2016 United States Supreme Court case
| Montgomery v. Louisiana | |
|---|---|
 Supreme Court of the United States | |
| Argued October 13, 2015 Decided January 25, 2016 | |
| Full case name | Henry Montgomery, Petitioner v. Louisiana |
| Docket no. | 14-280 |
| Citations | 577 U.S. 190 (more)136 S. Ct. 718; 193 L. Ed. 2d 599 |
| Argument | Oral argument |
| Case history | |
| Prior | annulling verdict, 181 So. 2d 756 (1966), affirming life sentence, 242 So.2d 818 (1970), denying motion to correct illegal sentence, 141 So.3d 264 (2014). |
| Subsequent | vacating sentence and remanding, 194 So.3d 606 (2016). |
| Holding | |
| Miller's prohibition on life in prison without the possibility of parole for juvenile homicide offenders is a substantive rule that must be applied retroactively. | |
| Court membership | |
| |
| Case opinions | |
| Majority | Kennedy, joined by Roberts, Ginsburg, Breyer, Sotomayor, Kagan |
| Dissent | Scalia, joined by Thomas, Alito |
| Dissent | Thomas |
| Laws applied | |
| U.S. Const. amend. VIII | |
Montgomery v. Louisiana, 577 U.S. 190 (2016), was a United States Supreme Court case in which the Court held that its previous ruling in Miller v. Alabama (2012), that a mandatory life sentence without parole should not apply to persons convicted of murder committed as juveniles, should be applied retroactively. This decision potentially affects up to 2,300 cases nationwide.
This case is one in a series since 2005 that have mitigated the harshness of sentencing of juveniles and persons who committed crimes as juveniles. It is based in part on scientific evidence showing that juvenile brains are not equivalent to those of adults.
Background
Issue
In Roper v. Simmons (2005), the Supreme Court of the United States by a 5–4 vote established that the death penalty for children under 18 was unconstitutional. In Graham v. Florida (2010), the Court ruled that it was unconstitutional to impose mandatory life sentence without parole on prisoners who committed non-murder crimes as juveniles.
Two years later, in Miller v. Alabama (2012), the Court by a 5–4 vote decided that mandatory life sentence without parole should not apply to persons who committed the crime as juveniles.
Petitioner
Henry Montgomery was 17 years old on November 13, 1963, when he shot and killed police officer Charles Hurt, a sheriff's deputy, in East Baton Rouge Parish, Louisiana. A jury convicted Montgomery of murder and sentenced him to death in February 1964 but, in January 1966, the divided Louisiana Supreme Court annulled that verdict, finding he had not received a fair trial due to public prejudice. In October 1966, Montgomery escaped from the parish jail and was rearrested two hours later.
In February 1969, a jury again convicted Montgomery of murder, triggering an automatic sentence of life in prison without parole, which was affirmed by the Louisiana Supreme Court in November 1970, over the dissent of Justice Mack Barham.
Montgomery became a model member of the prison community, serving as a coach on the prison boxing team, working in the prison's silk-screen program, and offering advice to younger prisoners. After the U.S. Supreme Court decided Miller v. Alabama, Montgomery made a motion to correct an illegal sentence, which, in June 2014, was denied by the Louisiana Supreme Court, over the dissent of Chief Justice Bernette Joshua Johnson.
Supreme Court of the United States
In September 2014, Montgomery filed a petition for a writ of certiorari from the U.S. Supreme Court, which was granted. Seventy-five minutes of oral arguments were heard on October 13, 2015, with attorneys appearing for the prisoner and the state as well as an amicus curiae appointed by the Court, arguing against the Court's jurisdiction, and the U.S. Deputy Solicitor General, arguing as a friend of the prisoner.
Opinion of the Court
On January 25, 2016, the Supreme Court delivered judgment in favor of the prisoner, by a vote of 6–3. Writing for the Court, Justice Anthony Kennedy, joined by Chief Justice John Roberts, along with Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor, and Elena Kagan, applied the Miller v. Alabama rule retroactively, holding that prisoners previously given automatic life sentences with no chance of parole for crimes committed as juveniles must have their cases reviewed for re-sentencing or be considered for parole.
The Court first found that it had jurisdiction over Louisiana's prisoner because the rule governing retroactivity is constitutional, not statutory. Next, Justice Kennedy wrote that "prisoners like Montgomery must be given the opportunity to show their crime did not reflect irreparable corruption; and if it did not, their hope for some years of life outside prison walls must be restored." Applying the presumption from Teague v. Lane (1989) that a new rule is not retroactive on collateral review unless it is substantive or "watershed", Kennedy said the decision was founded on substantive grounds, based "on the diminished culpability of all juvenile offenders, who are, he said, immature, susceptible to peer pressure and capable of change. Very few, he said, are incorrigible. But he added that as a general matter the punishment was out of bounds."
Dissents
Justice Antonin Scalia, joined by Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito dissented. Criticizing the majority's "sleight of hand", Scalia wrote that Kennedy had twisted the language in the Miller decision to make it sound categorical when it merely required a new sentencing procedure. Scalia also stated that it would be very difficult for judges and juries to decide whether defendants were incorrigible decades after they were originally sentenced.
Justice Thomas filed another dissenting opinion, alone, stating that the majority's decision "repudiates established principles of finality".
Subsequent developments
On June 28, 2016, the Louisiana Supreme Court vacated Montgomery's life sentence and remanded for resentencing in a per curiam decision, with Justice Scott Crichton additionally concurring. In February 2017, Montgomery, now 70 years old, remained a prisoner at the Louisiana State Penitentiary in Angola. In February 2018 and April 2019, Montgomery had parole hearings, and was denied both times. On November 17, 2021, the Louisiana Board of Pardons and Parole granted parole to Montgomery by a unanimous vote of 3–0. Following the vote, Montgomery was freed from prison and released. His release was opposed by some of Hurt's family members, however, two of Hurt's daughters had met with Montgomery in prison and forgiven him.
In March 2020, the Supreme Court agreed to hear a related case, Jones v. Mississippi, involving a person who had killed his grandfather when he was 15 in 2004 and given the mandatory sentence of life without parole. Due to the reactive rulings in Miller and Montgomery, Jones was given a rehearing but was still resentenced to life in prison, and appealed, claiming the court did not evaluate any aspect of his incorrigibility as required under Montgomery. Oral hearings were held on November 3, 2020.
See also
References
- Miller v. Alabama, 567 U.S. 460 (2012).
- Savage, David G. (June 25, 2012). "Supreme Court rules mandatory juvenile life without parole cruel and unusual". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved April 18, 2017.
- The Supreme Court, 2011 Term — Leading Cases, 126 Harv. L. Rev. 276 (2012).
- "Parole Hearing for Inmate Convicted in 1963 Slaying of Louisiana Sheriff's Deputy Delayed". Officer.com. December 14, 2017.
- Segura, Liliana (June 2, 2019). "Henry Montgomery Paved the Way for Other Juvenile Lifers to Go Free. Now 72, He May Never Get The Same Chance". The Intercept.
- Santana, Rebecca (April 12, 2019). "Board denies parole for inmate in landmark juvenile case". 4wwl. The Associated Press.
- Toohey, Grace (April 11, 2019). "After 55 years in prison, Baton Rouge man key to Supreme Court ruling again denied freedom". nola.com. theadvocate.com.
- Santana, Rebecca (April 11, 2019). "Inmate at center of landmark juvenile case loses parole bid". The Daily Herald. The Associated Press.
- Reckdahl, Katy (October 11, 2015). "Split-Second Flash of a Gun Still Resonates 52 Years Later". The Center for Public Integrity.
- Reckdahl, Katy (October 11, 2015). "Man Jailed 50 Years for Murder Is at Center of Supreme Court Hearing on Youth Life Sentences". jjie.org.
- Khan, Naureen (October 15, 2015). "After 52 years in prison, SCOTUS may help set Henry Montgomery Free". Aljazeera America. The Associated Press.
- Dahlia Lithwick (October 14, 2015). "Is Life Retroactive? He was sentenced to life without parole at 17. Fifty years later, the Supreme Court weighs setting him free". Slate.
- State v. Montgomery, 181 So. 2d 756, 248 La. 713 (1966).
- "Henry Montgomery, at center of juvenile life debate, is free". wric.com. November 17, 2021.
- "Will Supreme Court Decision be Death Knell for Juvenile Life without Parole? | Casetext".
- ^ State v. Montgomery, 242 So. 2d 818, 257 La. 461 (1970).
- ^ Adam Liptak (January 26, 2016). "Justices Expand Parole Rights for Juveniles Sentenced to Life for Murder". The New York Times. p. A18. Retrieved April 18, 2017.
- State v. Montgomery, 141 So. 3d 264 (La. 2014).
- "Montgomery v. Louisiana". SCOTUSblog. Retrieved January 25, 2016.
- "Montgomery v. Louisiana". IIT Chicago-Kent College of Law.
- ^ The Supreme Court, 2015 Term — Leading Cases, 130 Harv. L. Rev. 377 (2016).
- ^ Sherman, Mark (January 25, 2016). "Justices Extend Bar on Automatic Life Terms for Teenagers". ABC News. Associated Press.
- "Supreme Court rules in major Eighth Amendment sentencing case". Yahoo! News. January 26, 2016.
- State v. Montgomery, 194 So. 3d 606 (La. 2016).
- Berman, Douglas A. (February 3, 2017). "Sentencing Law and Policy: Lamenting that Henry Montgomery (and many other juve LWOPers) may not much or any benefit from Montgomery". Sentencing Law and Policy Blog. Retrieved April 18, 2017.
- Toohey, Grace (February 19, 2018). "Board denies parole to man who served more than 50 years after killing deputy when he was juvenile". The Advocate. Retrieved June 2, 2019.
- Segura, Liliana (June 2, 2019). "Henry Montgomery Paved the Way for Other Juvenile Lifers to Go Free. Now 72, He May Never Get the Same Chance". The Intercept. Retrieved June 2, 2019.
- Santana, Rebecca (November 17, 2021). "Henry Montgomery, at center of juvenile life debate, is free". Associated Press. Retrieved November 19, 2021.
- "An inmate whose story was key to the debate over juvenile life sentences gets parole". NPR. November 17, 2021. Retrieved November 19, 2021.
- Liptak, Adam (March 9, 2020). "Supreme Court to Consider When Juveniles May Get Life Without Parole". The New York Times. Retrieved November 3, 2020.
- Liptak, Adam (March 9, 2020). "Supreme Court to Consider When Juveniles May Get Life Without Parole". The New York Times.
- "Jones v. Mississippi". Cornell Law School. October 29, 2020.
- Rizer, Arthur (November 3, 2020). "It's immoral to sentence a teenager to life in prison". Las Vegas Sun.
External links
- Text of Montgomery v. Louisiana, 577 U.S. 190 (2016) is available from: Justia Oyez (oral argument audio) Supreme Court