criticized, with New York Times columnist Joseph Nocera saying: "Except for a few fellow-traveling Web sites, where Mr. Byrne is viewed as a heroic figure, most people who understand the issue or have looked into it think it's pretty bogus." SEC Chairman Christopher Cox called abusive naked short selling “a fraud that the commission is bound to prevent and to punish.”

In May 2006, Overstock.com received a subpoena from the SEC, requesting information about the company's accounting policies as well as its communications regarding naked short selling. Though Byrne said in a press release that he "celebrated" receiving the subpoena, critics of the company viewed it as an indication of Overstock's mounting troubles. Herb Greenberg, a journalist with Marketwatch.com and CNBC, termed the response "feeble spin control."

Byrne was instrumental in passage of anti naked shortselling legislation in Utah that was repealed in February 2007. Repeal of the legislation led to tension between Byrne and Utah officials. A New York Times report stated that "Utah officials now feel they were snookered by the Overstock C.E.O." and that the affair had damaged Overstock's political influence.

In May 2007, Overstock.com disclosed in an SEC filing that Patrick Byrne been had been personally served with an SEC subpoena one year earlier. Overstock had received a similar subpoena shortly before Byrne, and that subpoena was disclosed. The delay sparked controversy. The investigation of Byrne and Overstock is continuing.

In February 2007, Overstock.com launched a $3.5 billion lawsuit against Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs Group Inc. and other large Wall Street firms, saying the firms "have and continue to participate in a massive illegal stock market manipulation scheme" involving naked short selling. Nocera described the lawsuit as "ridiculous." John Coffee, director of the Center on Corporate Governance at Columbia University Law School, described it as "an extremely unpromising litigation," and said that Overstock "may quickly find out they bit off more than they can chew." Kerry Fields, associate professor of law and business ethics at the University of Southern California, said "Byrne may be able to help set new law if he handles this right." However, Fields said, Byrne's "best approach now is probably to persuade the SEC, which continues to wander around the issue, or the government to serve subpoenas and let them decide whether or not his company was wronged."

Two members of the Overstock.com board of directors, John Fisher and Ray Groves, resigned in protest against the lawsuit.

AntiSocialMedia.net

In January 2007, it was revealed that Judd Bagley, an executive of Overstock.com, was responsible for AntiSocialMedia.net, an (initially) anonymous website which attacked critics of Overstock.com. These critics included journalists, individuals who had criticised Byrne, and a mortgage broker who had aided reporters and federal investigators by finding old documents on the web. Its biggest target was journalist Gary Weiss, and at one point two Google ads had been purchased directing people who searched on Weiss's name to the site. Bagley had previously created similar websites which had been condemned as "crazy and profane attacks" and "conspiracy propaganda" at "The Motley Fool," an online investing website.

Patrick Byrne initially expressed public support of the site. Following identification of Bagley as the site's owner, Byrne stated that the site "receives support from neither myself nor Overstock", but reiterated his support for the site on First Amendment grounds. Bagley also stated that the site is run independently of Overstock.com.

Departures from the board

In July 2006, John J. Byrne, the father of Overstock's chief executive, resigned from the board of directors, rafter a public airing of the elder Byrne's unhappiness with his son's crusade against naked short-selling. John Byrne told the Wall Street Journal that "I can't tell whether this jihad adds to the value of the stock or subtracts from it, but what it does is take from Patrick's time." He told the newspaper that his "headstrong" son has ignored his pleas to drop the fight.

On February 23, 2007, John A. Fisher resigned from the Overstock board of directors. This action, he said explicitly, was "precipitated by disagreement with the company's pursuit of the lawsuit against the Prime Brokers."

On May 24, 2007, Ray Groves likewise resigned from the board. In his letter, he too said this related "to the Company's prime broker suit."

Motley Fool analyst Seth Jayson suggested that the directors may have departedg to avoid legal liability for the company's accounting or because of the actions of Judd Bagley, Overstock's director of communications. Bagley operates antisocialmedia.net, which attacks critics of Overstock.

References

1. What's With That Overstock.com Ad? Feb. 28, 2005
2. Is Overstock.com's CEO Completely Insane? 2005-12-06
3. Oh! Oh! Oh ... It's Another 'Sally' Ad November 13, 2004
5. Overstock's Campaign Of Menace February 25, 2006
6. SEC kills probe of Gradient February 14, 2007
7. Appeals court sides with Overstock.com May 31, 2007
8. New Crusade for Master of Overstock June 10, 2006
9. Floyd Norris, The New York Times (June 14,2007). "S.E.C. Ends Decades-Old Price Limits on Short Selling". {{cite web}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)
10. Overstock goes overboard May 10, 2006
11. Revisiting Overstock.com and Utah March 10, 2007
12. Company Byrne-d on probe report May 11, 2007
13. Appeals court sides with Overstock.com May 31, 2007
14. Overstock sues brokers Feb. 3, 2007
15. Overstock CEO reflects on Cramer debacle March 28, 2007
16. ”Overstock’s Suit Spurs Board Exit,” Bloomberg News Service, Feb. 24, 2007
17. “Overstock Director Groves Resigns Because of Broker Lawsuit,” Bloomberg News Service, Bloomberg News Service, May 25, 2007
18. ^ Mitchell, Dan. "Flames Flare Over Naked Shorts." New York Times, January 20, 2007, C1.
19. ^ Roddy Boyd, The New York Post (Jan. 2, 2007). "Overstock.com Lashes Out at Critics on the Web". {{cite web}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)
20. ^ Antilla, Susan. "Overstock Blames with Creepy Strategy". Bloomberg News, February 21, 2007
21. Jayson, Seth. "The Worst Stock for 2007: Overstock." The Motley Fool, December 21, 2006.
22. Susan Antilla, Bloomberg News Service (Feb. 21, 2007). "Overstock Blames With Creepy Strategy". {{cite web}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)
23. “Overstock.com chairman mulls stepping down,” the Associated Press, March 3, 2006
24. Letter to Patrick Byrne from John A. Fisher, Overstock.com SEC filing
25. Letter from Ray Groves to Patrick Byrne dated May 24, 2007, Overstock.com SEC filing
26. "Another Day, Another Departing Director," by Seth Jayson, The Motley Fool, May 25, 2007

External links

• Overstock.com
• Five-year stock price

• Companies based in Salt Lake City
• Companies based in Utah
• Online retail companies of the United States