Misplaced Pages:Wikiethics - Misplaced Pages

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Rgulerdem (talk | contribs) at 07:24, 8 April 2006 (→Editorial Guidelines). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Revision as of 07:24, 8 April 2006 by Rgulerdem (talk | contribs) (→Editorial Guidelines)(diff) ← Previous revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

The following is a proposed Misplaced Pages policy, guideline, or process. The proposal may still be in development, under discussion, or in the process of gathering consensus for adoption.

Shortcut

]

Wikiethics include principles of ethical standards related to editing articles on Misplaced Pages.

Misplaced Pages has a body of policies that presuppose the existence of ethical standards in both the editors contributing, and the encyclopedia itself. Although these ethical standards are largely undefinable this document aims to outline their parameters and scope.

Editorial Guidelines

The following sections provide important guidelines for editing an article. It is also helpful on how to have a productive editorial discussion concerning Misplaced Pages articles when disputes arise.

Article-based classifications

Due to diversity of editor backgrounds, the interpretation of terms like 'offensive', 'censorship', 'pornography', 'minority', 'acceptability' should always be decided on an article by article basis, and by following consensus.

Collective consciousness

Collective consciousness can be expressed as a common sense and common understanding of the contributing editors which does not strictly exclude ideas from minorities in a particular discussion.

The culture of compromise

Empathy and sincerity towards 'the other' when editors discuss articles is powerful tool for compromise.

Conflict resolution

It is generally possible to resolve a conflict by taking all possible options available into the consideration.

Images

If a picture is causing concerns in an article, choosing visual or verbal description based on the judgement of the contributing editors might be helpful. Changing the image with a more ensyklopedic one, lowering the picture in the article, providing a link instead, or posting a warning template are other options can be considered.

Discussion pages

Discussion pages are for discussing improvement of articles, not in general for theorising and debating general principles. The are many methods of achieving consensus provided on Misplaced Pages. Editors are encouraged to seek whatever process is most likely to result in consensus and build a better encyclopedia. For efficiency of the discussions on an article one might chose to copy the part from the article onto the discussion page, express his/her ideas why s/he thinks the part is not appropriate and give his/her suggestion to fix the problem. This could help to get more input from the other editors and consequently may lead to a better article.

Polls

A 'straw poll' on a particluar argument or on part of an article can be started at any time to see where community stands on that particluar issue. It is reasonable to think that an approval poll, however, need to be started upon the completion of the proposals and based on consensus.

Anonymity

The appearance of anonymity does not exempt any editor from a responsibility to their personal ethics.

Editorial standards

High editorial standards would add to reputation of Misplaced Pages. Misplaced Pages recognizes the standards which are shaped for centuries and currently practised in the mainstream media, for example, Harm limitation principle, and Taste, decency and acceptability listed in Journalism ethics and standards. Golden Rule ("not to inflict harm") can be taken to be another example. Some of the important editorial standards in Wiki are discussed below.

Objectivity

A Wiki article should reflect judgment based on observable phenomena, physical reality and uninfluenced by emotions or personal prejudices. Absence of bias, lack of emotional involvement are necessary. Separation between news, opinion, and advertisements is also equally important. Competing points of view need to be balanced and fairly characterized in the articles.

Privacy

Misplaced Pages is a form of publication. As Misplaced Pages becomes more popular and readership increases, the potential impact of published material, whether positive or negative, also magnifies. As we publish information about individuals, we must strive to be objective and fair. We should consider their rights to privacy (especially for private people) and strive to limit unnecessary harms or discomfort to them. These factors should be balanced against the public interest in reporting information about them. This might occasionally lead to an ethical dilemma, and requires greater effort on the part of editors to discuss and deliberate when making editorial decisions.

Responsibility

When making editorial decisions, each editor should make some personal consideration of sensitivity towards private individuals, children and juveniles, victims of crimes, and people who are currently suffering grief and tragedy.

Public accountability

Misplaced Pages has an obligation towards it's readers. It is not in WIkipedia editors' interest to act irresponsibly or improperly, in a manner that is contrary to public interest and violates the trust of our donors and the public. Keeping the public's trust is easier than regaining it.

Censorship

Censorship in any form is not acceptable. 'No censorship' means information/descriptions/expressions should be included into or excluded from an article for only editorial reasons or ethical concerns based on the editorial consensus. Based on their judgement about verifiability, informative and encyclopedic nature of the materials editors can include or exclude some information, expressions and visual or verbal descriptions into or from an article. A description can be considered inappropriate for one article but it might be appropriate for another. The article-based classification gives that flexibility in decision-making to the editors.

Offense

It is not in our interest to offend Wikipedians or people who are using Wiki as a source of information. It is generally possible to find a different way of the same description which might be found less offensive or not offensive at all, while expressing the core idea clearly. A careful use of language can help in that direction. In doing so, keeping the informative materials stated objectively in the article is also necessary. It is always good to be considerate for the concerns raised by the 'minorities' of particular discussions or articles.

Pornography

Pornography which can be described as visual or verbal descriptions or expressions that are intended to cause sexual excitement should generally be avoided in Wiki articles. The decision of what is appropriate is discussed on an article by article basis to form consensus.

Violence

Editors should be sensitive in portraying violence in the articles. Violence can be defined as an act of aggression or rough unwarranted force intended to cause physical or emotional harm on another being. Editors should also be sensitive about the rights of victims who are subject to violence and also the possibility, if any, that these portrayals may incite someone to harm others.

Racism

Racism can be defined as the notion that people of one race or creed are superior to another. In Misplaced Pages articles, expressions that unecessarily portray prejudice, discrimination or intolerance of people of race or creed are to be avoided.

Propaganda

Wiki articles must not be written from the perspective of supporting any political, social, or religious movements. Editors should be careful about the information put out by an organization or a government to promote a policy, idea, or cause. It is also good to be more conscious regarding the deceptive or distorted information that is systematically spread.

Bias

The possibility of causing unnecessary animosity between spiritual beliefs, lifestyles or ideologies should be carefully examined and avoided in making editorial decisions.

Sexism

Sexism can be defined as discriminatory or abusive behavior towards someone based on their gender identification. Expressions that unnecessarily promote sexism in articles are not encyclopedic.

Language

Language used is often as important as the context. Slang words, rudeness, sarcasm are not useful in articles.

Existing policies and guidelines

Policies

Misplaced Pages:No_binding_decisions
Misplaced Pages:Civility: Being rude, insensitive or petty makes people upset and stops Misplaced Pages working well. Try to discourage others from being uncivil, and be careful to avoid offending people unintentionally. Mediation is available if needed.
Misplaced Pages:Copyrights
Misplaced Pages:Harassment
WP:IUP: Be very careful when uploading copyrighted images, fully describe images' sources and copyright details on their description pages, and try to make images as useful and reusable as possible.
Misplaced Pages:Libel: It is Misplaced Pages policy to delete libellous revisions from the page history. If you believe you have been defamed, please contact the help desk.
Misplaced Pages:Neutral point of view: All Misplaced Pages articles must be written from a neutral point of view, representing views fairly and without bias. This includes reader-facing templates, categories and portals.
Misplaced Pages:No original research: Articles may not contain any unpublished theories, data, statements, concepts, arguments, or ideas; or any new analysis or synthesis of published data, statements, concepts, arguments, or ideas.
Misplaced Pages:No personal attacks: There is no excuse for personal attacks on other contributors. Do not make them. It is your responsibility to foster and maintain a positive online community in Misplaced Pages.
WP:NOT: Misplaced Pages is first and foremost an online encyclopedia, and as a means to that end, an online community. Please avoid the temptation to use Misplaced Pages for other purposes, or to treat it as something it is not.
WP:OFFICE
WP:OWN: You agreed to allow others to modify your work here. So let them.
Misplaced Pages:Three-revert rule: Do not revert any single page in whole or in part more than three times in 24 hours. (Or else an Administrator may suspend your account.)
Misplaced Pages:Vandalism
Misplaced Pages:Verifiability: Information on Misplaced Pages must be reliable. Facts, viewpoints, theories, and arguments may only be included in articles if they have already been published by reliable and reputable sources. Articles should cite these sources whenever possible. Any unsourced material may be challenged and removed.