Doping in baseball

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by 207.156.51.71 (talk) at 14:35, 14 December 2007 (→Effects on health). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Revision as of 14:35, 14 December 2007 by 207.156.51.71 (talk) (→Effects on health)(diff) ← Previous revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

The question of steroid use in baseball has been an ongoing issue for Major League Baseball since the mid 1990s and into the 21st century. Steroids are performance-enhancing drugs which have been banned from baseball.

While rumors of drug use by players have persisted for decades, the controversy over steroids has grown considerably due to the drastic rise in home runs since 1995. During the decade that followed the 1994 Major League Baseball strike, Mark McGwire, Sammy Sosa, and Barry Bonds each surpassed Roger Maris' home run record, which had stood largely unchallenged for over 30 years.

"The Steroids Era"

Cover of *Juiced*; Jose Canseco's book documenting the impact of steroids in baseball

In a 2002 interview with ESPN's Dan Patrick, author and commentator Bob Costas referred to the post-labor dispute era as the "Steroids Era," noting that while there had been only eighteen 50+ home run seasons in Major League Baseball to that point, there had been twenty two since the 1995 season. While many theories might explain the dramatic increase in home runs, including the "juiced ball" theory, the replacement of pitcher-friendly parks with hitter-friendly venues, and the dilution of the pitching ranks via expansion, steroid use remains the most commonly cited explanation for the power surge.

Several players have come forward in recent years to suggest that drug use is rampant in baseball. David Wells stated that "25 to 40 percent of all Major Leaguers are juiced". José Canseco stated on 60 Minutes and in his tell-all book Juiced that as many as 85% of players used steroids, and that he credited steroid use for his entire career. Ken Caminiti revealed that he won the 1996 NL MVP award while on steroids.

Effects on health

On February 17, 2003, Baltimore Orioles pitching prospect Steve Bechler collapsed and died on the practice field at spring training of heat stroke. The medical examiner ruled that the over-the-counter herbal supplement (not a steroid) Ephedra played a significant role in Bechler's death. One week later, Bud Selig banned all minor league players from using Ephedra. Major League players were not held to the same rules.

Former player Ken Caminiti, the 1996 National League MVP, detailed the health consequences he suffered from steroid use, telling Sports Illustrated that "his testicles shrank and retracted; doctors found his body had virtually stopped producing its own testosterone and that his level of the hormone had fallen to 20% of normal." Caminiti later died as a direct result of substance abuse.

The chase for 62

During the 1998 season, Sosa and McGwire competed in a race to set the home run mark previously set by Roger Maris. By the season's end, Sosa had eclipsed the record with 66 home runs while McGwire set the single season record by hitting 70 home runs. While the chase proved to be a watershed event in baseball's recovery following the 1994 players strike, both players were also dogged by suspicion over their use of supplements—In McGwire's case, androstenedione and in Sosa's case creatine.

The next year the two were in a similar race and McGwire hit 65 homers and Sosa 63. By 2001 Bonds was hitting home runs at an incredible pace. Bonds would break McGwire's record by hitting 73 home runs. It seemed unlikely to many observers that he could continue hitting home runs at such a pace at his age (Bonds turned 37 during the 2001 season) without some sort of supplementary help.

Congressional investigation

The nutrition center BALCO, was accused of distributing steroids to many star players, most notably Bonds. Baseball has attempted to toughen its drug policy, beginning a plan of random tests to players. Players such as Ryan Franklin and others were handed suspensions as short as ten days. However, a Congressional panel continued to argue that the penalties were not tough enough, and took action.

Many top players, including Rafael Palmeiro, McGwire, Sosa, Canseco and Curt Schilling were summoned on March 17, 2005 to testify in front of Congress. During the session, Canseco admitted his steroid use which he claims was perfectly acceptable during the 1980s and early 90's. Palmeiro denied all steroid use during his career, while McGwire refused to discuss the issue, repeatedly stating "I'm not here to discuss the past."

Palmeiro, who was listed in Canseco's book as a user along with McGwire, denied Canseco's claims and told Congress that those claims were absolutely erroneous. The committee had stated that baseball had failed to confront the problems of performance-enhancing drugs. The committee was disturbed by the accepted use of steroids by athletes because it created a bad persona of players who in many cases are role models to many of the aspiring youth. During the testimonies the players called to Congress offered their condolences for youthful athletes who had committed suicide after using performance-enhancing drugs.

Five months after the Congressional hearing, information came out indicating Palmeiro had already tested positive for steroids and knew it when he spoke before Congress. He appealed but the test results and ensuing suspension were upheld. Mark McGwire, whose credentials could arguably satisfy expectations for first ballot Hall of Fame election, was denied election in his first year, with many voters citing McGwire's refusal to speak at the Congressional Investigation.

BALCO scandal

During this period, Bonds' trainer, Greg Anderson and BALCO head Victor Conte (also connected to Jason Giambi and Canseco), were not subpoenaed in California by the House Committee for investigation.

As a result of pressure from Congress, baseball and the Major League Baseball Players Association began applying stricter regulations and applied a zero tolerance policy in correspondence to performance enhancing drugs. On August 1, 2005, Palmeiro tested positive for performing enhancing substances and was suspended ten days. Once thought to be a lock for the Baseball Hall of Fame as one of only four players to have both 3,000 hits and 500 home runs, Palmeiro's legacy has now been called into question. Palmeiro's career would quickly die as he would retire soon after his suspension was lifted.

The Bonds controversy continues especially now that he has surpassed the All time Home Run record. The media continues to pressure Bonds with questions over the issue. In 2006, the book Game of Shadows was published offering researched claims that Bonds' trainer was providing illegal performance enhancers to Bonds and other athletes. Bonds had admitted that he did use a clear substance and lotion given to him by his trainer but had no idea that they were any sort of performance enhancers. Bonds claimed that to his knowledge that the substances given to him were legal to treat his arthritis.

2006 Baseball steroids investigation

Main article: Mitchell Report (baseball)

On March 29, 2006, ESPN learned that former Senator and Disney chairman George J. Mitchell would head an investigation into past steroid use by Major League Baseball players, including San Francisco Giants outfielder Barry Bonds. Mitchell was appointed by baseball commissioner Bud Selig in the wake of controversy over the book Game of Shadows, which chronicles alleged extensive use of performance-enhancing drugs, including several different types of steroids and growth hormone by Bonds. Selig has acknowledged that the book, by way of calling attention to the issue, is in part responsible for the league's decision to commission an independent investigation. A report of the investigation was released on December 13, 2007 and named more than 50 former and current baseball players.

Selig did not refer to Bonds by name in announcing the investigation, and many past and present players will be investigated. Mitchell will take on a role similar to that of John Dowd, who investigated Pete Rose's alleged gambling in the late 1980s.

On June 6, 2006, Arizona Diamondbacks relief pitcher Jason Grimsley's home was searched by federal agents. He later admitted to using human growth hormone, steroids, and amphetamines. According to court documents, Grimsley failed a baseball drug test in 2003 and allegedly named other current and former players who also used drugs. On June 7, 2006 he was released by the Diamondbacks, reportedly at his own request.

MLB Steroid Policy

Over most of the course of Major League Baseball, steroid testing was never a major issue. However, after the BALCO steroid scandal, which involved allegations that top baseball players had used illegal performance-enhancing drugs, Major League Baseball finally decided to issue harsher penalties for steroid users. The policy, which was accepted by Major League Baseball players and owners, was issued at the start of the 2005 season and went as follows:

A first positive test resulted in a suspension of 10 games, a second positive test resulted in a suspension of 30 games, the third positive test resulted in a suspension of 60 games, the fourth positive test resulted in a suspension of one full year, and a fifth positive test resulted in a penalty at the commissioner’s discretion. Players were tested at least once per year, with the chance that several players could be tested many times per year. (See: List of Major League Baseball players suspended for steroids)

This program replaced the previous steroid testing program under which, for example, no player was even suspended in 2004. Under the old policy, which was established in 2002, a first-time offense would only result in treatment for the player, and the player would not even be named. The 2005 agreement changed this rule so that first-time offenders were named and suspended.

In November 2005, MLB owners and players approved even tougher penalties for positive tests than the ones in place during the 2005 season. Under the new rules, a first positive test would result in a 50-game suspension, a second positive test would result in a 100-game suspension, and a third positive test would result in a lifetime suspension from MLB.

These new penalties are much harsher than the previous ones. The new steroid policy finally brings MLB closer in line with international rules, as well as with the NFL, which has long taken a tough stance on those caught using steroids.

MLB's previous reluctance to take a hard line on drugs (as many other sports featured far stricter testing and penalties) was widely seen as one of the main reasons why baseball has been dropped from the Olympics, effective in 2012.

On March 30, 2006, Bud Selig launched an investigation on the alleged steroid use by players such as Barry Bonds, Tom Moglia, and Gary Sheffield as the weight of books like Game of Shadows emerged. The inquiry into steroids' use in baseball is expected to go back no further than 2002, when the MLB started testing players for performance-enhancing drugs.

References

Baseball, steroids and the truth, Dan Patrick, ESPN, June 3, 2002
Boomer Bombshell, Sports Illustrated.com, February 27, 2003
Canseco credits steroids for his career, MSNBC.com, February 14,2005
^ Totally Juiced, Sports Illustrated.com, June 3, 2002
Medical examiner: Ephedra a factor in Bechler death, USAToday, March 13, 2003
nytimes.com, Opponents Don't Fault McGwire For Pills, New York Times, August 25, 1998.
time.com, Crazy for Creatine, accessed May 23, 2007.
^ Palmeiro's shameful end, Yahoo Sports, August 1, 2006
He won't say: McGwire deflects panel's questions about steroid use, San Francisco Chronicle, March 18, 2005
Davidoff, Ken (2007-12-13). "Many high-profile names will make Mitchell Report". Newsday.
Duff Wilson (2007-12-13). "Baseball Braces for Steroid Report From Mitchell". The New York Times. Retrieved 2007-12-13. {{cite news}}: Unknown parameter |coauthor= ignored (|author= suggested) (help)

Misplaced Pages