Misplaced Pages

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by THF (talk | contribs) at 14:29, 27 February 2009 (Reverted to revision 273435150 by THF. using TW). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these messages) No issues specified. Please specify issues, or remove this template. (Learn how and when to remove this message)

The Business Plot (also the Plot Against FDR and the White House Putsch) conspiracy theory alleges that there was a political conspiracy in 1933 where wealthy businessmen and corporations plotted a coup d’état to overthrow United States President Franklin D. Roosevelt. In 1934, retired Marine Corps Major General Smedley Butler testified to the McCormack-Dickstein Congressional Committee and alleged that a group of men had approached him as part of a plot to overthrow Roosevelt in a military coup. One of the alleged plotters, Gerald MacGuire, vehemently denied any such plot. In their final report, the Congressional committee supported Butler's allegations of the existence of the plot, but no prosecutions or further investigations followed, and historians and contemporary journalists largely rejected the idea that any such plan was near execution.

Background

On July 17, 1932, thousands of World War I veterans converged on Washington, D.C., set up tent camps, and demanded immediate payment of bonuses due them according to the Adjusted Service Certificate Law of 1924. This "Bonus Army" was led by Walter W. Waters, a former Army sergeant. The Army was encouraged by an appearance from retired Marine Corps Major General Smedley Butler, who had considerable influence over the veterans, being one of the most popular military figures of the time. A few days after Butler's arrival, President Herbert Hoover ordered the marchers removed, and their camps were destroyed by US Army cavalry troops under the command of General Douglas MacArthur.

Butler, although a self-described Republican, responded by supporting Roosevelt in that year's election.

In a 1995 History Today article Clayton Cramer argued that the devastation of the Great Depression had caused many Americans to question the foundations of liberal democracy. "Many traditionalists, here and in Europe, toyed with the ideas of Fascism and National Socialism; many liberals dallied with Socialism and Communism." Cramer argues that this explains why some American business leaders viewed fascism as a viable system to both preserve their interests and end the economic woes of the Depression.

Timeline of events

This section is in list format but may read better as prose. You can help by converting this section, if appropriate. Editing help is available.

McCormack-Dickstein Committee

The Committee began examining evidence a year later, on November 20, 1934. On November 24 the committee released a statement detailing the testimony it had heard about the plot and its preliminary findings. On February 15, 1935, the committee submitted to the House of Representatives its final report.

During the McCormack-Dickstein Committee hearings, Butler testified that through MacGuire and Bill Doyle, who was then the department commander of the American Legion in Massachusetts, the conspirators attempted to recruit him to lead a coup, promising him an army of 500,000 men for a march on Washington, D.C., $30 million in financial backing, and generous media spin control. Butler testified that the pretext for the coup would be that the president's health was failing.

Despite Butler's support for Roosevelt in the election, and his reputation as a strong critic of capitalism, Butler said the plotters felt his good reputation and popularity were vital in attracting support amongst the general public, and saw him as easier to manipulate than others.

Butler said that Al Smith, Roosevelt's political foe and former governor of New York, and Irénée du Pont, a chemical industrialist, were the financial and organizational backbone of the plot. Butler stated that once the conspirators were in power, they would protect Roosevelt from other plotters.

Given a successful coup, Butler said that the plan was for him to have held near-absolute power in the newly created position of "Secretary of General Affairs," while Roosevelt would have assumed a figurehead role.

Reaction to Butler's testimony by the media and business elite was dismissive or hostile. The majority of media outlets, including The New York Times, Philadelphia Post, and Time Magazine ridiculed or downplayed his claims, saying they lacked evidence. After the committee concluded, The New York Times and Time Magazine rejected the conclusions of the committee.

Those accused of the plotting by Butler all denied any involvement. MacGuire was the only figure identified by Butler who testified before the committee. Others involved were actually called to appear to testify, though never were forced to testify.

Committee members

This article contains a list of miscellaneous information. Please relocate any relevant information into other sections or articles.

From the McCormack-Dickstein Committee files found at wikisource.

• John W. McCormack, Massachusetts, Chairman. McCormack served as Speaker of the House of Representatives from 1961 until 1971.
• Samuel Dickstein New York, Vice Chairman.
• Carl M. Weideman, Michigan. Democratic Congressman from March 4, 1933-January 3, 1935.
• Charles Kramer, California. Democratic Congressman from March 4, 1933-January 3, 1943.
• Thomas A. Jenkins, Ohio. Republican Congressman from March 4, 1925-January 3, 1959.
• James Willis Taylor, Tennessee. Republican Congressman from March 4, 1919-November 14, 1939.
• Ulysses Samuel Guyer, Kansas. Republican Congressman from March 4, 1927-June 5, 1943.
• Thomas W. Hardwick, Counsel.

Final resolution

The Congressional committee report confirmed Butler's testimony (emphasis added):

In the last few weeks of the committee's official life it received evidence showing that certain persons had made an attempt to establish a fascist government in this country...There is no question that these attempts were discussed, were planned, and might have been placed in execution when and if the financial backers deemed it expedient.

This committee received evidence from Maj. Gen Smedley D. Butler (retired), twice decorated by the Congress of the United States. He testified before the committee as to conversations with one Gerald C. MacGuire in which the latter is alleged to have suggested the formation of a fascist army under the leadership of General Butler.

MacGuire denied these allegations under oath, but your committee was able to verify all the pertinent statements made by General Butler, with the exception of the direct statement suggesting the creation of the organization. This, however, was corroborated in the correspondence of MacGuire with his principal, Robert Sterling Clark, of New York City, while MacGuire was abroad studying the various forms of veterans organizations of Fascist character.

Partial corroboration of Butler's story

This section is in list format but may read better as prose. You can help by converting this section, if appropriate. Editing help is available.

Portions of Gen. Butler's story were corroborated by:

• Veterans of Foreign Wars commander James E. Van Zandt. "Less than two months" after General Butler warned him, he said, "he had been approached by ‘agents of Wall Street’ to lead a Fascist dictatorship in the United States under the guise of a ‘Veterans Organization’ ".
• Captain Samuel Glazier—testifying under oath about plans of a plot to install a dictatorship in the United States.
• Reporter Paul Comly French, reporter for the Philadelphia Record and the New York Evening Post.

Historians’ treatment of the Business Plot

This section is in list format but may read better as prose. You can help by converting this section, if appropriate. Editing help is available.

These reasons were proposed to explain why the Business Plot did not become a cause célèbre:

• The story embarrassed politically influential business people, who felt it best to deflect attention from themselves.
• In 1934, newspapers were controlled by an élite — according to then-Interior Secretary Harold L. Ickes, 82 per cent of daily newspapers monopolised their communities; the media down-played Gen. Butler's testimony to protect the interests of advertisers and their owners.
• Some of President Roosevelt's advisors were plotters, and downplayed the matter, avoiding exposure.
• In the BBC Radio Document program, The Whitehouse Coup, John Buchanan suggests President Roosevelt stopped the investigation for a political deal: "The investigations mysteriously turned to vapor when it comes time to call them to testify. FDR's main interest was getting the New Deal passed, and so he struck a deal in which it was agreed that the plotters would walk free if Wall Street would back off of their opposition to the New Deal and let FDR do what he wanted".

Doubters of Gen. Butler's testimony claimed it lacked evidence:

• Robert F. Burk: "At their core, the accusations probably consisted of a mixture of actual attempts at influence peddling by a small core of financiers with ties to veterans organizations and the self-serving accusations of Butler against the enemies of his pacifist and populist causes."

• Hans Schmidt: "Even if Butler was telling the truth, as there seems little reason to doubt, there remains the unfathomable problem of MacGuire's motives and veracity. He may have been working both ends against the middle, as Butler at one point suspected. In any case, MacGuire emerged from the HUAC hearings as an inconsequential trickster whose base dealings could not possibly be taken alone as verifying such a momentous undertaking. If he was acting as an intermediary in a genuine probe, or as agent provocateur sent to fool Butler, his employers were at least clever enough to keep their distance and see to it that he self-destructed on the witness stand . . . MacGuire repeatedly perjured himself . . . Butler may have blown the whistle on an incipient conspiracy. . . . "

• Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr.: "Most people agreed with Mayor La Guardia of New York in dismissing it as a ‘cocktail putsch’ . . . As for the House committee, headed by John McCormack of Massachusetts, it declared itself "able to verify all the pertinent statements made by General Butler", except for MacGuire's direct proposal to him, and it considered this more or less confirmed by MacGuire's European reports. No doubt, MacGuire did have some wild scheme in mind, though the gap between contemplation and execution was considerable, and it can hardly be supposed that the Republic was in much danger".

• James E. Sargent reviewing The Plot to Seize the White House, by Jules Archer: "Thus, Butler (and Archer) assumed that the existence of a financially-backed plot meant that fascism was imminent, and that the planners represented a widespread and coherent group, having both the intent and the capacity to execute their ideas. So, when his testimony was criticized, and even ridiculed, in the media, and ignored in Washington, Butler saw (and Archer sees) conspiracy everywhere. Instead, it is plausible to conclude that the honest and straightforward, but intellectually and politically unsophisticated, Butler perceived in simplistic terms what were, in fact, complex trends and events. Thus, he leaped to the simplistic conclusion that the President and the Republic were in mortal danger. In essence, Archer swallowed his hero whole".

The 2007 BBC radio documentary The White House Coup reported on the Business Plot.

Bibliography

• Archer, Jules (1973, pub.2007). The Plot to Seize the White House. Skyhorse Publishing. ISBN 1-60239-036-3. {{cite book}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)
• Schlesinger Jr., Arthur M. (2003). The Politics of Upheaval: 1935-1936, The Age of Roosevelt, Volume III (The Age of Roosevelt). Mariner Books. ISBN 0-618-34087-4.
• Schmidt, Hans (1998). Maverick Marine: General Smedley D. Butler and the Contradictions of American Military History. University Press of Kentucky. ISBN 0-8131-0957-4. Excerpts of Schmidt's book dealing with the plot are available online.

References

1. Schlesinger, p. 85 " In March 1934, the House of Representatives authorized an investigation into "un-American" activities by a special committee headed by John W. McCormack of Massachusetts and Samuel Dickstein of New York. In the following months the McCormack-Dickstein Committee inquired into Nazi operations in America, exposed William Dudley Pelley and the Silver Shirts, looked into Smedley Butler's allegations, and called the Communist leaders up for testimony. Its manner of investigation commanded special respect. McCormack used competent investigators and employed as committee counsel a former Georgia senator with a good record on civil liberties. Most of the examination of witnesses was carried on in executive sessions. In public sessions, witnesses were free to consult counsel. Throughout, McCormack was eager to avoid hit-and-run accusation and unsubstantiated testimony. The result was an almost uniquely scrupulous investigation in a highly sensitive area."
2. Schlesinger, p. 85 "As for McCormack's House committee, it declared itself "able to verify all the pertinent statements made by General Butler" except for MacGuire's direct proposal to him, and it considered this more or less confirmed by MacGuire's European reports."
3. ^ Burk, Robert F. (1990). The Corporate State and the Broker State: The Du Ponts and American National Politics, 1925-1940. Harvard University Press. ISBN 0-674-17272-8.
4. ^ Schmidt p. 226, 228, 229, 230
5. ^ Schlesinger, p. 83
6. ^ Sargent, James E. (1974). "Review of: The Plot to Seize the White House, by Jules Archer". The History Teacher. 8 (1): 151–152. {{cite journal}}: Unknown parameter |month= ignored (help)
7. ^ Author unknown (December 3 1934). "Plot Without Plotters". Time Magazine. {{cite journal}}: |author= has generic name (help); Check date values in: |date= (help)
   Author unknown (November 21 1934). "Gen. Butler Bares 'Fascist Plot' To Seize Government by Force; Says Bond Salesman, as Representative of Wall St. Group, Asked Him to Lead Army of 500,000 in March on Capital -- Those Named Make Angry Denials -- Dickstein Gets Charge". New York Times: 1. {{cite journal}}: |author= has generic name (help); Check date values in: |date= (help); Author unknown (November 22 1934). "Credulity Unlimited". New York Times: 20. {{cite journal}}: |author= has generic name (help); Check date values in: |date= (help)
   Philadelphia Record, November 21 and 22, 1934;Time Magazine, 25 February 1935: "Also last week the House Committee on Un-American Activities purported to report that a two-month investigation had convinced it that General Butler's story of a Fascist march on Washington was alarmingly true."
   New York Times February 16 1935. p. 1, "Asks Laws To Curb Foreign Agitators; Committee In Report To House Attacks Nazis As The Chief Propagandists In Nation. State Department Acts Checks Activities Of An Italian Consul -- Plan For March On Capital Is Held Proved. Asks Laws To Curb Foreign Agitators, "Plan for “March” Recalled. It also alleged that definite proof had been found that the much publicized Fascist march on Washington, which was to have been led by Major. Gen. Smedley D. Butler, retired, according to testimony at a hearing, was actually contemplated. The committee recalled testimony by General Butler, saying he had testified that Gerald C. MacGuire had tried to persuade him to accept the leadership of a Fascist army."
8. ^ Schmidt, p. 219 "Declaring himself a "Hoover-for-Ex-President Republican," Smedley used the bonus issue and the army's use of gas in routing the (Bonus Expeditionary Force) B.E.F -recalling infamous gas warfare during the Great War- to disparage Hoover during the 1932 general elections. He came out for the Democrats "despite the fact that my family for generations has been Republican," and shared the platform when Republican Senator George W. Norris opened a coast-to-coast stump for FDR in Philadelphia....Butler was pleased with the election results that saw Hoover defeated; although he admitted that he had exerted himself in the campaign more "to get rid of Hoover than to put in Roosevelt," and to "square a debt." FDR, his old Haiti ally, was a "nice fellow" and might make a good president, but Smedley did not expect much influence in the new administration."
9. Clayton E. Cramer, "An American Coup d'État?" in History Today, November 1995
10. Wikisource: McCormack-Dickstein Committee report, pg. 1
11. Wikisource: McCormack-Dickstein Committee report
12. Wikisource: McCormack-Dickstein Committee report
13. Archer, p. 178
14. Wikisource: McCormack-Dickstein Committee report, pg. 20
15. Wikisource: McCormack-Dickstein Committee report
16. Wikisource: McCormack-Dickstein Committee report
17. Wikisource: McCormack-Dickstein Committee report, pg. 3
18. Wikisource: McCormack-Dickstein Committee report, pg. 10
19. Archer, p. 153
20. Wikisource: McCormack-Dickstein Committee report, pg. 3 and pg. 20
21. Wikisource: McCormack-Dickstein Committee report, pg. 5
22. Archer, p. 139
23. Wikisource: McCormack-Dickstein Committee report, public statement on preliminary findings, Novermber 24, 1934
24. Archer, p. 189
25. ^ Archer, p. x (Foreword)
26. National Archives: The Special Committee on Un-American Activities Authorized To Investigate Nazi Propaganda and Certain Other Propaganda Activities (73A-F30.1) "The (McCormack-Dickstein Committee) conducted public and executive hearings intermittently between April 26 and December 29, 1934, in Washington, DC; New York; Chicago; Los Angeles; Newark; and Asheville, NC, examining hundreds of witnesses and accumulating more than 4,300 pages of testimony."
27. Schmidt, p. 224
28. s:McCormack-Dickstein Committee#Testimony of Gerald C. Macguire
29. Archer, p. 6.
30. This contradicts MacGuire's testimony: "You are a past department commander in the American Legion?" "No, sir; never held an office in the American Legion. I have just boon a Legionnaire—oh, I beg your pardon. I did hold one office. I was on the distinguished guest committee of the Legion in 1933, I believe." Wikisource: McCormack-Dickstein Committee report, testimony of Gerald C. MacGuire
31. Archer, p. 6
32. Schmidt, p. 239, 241
33. ^ Archer, p. 14
34. Wikisource: McCormack-Dickstein Committee report, Testimony of Maj. Gen. S. D. Butler (ret)
35. Wikisource: McCormack-Dickstein Committee report, pg. 2
36. Archer, p. 155.
37. Beam, Alex (May 25 2004). "A Blemish Behind Beauty at The Clark". The Boston Globe: E1. {{cite journal}}: Check date values in: |date= (help): "In his congressional testimony, Butler described Clark as being "known as the "millionaire lieutenant" and was sort of batty, sort of queer, did all sorts of extravagant things. He used to go exploring around China and wrote a book on it, on explorations. He was never taken seriously by anybody. But he had a lot of money." "Clark was certainly eccentric. One of the reasons he sited his fantastic art collection away from New York or Boston was that he feared it might be destroyed by a Soviet bomber attack during the Cold War..."(Clark) was pointed out to me during a trip to Paris," says one on his grandnieces. "He was known to be pro-fascist and on the enemy side. Nobody ever spoke to him.""
    Wikisource: McCormack-Dickstein Committee
38. Archer, p. 173
    Philadelphia Post, November 22, 1934
39. United States Congress. "WEIDEMAN, Carl May (id: W000254)". Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.
40. United States Congress. "KRAMER, Charles (id: K000321)". Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.
41. United States Congress. "JENKINS, Thomas Albert (id: J000088)". Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.
42. United States Congress. "TAYLOR, James Willis (id: T000083)". Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.
43. United States Congress. "GUYER, Ulysses Samuel (id: G000538)". Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.
44. Investigation of Nazi Propaganda Activities and Investigation of Certain Other Propaganda Activities: Public Hearings Before the Special Committee on Un-American Activities, House of Representatives, Seventy-third Congress, Second Session, at Washington, D.C. p.8-114 D.C. 6 II
    Schmidt, p. 245 "HUAC's final report to Congress: "There is no question that these attempts were discussed, were planned, and might have been placed in execution when and if the financial backers deemed it expedient." The committee had verified "all the pertinent statements made by General Butler, with the exception of the direct statement suggesting the creation of the organization.""
45. Investigation of Nazi Propaganda Activities and Investigation of Certain Other Propaganda Activities: Public Hearings Before the Special Committee on Un-American Activities, House of Representatives, Seventy-third Congress, Second Session, at Washington, D.C. p. 111 D.C. 6 II.
46. Schlesinger, p 85; Wolfe, Part IV: "But James E. Van Zandt, national commander of the Veterans of Foreign Wars and subsequently a Republican congressman, corroborated Butler's story and said that he, too, had been approached by "agents of Wall Street." "Zandt had been called immediately after the August 22 meeting with MacGuire by Butler and warned that...he was going to be approached by the coup plotters for his support at an upcoming VFW convention. He said that, just as Butler had warned, he had been approached "by agents of Wall Street" who tried to enlist him in their plot.""Says Butler Described. Offer". New York Times: 3. 1934. {{cite journal}}: |first= has generic name (help); |first= missing |last= (help); Cite has empty unknown parameter: |coauthors= (help); Unknown parameter |month= ignored (help) Quoted material from the NYT
    Schmidt, p. 224 But James E. Van Zandt, national commander of the Veterans of Foreign Wars and subsequently a Republican congressman, corroborated Butler's story and said that he, too, had been approached by "agents of Wall Street."
    Archer, p.3, 5, 29, 32, 129, 176. For more on Van Zandt, and the Archer quotes, see Unknown author. "James Edward Van Zandt". Coalition to Oppose the Arms Trade (COAT). Retrieved 2006-03-28. {{cite web}}: |author= has generic name (help)
47. Chapter 10, FDR; Man on the White Horse of Sutton, Antony C. (1993). Wall Street and the Bolshevik Revolution. Buccaneer Books. ISBN 0-89968-324-X. {{cite book}}: Unknown parameter |month= ignored (help) Full book online.
48. Wikisource: McCormack-Dickstein Committee, Captain Glazier's testimony
49. Wikisource: McCormack-Dickstein Committee, testimony of Paul Comly French
50. BBC Radio 4 Document "The White House Coup - Greenham's Hidden Secret"
51. Wolfe, Part IV: "New York's Mayor Fiorello LaGuardia, who was known as the "Little Flower" . . .   a (supporter) of the fascist program of Mussolini, coined the term cocktail putsch to describe the Butler story: It's a joke of some kind, he told the wire services, "someone at a party had suggested the idea to the ex-marine as a joke".
52. http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio4/history/document/document_20070723.shtml
53. Maverick Marine: Excerpt at coat.ncf.ca

External links

This article's use of external links may not follow Misplaced Pages's policies or guidelines. Please improve this article by removing excessive or inappropriate external links, and converting useful links where appropriate into footnote references. (Learn how and when to remove this message)

• U.S. House of Representatives, Special Committee on Un-American Activities, Public Statement, 73rd Congress, 2nd session, (Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1934)
• U.S. House of Representatives, Special Committee on Un-American Activities, Investigation of Nazi Propaganda Activities and Investigation of Certain Other Propaganda Activities, Hearings 73-D.C.-6, Part 1, 73rd Congress, 2nd session, (Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1935).

• Wikisource: Full text, Part 1; pdf file 1;
• Wikisource: Full text, Part 2 pdf file 2;
• pdf file 3

• Adams, Cecil (November 18 2005). "Oh, Smedley: Was there really a fascist plot to overthrow the United States government?". The Straight Dope. {{cite journal}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)
• Cramer, Clayton (1995). "An American Coup d'État? Plot against Franklin D. Roosevelt, 1934". History Today. 45 (11): 42. {{cite journal}}: Unknown parameter |month= ignored (help) Examines Butler's testimony from both sides
• LaMonica, Barbara (March–April 1999). "The Attempted Coup Against FDR". Probe.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: date format (link)
• Sanders, Richard (editor) (2004). "Facing the Corporate Roots of American Fascism". Press for Conversion! (53). {{cite journal}}: |author= has generic name (help); Unknown parameter |month= ignored (help)
• Spivak, John L. (January 29 1935; February 5 1935). "Wall Street's Fascist Conspiracy: Testimony that the Dickstein MacCormack Committee Suppressed; Wall Street's Fascist Conspiracy: Morgan Pulls the Strings" (PDF). New Masses. {{cite journal}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)
• "The Plot Against FDR" History Channel documentary. In public domain.
• Thomson, Mike (2007-07-23). "The Whitehouse Coup". BBC. Retrieved 2007-07-24. {{cite web}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)
• Nasser, Alan (2007-10-03). "FDR's Response to the Plot to Overthrow Him". counterpunch.org. Retrieved 2008-11-01. {{cite web}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)

Further reading

• Archer, Jules (1973, pub.2007). The Plot to Seize the White House. Skyhorse Publishing. {{cite book}}: Check date values in: |year= (help)CS1 maint: year (link)ISBN 1-60239-036-3, Book Information and Chapter Summaries, Executive summary and/or extensive quotes of Jules Archer's book on the subject, mostly on Butler's Censored Testimony Concerning Attempts to Bribe Him Into the Plot.
• Extensive list of links, books and video on the plot
• The History Channel Video: In Search of History: The Plot to Overthrow FDR "While The Plot To Overthrow FDR will astonish those who never learned about this story in school, in the end many viewers may feel as if they are trying to handcuff a shadow."Feran, Tim (February 12 1999). "History Channel Looks At Plot to Oust FDR". Columbus Dispatch (Ohio): 1H. {{cite journal}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)

Books with Business Plot chapters

• Seldes, George (1947). 1000 Americans: The Real Rulers of the U.S.A. Boni & Gaer. ASIN: B000ANE968. p. 292-298 Excerpts of the book can be found here.
• Spivak, John L. (1967). A Man in His Time. Horizon Press. ASIN: B0007DMOCW. p. 294-298 Excerpts: Socioeconomic and Political Context of the Plot, General Smedley Butler.
• Bankers, Lawyers and Linkage Groups found in Simpson, Christopher (1995). The Splendid Blond Beast: Money, Law and Genocide in the Twentieth Century. Common Courage Press. ISBN 1-56751-062-0. p. 43-58 Book Experts can be found here.
• Colby, Gerard (1984). Du Pont Dynasty: Behind the Nylon Curtain. L. Stuart. ISBN 0-8184-0352-7. p. 324-330 Excerpts of the book about the plot found here.

• Conflicts in 1933
• 1933 in the United States
• Conspiracy theories
• Great Depression in the United States
• Political history of the United States