This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Dornicke (talk | contribs) at 17:32, 29 December 2020 (→Torture). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.
Revision as of 17:32, 29 December 2020 by Dornicke (talk | contribs) (→Torture)(diff) ← Previous revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)Biography Unassessed | |||||||
|
China Unassessed | ||||||||||
|
COVID-19 Unassessed | ||||||||||
|
Human rights Unassessed | ||||||||||
|
Crime and Criminal Biography Unassessed | ||||||||||
|
Journalism C‑class Low‑importance | ||||||||||
|
Sinophobia much?
First, she isn't a journalist, she's a lawyer. Posting videos on twitter does not turn her into a journalist. Second, "tortured"? Shouldn't it be at least "allegedly tortured"?
Could people here stop trying to transform Misplaced Pages in an anticommunist McCarthyist platform and keep their political agendas away from this project? Dornicke (talk) 02:03, 29 December 2020 (UTC)
- Dunno, Dornicke. 24 hpd in handcuffs & forced feedng sounds like torture, no? And comparsing the article with your "anticommunist McCarthyist platform" leads me to the conclusion that it is you, and not the article, that has a bias issue. On that basis, I'll remove the tag from the article. You could perhaps slap one on your forehead? --Tagishsimon (talk) 02:21, 29 December 2020 (UTC)
- I don't recall seeing journalists who received far worse treatment in the US and Europe being labeled as "victims of tortures" for being handcuffed, so I'll revert you. Dornicke (talk) 02:49, 29 December 2020 (UTC)
- At a quick web search, she was referred to as a citizen journalist in headlines by the Guardian, Al Jazeera, NBC, CBS, Times of Israel and Deutsche Welle, and probably many others. The ultimate source of this may be AFP. Since Misplaced Pages merely paraphrases reliable sources, I recommend continuing to refer to her as a (citizen) journalist. I'm not personally sure it's worth debating whether the "citizen" moniker must always be included, but there might be reliable sources that clearly state that citizen journalists aren't journalists. If so, let's see them. Samsara 06:03, 29 December 2020 (UTC)
- I agree with Tagishsimon here, multiple reliable sources indicate that what Zhang Zhan experienced is indeed state torture and it also seems to indicate that she is being subjected to a show trial. But that is just my opinion. Since it is so widely stated in reliable sources that she is a citizen journalist and given that her work seems to meet the definition of citizen journalist I am happy for this article to continue referring to her as such. Samsara is right to point out that that Misplaced Pages is merely, and often does -indeed often should-, paraphrase reliable sources. On the sinophobia accusation, I fail so see how the article (in its current form as of writing this comment) is sinophobic or that people are "trying to transform Misplaced Pages in an anticommunist McCarthyist platform". Perhaps Dornicke could expand on how they believe this article is guilty of that? Covering issues such as this covered by multiple reliable sources, no matter how critical of a government it might be, does not equate to sinophobia (or any other type of prejudicial bias). --Discott (talk) 11:49, 29 December 2020 (UTC)
- Seems to be consensus that she is a citizen journalist so I will amend 'amateur journalist' (not sure what that means anyway), I think it is important to make clear she is not a professional journalist. 51.6.235.99 (talk) 14:30, 29 December 2020 (UTC)
- It appears that several editors here are not familiar with the relevant Misplaced Pages policies, in particular WP:NPOV and WP:V. If an editor's personal beliefs or opinions diverge from what reliable sources state, we still go with the latter. Regards, HaeB (talk) 16:32, 29 December 2020 (UTC)
Torture
I have removed 'alleged' from the information on torture, there are now multiple reliable sources saying she has been tortured and describing the nature of the multiple methods of torture; prolonged use of handcuffs and other restraints and prolonged force feeding. John Cummings (talk) 15:05, 29 December 2020 (UTC)
I've also added the Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment as a reference, her treatment fits with the definition:
1) intentional infliction of severe pain or suffering; 2) for a specific purpose, such as to obtain information, as punishment, or to intimidate, or for any reason based on discrimination; and, 3) by or at the instigation of or with the consent or acquiescence of State authorities.
John Cummings (talk) 15:55, 29 December 2020 (UTC)
An IP editor has been edit warring on the page, I've explained multiple times to discuss the issue here which they do not appear to be interested in doing, I've requested that they be blocked at Misplaced Pages:Administrator intervention against vandalism. John Cummings (talk) 17:09, 29 December 2020 (UTC)
- I agree with the IP. You can not say she was tortured just because you cherrypicked sources that say so. Most reliable sources are using "allegedly tortured", and even if it wasn't the case, WP should anyway, because that's an allegation by her and her lawyer, not a proven fact. You do not endorse information which is not consensual as if it was, unless you intend to write a propaganda piece in favor of proving a point - not informing the readers. Dornicke (talk) 17:32, 29 December 2020 (UTC)
Trial and sentencing
It seems like the charges section is getting a bit confusing, it might be helpful to have it as a full list of charges and which she was found guilty of. John Cummings (talk) 15:08, 29 December 2020 (UTC)
This might help: https://mobile.twitter.com/skkboz/status/1343575199384420352 This Twitter thread and video has some of the offences that amount to "provoking trouble", such as harassing police/frontline workers, breach of privacy (videoing into hospital windows), public disorder (kicking over police barriers), etc.
Original source is her YouTube channel 2A00:23C7:C005:4300:4DC8:A8E5:4E94:FCCE (talk) 15:47, 29 December 2020 (UTC)
- To explain how Misplaced Pages works, personal Twitter accounts (especially ones which spread conspiracy theories) aren't Misplaced Pages:Reliable sources so aren't used on Misplaced Pages. John Cummings (talk) 16:13, 29 December 2020 (UTC)
- Unassessed biography articles
- WikiProject Biography articles
- Unassessed China-related articles
- Unknown-importance China-related articles
- Unassessed China-related articles of Unknown-importance
- WikiProject China articles
- Unassessed COVID-19 articles
- Unknown-importance COVID-19 articles
- WikiProject COVID-19 articles
- Unassessed Human rights articles
- Unknown-importance Human rights articles
- WikiProject Human rights articles
- Unassessed Crime-related articles
- Unknown-importance Crime-related articles
- WikiProject Crime and Criminal Biography articles
- C-Class Journalism articles
- Low-importance Journalism articles
- WikiProject Journalism articles