Misplaced Pages

A Place for Wolves

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
Cancelled young adult novel by Kosoko Jackson

A Place for Wolves
Book cover
AuthorKosoko Jackson
LanguageEnglish
GenreRomantic thriller
Historical fiction
Young adult fiction
Set inKosovo
Publication placeUnited States
ISBN978-1-492-67365-1

A Place for Wolves is a young adult novel by Kosoko Jackson. Although the novel was scheduled to be published by Sourcebooks in 2019, it was canceled by Jackson soon before release when it faced backlash on social media for perceived insensitivities in its depiction of the Kosovo War. Media coverage examined the controversy through the frame of cancel culture.

Background

A Place for Wolves was to be Jackson's debut novel. He had previously worked as a sensitivity reader for major publishing companies, identifying content regarded as offensive or problematic in book manuscripts.

Jackson, a gay black man, had been an advocate of the #ownvoices movement, which promotes books with characters of diverse identities written by authors who share those identities. He had argued that "stories about the civil rights movement should be written by black people" and criticized female authors who "profit" from stories about gay men. Although Jackson had at one point been interested in writing a book that dealt with themes of immigration, he later changed his mind after speaking with friends who were Latino.

Jackson had also been a prominent critic of Blood Heir by Amélie Wen Zhao, a young adult novel that in January 2019 faced accusations of racial insensitivity on social media before its publication. In response, Zhao first canceled the book, then decided to postpone its release while making revisions.

Plot

The novel takes place during the Kosovo War of the late 1990s. It follows James Mills, a gay African American teenager who lives in the Kosovar village of Restelicë with his aid worker parents. When war breaks out in the region and he is separated from his parents, James attempts to flee with his Brazilian boyfriend Tomas to the safety of the U.S. embassy in Pristina.

Reception

Advance reviews

Prior to its publication date in March 2019, A Place for Wolves had received starred reviews from Booklist and School Library Journal. Booklist called the novel "a pulse-pounding, emotional roller coaster, showcasing Jackson’s ability to balance the tenderness of a love story against the complexities and horrors of a country at war." School Library Journal said that "Jackson has masterfully woven action, drama, and history in this fast-paced, impossible-to-put-down debut... The historical context of the Kosovo War is fleshed out accurately without overwhelming readers." The book was also selected for IndieBound's Spring 2019 "Kids' Indie Next" list.

Kirkus Reviews described A Place for Wolves as "an earnest freshman novel that celebrates love", but argued that the romance story was "incongruous with both the novel's setting and the dangerous events happening within the war-torn country." Wesley Jacques wrote in The Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books that the novel "oversimplified" the historical context with a "cartoonish" villain while lauding its "kickass queer representation".

The book's marketing included blurbs from young adult authors such as Shaun David Hutchinson, praising it as "a masterful debut," and Heidi Heilig, who called it "an intricate, rich story".

Reception on social media

Backlash to A Place for Wolves on social media began in February 2019 with a review posted on Goodreads. The review argued that the novel was insensitive because it emphasized the perspectives of Americans while using the war as merely a backdrop for the story. It criticized Jackson for writing about a largely Muslim country as a non-Muslim author with non-Muslim main characters.

In particular, the review condemned Jackson's choice to make the novel's villain an Albanian Muslim with the Kosovo Liberation Army (KLA), since Kosovo Albanians had been subject to widespread ethnic cleansing during the war and since it contributed to stereotypes about Muslims as terrorists. The review suggested that readers who enjoyed the novel might suffer from "subconscious Islamophobia" and argued that the book had potential to cause real-world harm.

The contents of the Goodreads review were quickly amplified and spread by members of Twitter's young adult fiction community. Since the book had not been released, most of those criticizing it had not read it. Heilig and others amended their formerly positive reviews, with Heilig apologizing "to those I've hurt by my blurb". Jackson's literary agent and the book's copy editor also apologized for their role in bringing the book to market. Jackson was dropped from the lineup of an upcoming literary festival and reportedly removed from a private Facebook group for young adult fiction.

Six days after the Goodreads review was posted, Jackson released a statement apologizing for the novel's "problematic representation and historical insensitivities", writing: "I failed to fully understand the people and the conflict that I set around my characters. I have done a disservice to the history and to the people who suffered." Jackson also announced that he had asked Sourcebooks to withdraw A Place for Wolves from publication. At the time of his announcement, 55,000 copies of the book had already been printed.

Reactions to the controversy

Following the backlash on social media, commentators took an interest in the book's artistic merits. Jennifer Senior of The New York Times said that although Jackson "can write with charm and the authentic sass of an American adolescent, much of the book is painfully clumsy and poorly paced — which makes it a fairly typical debut novel, by the way." After obtaining an advance copy of the book, journalist Jesse Singal wrote in Reason that A Place for Wolves "isn't great, but it didn't deserve to be canceled." He called Jackson's writing "clunky" and the book's characters "poorly developed," criticizing it for the "flatness" of the wartime setting.

Singal also mentioned several elements of the backlash to A Place for Wolves that he said were "untrue or exaggerated". For one, Singal questioned the interpretation that the villain was Muslim; he claimed that the villain's religion was not mentioned in the novel and the character did not fit the stereotypical "Muslim terrorist" trope. In addition, Singal took a more nuanced stance on the Kosovo War than many of the book's critics, who saw Albanians merely as victims of the conflict. He observed that while the opposing Serbian forces had perpetrated the majority of wartime atrocities, the KLA had also murdered civilians and committed other war crimes.

Multiple commentators noted the ferocity of the criticism from some of the book's detractors. Singal said that after covering the controversy on his Twitter account, he was subject to personal attacks from author L.L. McKinney. Senior described the young adult fiction community on Twitter as "a hothouse subculture — self-conscious, emotional, quick to injure." Ruth Graham of Slate criticized the incident as an example of the "increasingly toxic online culture" in young adult literature, "with evermore-baroque standards for who can write about whom under what circumstances."

Analysis

Media coverage of A Place for Wolves' cancellation mainly examined it through the lens of cancel culture and online shaming. Katy Waldman wrote in The New Yorker that the debate surrounding the book "seems rooted in who gets to speak, and when, and how much power their words can wield". Waldman noted the irony that Jackson had previously been involved in assessing and calling out books for controversial content before becoming entangled in controversy himself.

The New York Times' Jennifer Senior called the incident "frightening", saying that A Place for Wolves "should have failed or succeeded in the marketplace of ideas" instead of being canceled outright. Senior predicted that attacking authors in the name of diversity would paradoxically lead to an overly censored "dreary monoculture" in book publishing.

Ruth Graham, in Slate, viewed the uproar over books such as A Place for Wolves and Blood Heir as counterproductive. Graham observed that the authors of both works were "people of color who now see their careers hobbled in an industry that claims to be laser-focused on diversity." She also remarked that those involved in these disputes were not the book's supposed audience of teenagers, but adults "shredding each other’s reputations under the guise of protecting the children."

In an article for Reason, Jesse Singal characterized the online critics of A Place for Wolves and other controversial young adult novels as "left-wing identitarians" who believed that "the more marginalized you are, the better you are as a person." Singal claimed that these critics were a highly vocal minority of young adult fiction readers on social media, making their views appear deceptively popular to publishers and authors and making it more difficult to identify truly problematic content.

The New Republic contributing editor Osita Nwanevu disagreed with the notion that Jackson had been a "casualty of cancel culture". Nwanevu noted that Jackson, not the publisher, had decided to cancel the book's publication, and that Jackson still had another novel set for release.

See also

References

  1. ^ Graham, Ruth (March 4, 2019). "Wolves". Slate. Archived from the original on September 25, 2023. Retrieved December 24, 2023.
  2. Vartan, Kristin (November 20, 2019). "A timeline of 2019's 5 biggest YA controversies". Entertainment Weekly. Archived from the original on December 23, 2023. Retrieved December 24, 2023.
  3. ^ Waldman, Katy (March 21, 2019). "In Y.A., Where Is the Line Between Criticism and Cancel Culture?". The New Yorker. Archived from the original on December 21, 2023. Retrieved December 24, 2023.
  4. ^ Senior, Jennifer (March 8, 2019). "Teen Fiction and the Perils of Cancel Culture". The New York Times. Archived from the original on December 19, 2023. Retrieved December 24, 2023.
  5. ^ Singal, Jesse (June 2019). "Teen Fiction Twitter Is Eating Its Young". Reason. Archived from the original on December 2, 2023. Retrieved December 24, 2023.
  6. ^ Singal, Jesse (February 28, 2019). "He Was Part of a Twitter Mob That Attacked Young Adult Novelists. Then It Turned on Him. Now His Book Is Canceled". Reason. Archived from the original on December 23, 2023. Retrieved December 24, 2023.
  7. Alter, Alexandra (April 29, 2019). "She Pulled Her Debut Book When Critics Found It Racist. Now She Plans to Publish". The New York Times. Archived from the original on March 5, 2024. Retrieved April 14, 2024.
  8. ^ Singal, Jesse (March 15, 2019). "A Review of a Book That Will Never Be Published, Thanks to the Young Adult Twitter Mob". Reason. Archived from the original on November 1, 2023. Retrieved December 24, 2023.
  9. Bittner, Rob (February 1, 2019). "A Place for Wolves". Booklist. 115 (11): 72.
  10. Peebles, Donald (February 2019). "JACKSON, Kosoko. A Place for Wolves". School Library Journal. 65 (1): 74.
  11. "Indie Next List | IndieBound.org". IndieBound. Archived from the original on June 8, 2019. Retrieved May 15, 2024.
  12. "Jackson, Kosoko: A PLACE FOR WOLVES". Kirkus Reviews. 87 (4). February 15, 2019.
  13. Jacques, Wesley (2019). "A Place for Wolves by Kosoko Jackson". Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books. 72 (6): 259. doi:10.1353/bcc.2019.0106. ISSN 1558-6766. Archived from the original on July 9, 2022.
  14. ^ Lukianoff, Greg; Schlott, Rikki (2023). The Canceling of the American Mind: How Cancel Culture Undermines Trust, Destroys Institutions, and Threatens Us All. Simon & Schuster. pp. 242–244. ISBN 978-1668019146.
  15. Rothstein, Katie (February 28, 2019). "Another YA Author Withdraws Book From Publication After Backlash". Vulture. Archived from the original on February 7, 2023. Retrieved December 24, 2023.
  16. Fry Schultz, Madeline (March 4, 2019). "How identity-obsessed Twitter mobs make writers pull their own books from publication". Washington Examiner. Archived from the original on May 8, 2024. Retrieved May 8, 2024.
  17. Benedictus, Leo (June 15, 2019). "Torn apart: the vicious war over young adult books". The Guardian. Archived from the original on October 9, 2023. Retrieved December 24, 2023.
  18. Rosenfield, Kat (April 9, 2019). "What Is #OwnVoices Doing To Our Books?". Refinery29. Archived from the original on July 15, 2020. Retrieved May 11, 2024.
  19. Nwanevu, Osita (September 23, 2019). "The "Cancel Culture" Con". The New Republic. Archived from the original on November 14, 2023. Retrieved December 26, 2023.
Categories: