Banner in the Sky is a book written by James Ramsey Ullman published by the J. B. Lippincott Company in 1954. The story is based on the first ascent of the Matterhorn and follows the young boy Rudi Matt who is determined to climb the citadel. The book was a runner-up for a Newbery Award in 1955 and was later adapted into the Disney film Third Man on the Mountain.
Background
The book was published by the J. B. Lippincott Company in 1954. The book was inspired by a real-life event in 1865 when an Englishman named Edward Whymper became the first to climb the Matterhorn. During Whymper's descent from the mountain, four of his companions died. Shortly before writing the book, Ullman had taken a trip to the Swiss Alps with his son and climbed the mountain himself. The book inspired a Canadian dentist to also climb the Matterhorn.
Plot
The story is set in Switzerland in the small town of Kurtal at the base of a mountain called the Citadel. Josef Matt died in an attempt to scale the mountain fifteen years ago and no one has attempted the climb since. Sixteen-year-old Rudi Matt is determined to carry his father's red shirt to the top of the Citadel despite his family's reservations. However, Rudi can convince two of the town's best guides to join him with the help of the English Captain Winter. Rudi is picked on by the other boys because he is small and does not have the complexion of a rough mountaineer. Rudi is familiar with the lower slopes of the Citadel and is eager to prove that he can conquer the mountain. Rudi had been studying the lower slopes of the mountain with the help of his coworker Teo, a crippled old cook who had assisted Josef Matt on the expedition that led to his death. Rudi would sneak out after work and practice climbing.
Reception
Robert G. Carlsen noted in his review of the book that Rudi's rebellious attitude may be questionable to the adult reader, but that the book is "unquestionably a fine boy's story". The novel received a favorable review from Laura Scott Meyers in the El Paso Herald-Post, however, she was more impressed by Ullman's previous work—The White Tower. The book was the runner-up for a Newbery Award in 1955.
References
- ^ Fitzpatrick, Stephen (March 18, 2019). "'Banner in the Sky': One of the Best-kept Secrets in Children's Literature". Crisis Magazine. Sophia Institute Press. Retrieved October 23, 2023.
- ^ Meyers, Laura Scott, ed. (September 18, 1954). "The Bookshelf". El Paso Herald-Post. E. W. Scripps Company. p. 4 – via Newspaper Archive.
- Lent, Henry B. (September 12, 1954). "The Challenge; 'Banner in the Sky'. By James Ramsey Ullman". The New York Times. p. 252. ProQuest 113057091. Also available from TimesMachine (subscription required)
- Craggs, Samantha (August 25, 2007). "Conquering a boyhood dream". The Belleville Intelligencer. Postmedia Network. p. C1. Archived from the original on June 22, 2024. Retrieved February 9, 2024 – via ProQuest.
- Shefelman, Janice (December 29, 1984). "Ullman Classic Delivers: Books For Kids". Austin American-Statesman. Gannett. Retrieved February 9, 2024 – via newspapers.com.
- F., A. W. (January 16, 1960). "Books to Stimulate the Minds of Eager, Older Children". Canberra Times. Australian Community Media. p. 11 – via Newspaper Archive.
- Arbuthnot, Mary Hill (1955). "Books for Children". Elementary English. 32 (1). National Council of Teachers of English: 61–62. JSTOR 41384299.
- Chan, Emily (September 3, 1997). "Emily's back to school book is about the Alps; what will you read?". Vancouver Sun. Postmedia Network. p. D15. ISSN 0832-1299. Retrieved February 9, 2024 – via newspapers.com.
- Carlsen, G. Robert (1954). "For Individual Reading". The English Journal. 43 (8). National Council of Teachers of English: 476–477. JSTOR 809397.
- Jenkins, William A. (1955). "The Educational Scene". Elementary English. 32 (5). National Council of Teachers of English: 335. JSTOR 41384366.
- Goodwin, Polly (March 13, 1955). "The Junior Bookshelf". Chicago Tribune. Tribune Publishing. p. 220. Retrieved February 9, 2024 – via newspapers.com.