John Zerzan - Misplaced Pages

(Redirected from Against Civilization) American anarchist and primitivist philosopher

John Zerzan
Zerzan in 2010
Born	August 10, 1943 (1943-08-10) (age 81) Salem, Oregon, U.S.
Alma mater	Stanford University San Francisco State University University of Southern California

Era	Contemporary philosophy
Region	Western philosophy
School	Anarcho-primitivism, post-left anarchy
Main interests	Hunter-gatherer society, civilization, alienation, symbolic culture, technology, mass society
Notable ideas	Domestication of humans, rewilding

John Edward Zerzan (/ˈzɜːrzən/ ZUR-zən; born August 10, 1943) is an American anarchist and primitivist author. His works criticize agricultural civilization as inherently oppressive, and advocates drawing upon the ways of life of hunter-gatherers as an inspiration for what a free society should look like. Subjects of his criticism include domestication and symbolic thought (such as language, number, art and the concept of time).

His six major books are Elements of Refusal (1988), Future Primitive and Other Essays (1994), Running on Emptiness (2002), Against Civilization: Readings and Reflections (2005), Twilight of the Machines (2008), and Why hope? The Stand Against Civilization (2015).

Green anarchism
Part of a series on

Schools of thought Anarcho-primitivism Deep ecology Green syndicalism Social ecology Total liberation
Theory and practice Animal rights Anti-authoritarianism Anti-capitalism Anti-consumerism Bioregionalism Decentralization Degrowth Deindustrialization Direct action Ecocentrism Environmental protection Municipalism Naturalism Neo-Luddism Neo-Malthusianism Primitive communism Radical environmentalism Return to nature Rewilding Simple living Unity in diversity
People Abbey Bari Best Biehl Bookchin Camenisch Carter Glendinning Jensen Kropotkin Morris Næss Perlman Reclus Sale Semprún Snyder Thoreau Zerzan
Books and publications Walden, or life in the woods (1854) Fields, Factories, and Workshops (1899) Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution (1902) Post-Scarcity Anarchism (1971) The Ecology of Freedom (1982) Green Anarchist (1984) Future Primitive and Other Essays (1994)
Related topics Anarchism Anti-capitalism Anti-consumerism Eco-socialism Green politics Libertarian socialism Naturism
Anarchism portal Environment portal Politics portal
v t e

Early life and education

Zerzan was born in Salem, Oregon, and is of Czech and Slovakian descent. He received his bachelor's degree in political science from Stanford University in 1966. From 1967 to 1970, Zerzan worked as a union organizer for the Social Service Employees’ Union in San Francisco. Zerzan returned to school and received a master's degree in history from San Francisco State University in 1972. He completed his coursework towards a PhD at the University of Southern California but dropped out in 1975 before completing his dissertation.

Activism

In 1966, Zerzan was arrested while performing civil disobedience at a Berkeley anti-Vietnam War march and spent two weeks in the Contra Costa County Jail. He vowed after his release never again to be willingly arrested. He attended events organized by Ken Kesey and the Merry Pranksters and was involved with the psychedelic drug and music scene in San Francisco's Haight-Ashbury neighborhood.

In the late 1960s he worked as a social worker for the city of San Francisco welfare department. He helped organize a social workers’ union, the SSEU, and was elected vice president in 1968, and president in 1969. The local Situationist group Contradiction denounced him as a "leftist bureaucrat".

In 1974, Black and Red Press published Unions Against Revolution by Spanish ultra-left theorist Grandizo Munis that included an essay by Zerzan which previously appeared in the journal Telos. Over the next 20 years, Zerzan became intimately involved with the Fifth Estate, Anarchy: A Journal of Desire Armed, Demolition Derby and other anarchist periodicals. He began to question civilization in the early 80s, after having sought to confront issues around the neutrality of technology and division of labour, at the time when Fredy Perlman was making similar conclusions. He saw civilization itself as the root of the problems of the world and that a hunter-gatherer form of society presented the most egalitarian model for human relations with themselves and the natural world.

Zerzan became more widely known during the trial of Ted Kaczynski. After reading the Unabomber manifesto, Zerzan went to Colorado to experience the trial and meet with Kaczynski in-between proceedings. The New York Times reporter Kenneth B. Noble took interest in Zerzan's sympathies and published an interview titled "Prominent Anarchist Finds Unsought Ally in Serial Bomber" that raised his national profile. Kaczynski eventually split from Zerzan and the anarcho-primitivists with the belief that leftist causes were a distraction.

In a 2014 interview, Zerzan stated that he and Kaczynski were "not on terms anymore." He criticized his former friend's 2008 essay "The Truth About Primitive Life: A Critique of Anarchoprimitivism" and expressed disapproval of Individuals Tending Towards the Wild, a Mexican group influenced by the Unabomber's bombing campaign.

In 2014, Zerzan engaged in a public debate against Zoltan Istvan at Stanford University. Zerzan and Istvan hold differing views on technology, with Istvan stating on HuffPost that their views on the subject are polar opposites of each-other. Zerzan is an anarcho-primitivist and therefore considers technology inherently harmful to humanity, animals and nature and Planet Earth more generally. Istvan is a transhumanist and considers technology as a beneficial to humanity, animals and nature and Planet Earth more generally.

Zerzan was associated with the Eugene, Oregon anarchist scene.

Thought

Zerzan is an anarchist philosopher, and is broadly associated with the philosophies of anarcho-primitivism, green anarchism, anti-civilisation, post-left anarchy, neo-luddism, and in particular the critique of technology.

Zerzan has accused linguist and activist Noam Chomsky of not being a real anarchist, saying that he is instead "a liberal-leftist politically, and downright reactionary in his academic specialty, linguistic theory. Chomsky is also, by all accounts, a generous, sincere, tireless activist -- which does not, unfortunately, ensure his thinking has liberatory value."

Radio show

One method Zerzan uses to promote his Anarcho-primitivist ideas is with his radio show AnarchyRadio on KWVA at 88.1 FM in Eugene, Oregon and live-streamed worldwide by the station's website with archive recordings of full shows available on John Zerzan's own website. Zerzan's website states that he started the show in 2000 although the recorded archive of shows on the site only goes back to 2006. Zerzan's show airs live on Tuesdays on KWVA at 7pm PST and lasts an hour. Besides Zerzan himself, AnarchyRadio occasionally has a co-host with Zerzan and also fills in for Zerzan entirely when he is on speaking tours. AnarchyRadio is a call-in show and listeners can phone KWVA during the show and talk to the host(s) live. Until 2024, AnarchyRadio aired every Tuesday. Since 2024, AnarchyRadio now only airs on the second and fourth Tuesdays of the month. This new scheduling was introduced unofficially in February with an announcement at the end of the February 27 airing and later became official when Zerzan announced it at the start of the March 26 airing, claiming it was "more manageable" for him at his age of 80 years.

In 2014, AnarchyRadio gained unwanted media attention when it was discovered by the New York Daily News that Adam Lanza (who was the infamous shooter in the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting in 2012) once called the show in December 2011 and spoke to Zerzan live on air. Lanza called during the December 20 2011 show. Lanza did not use his real name and gave his name as "Greg" while calling Zerzan. Lanza also disguised his voice while calling as "Greg". During the seven minute call, Greg/Lanza talked about the chimpanzee Travis who lived in Lanza's home state of Connecticut and was notorious for an incident in 2009 where he tore off the face of Charla Nash (a friend of Sandra Herold, who kept Travis in her home as a pet) and was shot and killed shortly after 911 was called to house for help. This incident was considered as shocking because Travis raised by humans his whole life and was very friendly towards them. During the call, Greg/Lanza said that he was a fan of Zerzan's work and stated that Travis was not "an untamed monster" but was actually "civilized. He was able to integrate into society." One comment by Lanza drew particular attention from media in light of his actions was "I just don't think it would be such a stretch to say that he very well could have been a teenage mall shooter or something like that." A day later, Lanza posted on the online forum Shocked Beyond Belief under the username "Smiggles" about the call to Zerzan. In an interview with TV station KMTR shortly the call surfaced, Zerzan stated that Lanza mentioning shooting "and then again later he ends up doing it, I mean it's just hard to grasp." Zerzan also notes that "it's tough to wrap your mind around, but then when you realize you spoke with the guy or listened to the guy, it's all the more upsetting."

Criticism

In his essay "Social Anarchism or Lifestyle Anarchism: An Unbridgeable Chasm", Murray Bookchin directed criticism from an anarchist point of view at Zerzan's anti-civilizational and anti-technological perspective. He argued that Zerzan's representation of hunter-gatherers was flawed, selective and often patronisingly racist, that his analysis was superficial, and that his practical proposals were nonsensical.

Aside from Bookchin, several other anarchist critiques of Zerzan's primitivist philosophies exist. The pamphlet, "Anarchism vs. Primitivism" by Brian Oliver Sheppard criticizes many aspects of the primitivist philosophy. It specifically rejects the claim that primitivism is a form of anarchism.

Some authors such as Andrew Flood have argued that destroying civilization would lead to the death of a significant majority of the population, mainly in poor countries. John Zerzan responded to such claims by suggesting a gradual decrease in population size, with the possibility of people having the need to seek means of sustainability more close to nature.

Flood suggests this contradicts Zerzan's claims elsewhere, and adds that, since it is certain that most people will strongly reject Zerzan's supposed utopia, it can only be implemented by authoritarian means, against the will of billions.

In his essay "Listen Anarchist!", Chaz Bufe criticized the primitivist position from an anarchist perspective, pointing out that primitivists are extremely vague about exactly which technologies they advocate keeping and which they seek to abolish, noting that smallpox had been eradicated thanks to medical technology.

In an essay called "Anarchism = Zerzan?", socialist economist Michael Albert critiques Zerzan's perspectives on concepts such as language, division of labour, and technology, instead saying that Zerzan's argument rests on these concepts being inherently wrong, instead of, as Albert argues, being neutral concepts that can be utilised morally or immorally.

Early life and education

Activism

Thought

Radio show

Criticism

Selected works

Books and pamphlets

Articles

See also

References

Further reading

External links