This is an old revision of this page, as edited by DuncanBCS (talk | contribs) at 23:02, 25 February 2006 (RV to previous version. Disputed tags should remain. See talk). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.
Revision as of 23:02, 25 February 2006 by DuncanBCS (talk | contribs) (RV to previous version. Disputed tags should remain. See talk)(diff) ← Previous revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)Max Shachtman (September 10 1904 - November 4, 1972) was an American Marxist theorist and associate of Leon Trotsky. He is widely regarded as a principal forefather of neoconservatism.
Beginnings in the Communist left
Shachtman was born in 1904 to a Jewish family in Warsaw, Poland, which was then part of the Russian Empire. He emigrated with his family to New York City in 1905. At an early age he became interested in Marxism and was sympathetic to the radical wing of the Socialist Party. In 1922, he joined the Workers Party, a predecessor to the Communist Party USA. He soon moved to Chicago and became a youth organizer for the party. He associated with a group of dissidents close to Leon Trotsky that included James Cannon and Martin Abern.
Shachtman, Cannon and Abern were expelled from the Communist Party in 1928 after Joseph Stalin took control of the Communist International. These three and a handful of others formed a group around a newspaper called The Militant, and shortly thereafter formed the Trotskyist Communist League of America (CLA). In 1934, the CLA merged with A. J. Muste's American Workers Party to form the Workers Party, and Shachtman began editing the party's new theoretical journal, New International. Shachtman and the other Trotskyists soon entered the Socialist Party as a tendency around the newspaper Socialist Appeal. They were expelled from the SP in 1937 and founded a separate group, the Socialist Workers Party (SWP).
Following the Hitler-Stalin Pact and the Soviet invasion of Finland and Poland, Shachtman broke with Cannon and others in the SWP, feeling that he could no longer give even critical support to the USSR. While Cannon and his allies regarded the Soviet Union as a "degenerated workers' state," Shachtman and his grouping believed that the Stalinist bureaucracy had become a new imperialist ruling class. In the summer of 1940 Shachtman led an exodus of almost 40 percent of the SWP membership, half of whom formed yet another organization called the Workers Party. In 1948, the group was renamed the Independent Socialist League (ISL).
The development of the "Third Camp"
In the early 1940s Shachtman developed the idea of a "Third Camp" that would be equally distinct from Stalinism and Western capitalism. Shachtman no longer endorsed the Trotskyist conclusion that the Soviet Union was a "degenerated workers' state," a post-capitalist country in which political control had been won by a bureaucratic caste that was not a new ruling class. He classified the USSR as a "bureaucratic collectivist" state ruled by a reactionary bureaucratic class that could engage in imperialist invasions. By 1948, Shachtman regarded capitalism and Stalinism to be equal impediments to socialism. His ideology at this time was different from his later thinking that Communism was the greater obstacle. Shachtman's views were detail in a famous debate with Communist leader Earl Browder during this period.
Shachtman's Workers Party became active in union struggles, though it never gained a considerable influence in the labor movement. In 1948, Shachtman's group dropped its self-description as a "party" and became the Independent Socialist League (ISL). The WP/ISL attracted many young intellectuals, including Michael Harrington, Irving Howe, Hal Draper, Sidney Hook, and Julius Jacobson. Shachtman also maintained contact with Trotsky's widow, Natalia Sedova, who generally agreed with his views at this time.
During the 1950s, Shachtman and the ISL moved from Marxism to an ideology more in line with democratic socialism. Despite Shachtman's ideological dedication to democracy, critics have argued that he maintained a top-down power structure and strict party discipline in the ISL that resembled negative aspects of democratic centralism. Organizational and programmatic disputes in the group caused a number of splits, most notably by Hal Draper, who left and formed the Independent Socialist Club in 1964.
Shachtman in the Socialist Party
In 1958 the ISL merged with the Socialist Party, which from its height in the 1910s had fallen in strength to approximately 1,000 members. Shachtman pressured the SP to work with the Democratic Party in order to push the Democrats to the left. This strategy, known as "realignment", proved to be somewhat successful. With the eager participation of the Shachtmanites, the SP took an active role in the civil rights movement and the early events of the New Left.
The Shachtmanites soon became irreparably divorced from the new left because of their unwavering support for the Vietnam War. In 1972 Shachtmanites supported Democrat "Scoop" Jackson's presidential primary bid, as Jackson was by then the only major candidate who favored a continuation of the war. When George McGovern was nominated instead, the Shachtmanites chose not to endorse him.
Following the 1972 convention of the SP, Shachtman's followers, organized in the "Unity Caucus", gained control of the SP's leadership. After Shachtman's death in November of that year, the Shachtmanites reconstituted the SP as Social Democrats USA (SDUSA). Harrington and the bulk of the party's membership soon left the organization.
Influence on Neoconservatism
After Shachtman's death in 1972, many Shachtmanites rose to prominent positions in government and organized labor. Supporters of Social Democrats USA (SDUSA) in the labor movement included Albert Shanker (president of the American Federation of Teachers), as well as AFL-CIO presidents George Meany and Lane Kirkland.
The most lasting legacy of Shachtman may be the intellectual contribution that Shachtman's followers and colleagues made to neoconservatism. Many of the founders of neoconservatism, such as Irving Kristol, Nathan Glazer, and Sidney Hook, developed their thinking in the Shachtmanite milieu of the 1930s and 1940s. Jeane Kirkpatrick was a member of the Shachtmanite-dominated Young People's Socialist League as a university student. In the 1970s Paul Wolfowitz was a speaker at SDUSA conferences. Joshua Muravchik, Penn Kemble, Carl Gershman, and Max Green, leaders in the Young People's Socialist League, became right-wing think tank insiders.
Indeed, it has often been suggested that much of the history of neoconservatism can be explained as a classic Leninist takeover of first the American left and then the American right by the followers of Max Shachtman .
External links
- Shachtman, Max and Earl Browder. Is Russia a Socialist Community? The Verbatim Text of a Debate. March 1950 debate moderated by C. Wright Mills. Published in The New International: A Monthly Organ of Revolutionary Marxism, Vol.16 No.3, May-June 1950, pp.145-176. Retrieved June 6, 2005.
- The Lubitz TrotskyanaNet provides a biographical sketch and a selective bibliography of Max Shachtman
Further reading
Max Shachtman Papers 1917-1969. Tamiment 103; Tamiment Library/Robert F. Wagner Labor Archives at New York University. Online guide retrieved April 20, 2005.
Categories: