Misplaced Pages

1927-1928 Colorado Coal Strike
Part of the Coal Wars
Date	October 18, 1927 - May, 1928
Location	Colorado
Resulted in	Union victory, $1/day wage increase
Parties
Industrial Workers of the World Colorado Fuel & Iron Co. Rocky Mountain Fuel Co. Colorado Rangers Police Knights of Columbus Ku Klux Klan
Lead figures
Kristin Svanum A. S. Embree Adam Bell; Amelia Milka Sablich Jesse F. Welborn; Louis Scherf
Casualties and losses
Deaths: 8 killed Injured: ~20 Arrests: +10 Deaths:
Original basic wages before the strike were $6.27/day

The 1927–1928 Colorado Coal Strike was a spreading strike, spearheaded by the Industrial Workers of the World. The exact number of workers involved is unclear due to the nature of the strike. However, it shutdown nearly all of Colorado's coal mines.

Strike

The strike has its immediate beginnings in 1927 when the IWW called for a three-day nationwide walkout to protest the execution of Sacco and Vanzetti.

While the United Mine Workers predicted the IWW's walkout would fail in Colorado, Sheriff Harry Capps of Huerfano County commented that "fully two-thirds of the miners in the district members of the I.W.W." When the walkout occurred on August 8, 1927, out of a total 1,167 miners, 1,132 stayed off the job, and only 35 went to work. Under threat of injunction, the IWW leaders felt they'd demonstrated success, and they persuaded the miners to return to work one day early. Conlin wrote, "The tactical decision of the Wobblies was to give ground on this occasion to intensify organizing efforts for a statewide strike."

Organizing proceeded apace. In one mine, the Supervisor went to work one morning and discovered "Wobbly stickers pasted on every timber and cross beam in the place."

IWW leader Kristin Svanum met in a mass meeting with 187 delegates from 43 of the state's 125 mines to work out the miners' demands. Industrial Solidarity declared, "These mass meetings to be the legislative bodies of the strikers."

The rank and file miners were given full veto power over every aspect of the pending strike. The miners elected a General Strike Committee, which had the power to appoint all other committees, with only miners eligible for committee membership. While Wobbly organizers conducted the meetings, they had no vote in the miners' decisions.

The Wobblies were careful that the strike demands reflected only the immediate needs of the workers, rather than long range goals of the IWW. The perceptions expressed in the IWW Preamble coincided with the Colorado miners' personal experiences with capitalism, and also with their feelings about the United Mine Workers union which since 1914 had seemed to ignore their needs.

All national groupings were represented on the General Strike Committee—"Mexican, Slav, Spanish, Greek, Anglo, Italian, and Negro." There were so many different nationalities in the coal towns of Colorado due to corporate recruitment policy. After the coal strike of 1903–04, the companies intentionally recruited replacement miners who would have social, cultural, and language barriers to overcome before they could unite with other miners to form unions. But the IWW, always the champion of the immigrant and the ethnic worker, had readily overcome such challenges as early as the 1912 Lawrence Textile Strike.

'Docile' immigrant workers may have been a boon to industry, but invariably, such workers were ruthlessly exploited. In the mines, yesterday's perplexed new arrival often became today's militant unionist.

Immigrants aroused by injustice became targets. The Colorado newspapers railed against foreign workers and, alternately, an alleged foreign, or a lower class philosophy. For example, IWW leaders were called "tramps with their pants pressed." The Denver Morning Post criticized the strikers' spelling, their speech, their dress, their personal hygiene, and their values. The IWW responded by promoting international and ethnic solidarity. Organizers with Spanish surnames played a vital role. The more loudly the coal operators objected, the quicker the Wobbly message circulated.

The IWW was careful to follow the minutiae of Colorado law related to the pending strike, in an effort to keep the focus on the miners, rather than on the IWW itself. Nonetheless, the State Industrial Commission declared the pending strike illegal. This decision angered even established labor organizations who had not supported the strike up to that point. They considered it an affront to all of organized labor in Colorado.

IWW organizers were arrested, beaten, and robbed. Proclamations were passed by at least six city councils ordering the IWW to leave. IWW union halls were wrecked. Strike preparations proceeded unabated, and strike votes were held throughout the state. In Lafayette, so many people arrived at the meeting hall to endorse the pending strike that the vote was moved to the football field, and conducted under the headlights of trucks. The Denver Post estimated that 4,000 attended.

Along with the coal companies, the state, and many local communities, the United Mine Workers came out publicly against the pending strike. But the strike was called in spite of the opposition, and miners walked on October 18, 1927. The strike then continued to spread across the state. After two weeks of the Wobbly led strike, 113 Colorado coal mines had closed, and just 12 mines remained open. Joseph Conlin declared it the most successful strike in Colorado's history. The coal companies offered a non-negotiated pay increase of sixty-eight cents per day. This offer did not disrupt the strikers' motivation. On October 26, the Colorado Governor criticized the strike and called it illegal.

With IWW guidance, the General Strike Committee instructed the miners to commit no violence. The strike saw auto caravans of five hundred strikers traveling in more than a hundred vehicles, touring struck communities to dispense donated food and other provisions. This not only spread the strike, it kept up the strikers' morale. All participants were searched by their leaders for liquor or firearms before each activity.

Conlin quotes McClurg to observe that "Laws were broken, but selectively and with care." The state of Colorado banned picketing, but miners voted in mass meetings to ignore the state's ban. Colorado law outlawed red flags such as those long flown by the IWW, so the strikers carried American flags. In a further declaration of non-violent intent, the IWW admonished strikers, "If anyone is going to be killed, let it be one of our men first."

The Columbine mine, one of the larger of the few mines still working, granted a fifty cent per day pay raise. The IWW saw this as one major coal company weakening, but announced that it was not enough. The Wobblies organized massive marches to the Columbine, numbering from 500 to 1,200 miners plus their families. They sometimes brought a five piece brass band, and they sang union songs, satirizing the company and the police.

In one surprising episode during the strike, the IWW made an attempt to establish a workers' cooperative for striking miners at an abandoned mine. Two coal mine operators sought to demonstrate that such cooperatives were impossible, and they issued a challenge to the IWW to follow through at their facilities. However, they insisted that the IWW had to post a state-required safety bond within 24 hours, before it could reopen the mines. Since the IWW wasn't able to post the bond within the designated period, the experiment was not pursued.

Entire communities became organized during the 1927 strike, and they were capable of protracted militant action. However, a strike typically puts a dramatic strain on relationships within communities. Affected relationships are not just between strikers and business interests, or between strikers and non-strikers. During a coal strike, entire families are involved. One resident of a coal community spoke of the effect of the 1927 strike on students,

You'd think the coal miner was the dirtiest reptile that walked the earth. Everybody was down on the coal miner when he went on strike ... And the teachers were against us. And they had their favorites. The scabs' boys were in there too and, of course, we had gangs just like they do today. And the teachers would side with the scabs' side. Why hells bells man, we had to do something! So we organized (Junior Wobblies) at school just to protect ourselves.

The State of Colorado and local law enforcement began to arrest every strike leader that they could identify, on vagrancy or other trumped up charges. Many were deported from the state. In Trinidad, in Walsenberg, and elsewhere, members of strikers' families stepped forward to take the place of arrested leaders, and lead the strike.

Seventy-five IWW members in the Trinidad jail conducted protests that featured bonfires. Prisoners in the Lafayette jail carried on incessant singing. When they were offered their freedom, they refused to leave. A group of prisoners in Erie persuaded their jailers that deputies in Utah and Wyoming received higher pay, had better working conditions, and worked shorter hours. In Pueblo, the jail was secured by "200 deputies armed with tear bombs, machine guns, rifles, and fire engine pumpers."

Mine Massacre

Newspapers began calling for the governor to no longer withhold the "mailed fist", to strike hard and strike swiftly, and for "Machine Guns Manned By Willing Shooters" at more of the state's coal mines. Within days, on November 21, 1927, state police and mine guards fired machine guns, rifles, and pistols against 500 unarmed miners and their wives at the Columbine mine, killing six. This led to a brief secession of picketing as workers/IWW grieved. Now faced with their own massacre, the IWW's leaders kept their focus on the immediate goal: winning the strike. After the memorial services, when some angry miners talked about getting their guns, organizers counseled them with the words of Joe Hill: "don't mourn, organize!"

On November 26, 1927, 1,000 people gathered in Union Square, calling for the end of troop use and protesting against the recent killing of strikers. Following the Mine Massacre public pressure led to the starting of Colorado Industrial Commission formal hearings announced on December 12, 1927. The hearings were held from December 19, 1927 - February 15, 1928.

Other involvements

On December 27, 1927 Trinidad Mayor James G. Espey announced they would be deputizing civilians. During this it was accused that the Knights of Columbus and Ku Klux Klan were deputized. The day after this, the deputized police force lashed out with violence against the strikers.

Walsenburg Hall Killings

On January 12, 1928, two more people were killed by police raiding the IWW's Walsenburg IU 210-220 hall while strikers were rallying there.

A 15-year-old boy named Salastino Martinez and 40 year old wobbly Klementz Chavez were killed.

Aftermath

The miners won a dollar a day increase from the 1927 strike. The miners in the northern field won union recognition from the second largest coal operator in Colorado. It was not recognition of the IWW, as it turned out. The company picked a union for the miners, and it was the United Mine Workers. Nonetheless, these were the most substantial gains the miners had ever achieved from a strike in Colorado. It was the only increase obtained by coal miners in the country during the period from 1928 to 1930.

Although the United Mine Workers in Colorado had vocally opposed the strike, they had established an official position of neutrality. However, United Mine Workers agents conducted overt actions against the strikers, including participation in vigilante raids against IWW property. Some UMW miners scabbed on the IWW strike, and others became informants for the state police. One popular United Mine Workers official, a union organizer from the Ludlow era by the name of Mike Livoda, hired himself out to the governor to spy on the Wobblies.

The most pervasive spying during the 1927 strike was most probably conducted by Colorado Fuel and Iron, the coal and steel company owned by the Rockefeller dynasty The company organized a network of spies to infiltrate, propagandize against, and disrupt the IWW. Archives currently held at the Bessemer Historical Society reveal that the company used its spies and its relationship with the authorities to compile dossiers on union activists, and to obtain photographs, IWW membership lists, private union correspondence, and other union materials related to the strike.

Summing up the Colorado coal strike, Joseph Conlin concludes that Colorado coal miners were radical, based upon their experiences, and willfully chose to have the IWW lead them. In Conlin's words, "he failure of the Wobblies to establish and maintain a viable organization in Colorado resulted from the anarcho-syndicalist strategy of the IWW (i.e., no labor contracts, no union recognition), not from the absence of class consciousness and radicalism among the miners."

See also

• Colorado Coalfield War, 1913-1914
• Columbine Mine Massacre

References

1. Schreck, Christopher. "The Strike of 1927". Retrieved 6 November 2019.
2. "STATE TROOPS KEEP ORDER IN COLORADO; Striking Coal Miners Are Quiet Following Monday's Fatal Clash Near Denver. SAY THEY WILE AVOID FORCE National Guardsmen Quartered in Mines -- Civil Liberties Union Here Protests to Governor Adams". The New York Times. 1927-11-23.
3. Survey Associates; Charity Organization Society of the City of New York (February 15, 1928). The Survey. Prelinger Library. . pp. 644–646.
4. "Miners [offered] 50 cent a day wage increase; No change in workers tod'y". The Daily Times (Colorado). December 31, 1928.
5. McClurg (1963).
6. McClurg (1963), p. 71.
7. ^ McClurg (1963), p. 72.
8. Campbell-Hale, Leigh (2013). Remembering Ludlow but Forgetting the Columbine: The 1927-1928 Colorado Coal Strike (Thesis). ProQuest 1491383626.
9. "SACCO STRIKE BEGINS IN COLORADO MINES; I.W.W. Says 4,000 Are Out, but Coal Operators Insist Force Is 58 Per Cent. Normal". The New York Times. 1927-08-09.
10. "COLORADO STRIKE ENDING.; 1,500 Miners Out in Sacco Protest Are Expected Back Today". The New York Times. 1927-08-10.
11. ^ Conlin (1981), p. 199.
12. Margolis (2005), p. 31.
13. McClurg (1963), p. 73.
14. Myers (2005a), p. 132.
15. ^ McClurg (1963), p. 74.
16. ^ Conlin (1981), p. 200.
17. Conlin (1981), p. 195.
18. Margolis & Romero (1987), pp. 112–114.
19. Margolis & Romero (1987), p. 113.
20. ^ Myers (2005a), p. 136.
21. Phil Goodstein, Richard Myers, Slaughter in Serene, The Columbine Coal Strike Reader, Colorado's First Columbine Strike, and The Columbine Mine Massacre, pub. Bread and Roses Workers' Cultural Center and Industrial Workers of the World, 2005, pages 110, 135-136
22. "BOARD URGES UNIONS IN COLORADO MINES; Collective Bargaining Is Held a Means of Averting Future Coal Strikes. I.W.W. WALKOUT REVIEWED Lack of Organization of Miners Blamed in State Industrial Report for Outbreak". The New York Times. 1928-03-21.
23. ^ McClurg (1963), pp. 76–77.
24. "THREAT OF TROOPS QUIETS I.W.W. STRIKE; More Coal Mines Close in Colorado, but Violence Ends -- Martial Law Proclamation Ready". The New York Times. 1927-10-30.
25. Conlin (1981), pp. 200–201.
26. "I.W.W. Calls Out 4,000 Colorado Coal Miners; 18 Pickets Jailed as Northern Pits Close". The New York Times. 1927-10-19.
27. "COLORADO STRIKE SPREADS.; I.W.W. Leader Sees Gains -- Officers Narrowly Avert Disorder". The New York Times. 1927-10-25.
28. Richard Myers, Slaughter in Serene, The Columbine Coal Strike Reader, The Columbine Mine Massacre, pub. Bread and Roses Workers' Cultural Center and Industrial Workers of the World, 2005, page 132, from a report in the Denver Morning Post, November 1, 1927, page 4
29. "COLORADO GOVERNOR DENOUNCES THE I.W.W.; Warns That Picketing in Coal Strike Is Unlawful and State Will Keep Peace". The New York Times. 1927-10-27.
30. ^ McClurg (1963), p. 77.
31. ^ McClurg (1963), p. 79.
32. Joanna Sampson, "Slaughter in Serene, The Columbine Coal Strike Reader, Hawk Over November," pub. Bread and Roses Workers' Cultural Center and Industrial Workers of the World, 2005, page 59
33. ^ Conlin (1981), p. 201.
34. Richard Myers, "Slaughter in Serene, The Columbine Coal Strike Reader," pub. Bread and Roses Workers' Cultural Center and Industrial Workers of the World, 2005, page 140 and Appendix A
35. Phil Goodstein, "Slaughter in Serene, The Columbine Coal Strike Reader, Colorado's First Columbine Strike," pub. Bread and Roses Workers' Cultural Center and Industrial Workers of the World, 2005, page 116
36. Conlin (1981), p. 206.
37. Margolis & Romero (1987), p. 126.
38. Myers (2005b), p. 156.
39. Eric Margolis and Mary Romero, quoting Celeski, 1976, "The Greater Evil: The Role of Radical Unions in the End of Industrial Feudalism," Research in Social Policy, Volume 1, 1987, page 123
40. Myers (2005b), pp. 161–171.
41. Myers (2005a), pp. 134–135.
42. McClurg (1963), p. 82.
43. Denver Morning Post editorial, November 2, 1927, page 1
44. Boulder Daily Camera, November 17, 1927, page 2
45. Myers (2005a), pp. 138–139.
46. "STATE TROOPS KEEP ORDER IN COLORADO; Striking Coal Miners Are Quiet Following Monday's Fatal Clash Near Denver. SAY THEY WILE AVOID FORCE National Guardsmen Quartered in Mines -- Civil Liberties Union Here Protests to Governor Adams". The New York Times. 1927-11-23.
47. Myers (2005a), p. 142.
48. "1,000 PROTEST KILLING OF MINERS IN COLORADO; Mass Meeting in Union Square Telegraphs Governor Adams to End Use of Troops". The New York Times. 1927-11-27.
49. P. Marsh, Douglas (August 5, 2022). "Colorado and the IWW, Part III". IWW.org.
50. Bayard, Charles J. (1963). "The 1927-1928 Colorado Coal Strike". Pacific Historical Review. 32 (3): 235–250. doi:10.2307/4492179. ISSN 0030-8684. JSTOR 4492179.
51. P. Marsh, Douglas (August 5, 2022). "Colorado and the IWW, Part III".
52. Casey, Conor. "Library Guides: Industrial Workers of the World Photograph Collection: Colorado Mine Strike, 1927-1928". guides.lib.uw.edu (Warning, very graphic imagery present within source). Retrieved 2023-04-16.
53. ^ Conlin (1981), p. 203.
54. Margolis (2005), p. 47.
55. ^ Margolis (2005), p. 28.
56. Bayard, Charles J. (1963). "The 1927-1928 Colorado Coal Strike". Pacific Historical Review. 32 (3): 235–250. doi:10.2307/4492179. JSTOR 4492179.
57. ""X," "XX," and "X-3": Spy Reports from the Colorado Fuel & Iron Company". www.historycolorado.org. Retrieved 2023-03-05.
58. Conlin (1981), p. 210.

Works cited

• Conlin, Joseph R. (1981). At the Point of Production: The Local History of the IWW. Greenwood Press.
• Margolis, Eric; Romero, Mary (1987). Stanfield, John H. (ed.). The Greater Evil: The Role of Radical Unions in the End of Industrial Feudalism. Vol. 1. Research in Social Policy. JAI Press. ISBN 0892325216.
• Margolis, Eric (2005). May, Lowell A.; Myers, Richard (eds.). Colorado's Wobbly Strike. Slaughter in Serene: The Columbine Coal Strike Reader. Bread and Roses Workers' Cultural Center and Industrial Workers of the World. ISBN 0-917124-01-4.
• McClurg, Donald J. (1963). "The Colorado Coal Strike of 1927 -- Tactical Leadership of the IWW". Labor History. 4 (1): 68–92. doi:10.1080/00236566308583916.
• Myers, Richard (2005a). May, Lowell A.; Myers, Richard (eds.). The Columbine Mine Massacre. Bread and Roses Workers' Cultural Center and Industrial Workers of the World. ISBN 0-917124-01-4.
• Myers, Richard (2005b). May, Lowell A.; Myers, Richard (eds.). The Women of the 'Twenties Coal Strikes. Slaughter in Serene: The Columbine Coal Strike Reader. Bread and Roses Workers' Cultural Center and Industrial Workers of the World. ISBN 0-917124-01-4.

Notes

1. Basic wages does not include the amount workers were paid for output.

• Labor disputes in Colorado
• Miners' labor disputes in the United States
• Mining in Colorado
• Political repression in the United States
• Labor disputes led by the Industrial Workers of the World
• 1927 in Colorado
• 1928 in Colorado
• 1927 labor disputes and strikes
• 1928 labor disputes and strikes
• Industrial Workers of the World in Colorado
• 1920s strikes in the United States