Misplaced Pages

Bill Evans at Town Hall
Live album by The Bill Evans Trio
Released	1966
Recorded	February 21, 1966
Venue	The Town Hall, New York City
Genre	Jazz
Length	35:12
Label	Verve
The Bill Evans Trio chronology
Bill Evans Trio with Symphony Orchestra (1966) Bill Evans at Town Hall (1966) Intermodulation (1966)

Bill Evans at Town Hall is a live album from 1966 by American jazz pianist Bill Evans and his trio. It is his only commercial trio recording featuring drummer Arnold Wise, and it was the last recorded appearance of bassist Chuck Israels as a regular member of the trio.

The recording was released as "Volume 1," but no subsequent volume appeared. A planned release of big-band material, featuring Evans, from the second half of the concert ended up being nixed, as according to Evans's manager, Helen Keane, the pianist "did not play his best" during that part of the program.

The original LP consisted of four trio performances of jazz standards followed by a lengthy solo elegy for Evans's recently deceased father. Verve Records released the album on CD in 1986 with three additional trio performances, including the first recording of Evans's composition "One for Helen," dedicated to his manager.

Arnold Wise

Israels highly valued the contributions of drummer Arnold Wise, saying, "He's like a catalytic drummer, instigating nothing but taking everything in his musical surroundings and gluing it together, melding the elements." However, Wise disliked travel and, according to Peter Pettinger, "remained uncommitted to the job." Wise did later rejoin the Bill Evans Trio for six months, including a European tour. Some additional trio recordings with "Arnie" Wise were eventually released by Milestone Records in 1996 on the 8-CD set The Secret Sessions, and his playing on these was highly praised by Pettinger. Evans worked with various other drummers in the late '60s, including Philly Joe Jones and Jack DeJohnette, before finally achieving stability in this respect with Marty Morell starting in late 1968.

Reception

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic
The Rolling Stone Jazz Record Guide
The Penguin Guide to Jazz Recordings

Writing for AllMusic, music critic Scott Yanow called the album "a superior effort by Bill Evans and his trio in early 1966. ... his live set features the group mostly performing lyrical and thoughtful standards. ... However the most memorable piece is the 13½-minute 'Solo - In Memory of His Father,' an extensive unaccompanied exploration by Evans that partly uses a theme that became 'Turn Out the Stars.'"

The lengthy solo also features a newly composed "Prologue," somewhat reminiscent of Satie and Debussy, an elaborated version of "Re: Person I Knew," now titled "Story Line," and a closing "Epilogue" drawn from the 1958 album Everybody Digs Bill Evans. Keith Shadwick highly praised this solo Evans performance for its "great intensity and almost infinite gradations of feeling, touch, tone, rhythmic adjustments and emphases. The overall mood of the music is elegiac, the melancholy at its heart becoming progressively darker and more intense until, touching despair, it is resolved by the enigmatic 'Epilogue,' newly poignant in its latest role."

Evans biographer Peter Pettinger notes that "'Turn Out the Stars' was to endure and to become arguably Evans's second-greatest classic after 'Waltz for Debby.'"

'Turn Out the Stars'

Evans composed "Turn Out the Stars" with lyrics by his friend Gene Lees, who had also contributed the words for "Waltz for Debby." Lees said the title was inspired by an old movie called Turn Off the Moon. Contrary to widespread belief, the piece was not originally composed in connection with the death of Evans's father; it was only used that way later on this album. The piece remained an integral part of Evans's repertoire until the end of his career, with notable later standalone recordings (i.e., not part of the suite for his father) appearing on the albums Intermodulation with Jim Hall and the live trio recording Since We Met. There are also many later live Evans trio recordings of it in circulation, released after the pianist's death, including no fewer than 14 versions with his final trio during just the last year of his life.

This signature piece has subsequently been covered many times by other notable jazz artists, including Clare Fischer (1987), David Benoit (1989), Gary Burton and Paul Bley (1990), Fred Hersch (1991), Lee Konitz (1993), John McLaughlin (1993), Art Farmer (1994), Herbie Mann (1995), Dave Grusin (2010), and Chick Corea (2011); in addition, transcriptions of the piece have been recorded by classical artists, including the Kronos Quartet (1986) and Jean-Yves Thibaudet (1997), who frequently played it in recitals as an encore.

Evans never recorded a version of the piece with a vocalist, and Lees noted that the melody is "dark" and "very hard to sing." A vocal performance appears on Tierney Sutton's tribute album Blue in Green from 2001.

Track listing

Side one

1. "I Should Care" (Sammy Cahn, Axel Stordahl, Paul Weston) – 5:30
2. "Spring Is Here" (Richard Rodgers, Lorenz Hart) – 5:00
3. "Who Can I Turn To?" (Leslie Bricusse, Anthony Newley) – 6:17

Side two

1. "Make Someone Happy" (Betty Comden, Adolph Green, Jule Styne) – 4:45
2. "Solo - In Memory of His Father Harry L. (Prologue/Improvisation on Two Themes/Story Line/Turn Out the Stars/Epilogue)" (Evans) – 13:40

Reissue

1. "I Should Care" (Sammy Cahn, Axel Stordahl, Paul Weston) – 5:30
2. "Spring Is Here" (Richard Rodgers, Lorenz Hart) – 5:00
3. "Who Can I Turn To?" (Leslie Bricusse, Anthony Newley) – 6:17
4. "Make Someone Happy" (Betty Comden, Adolph Green, Jule Styne) – 4:45
5. "Solo - In Memory of His Father Harry L. (Prologue/Story Line/Turn Out the Stars/Epilogue)" (Evans) – 13:40
6. "Beautiful Love" (Haven Gillespie, Wayne King, Egbert Van Alstyne, Victor Young) – 6:56
7. "My Foolish Heart" (Ned Washington, Victor Young) – 4:51
8. "One for Helen" (Evans) – 5:51

Structure of the solo

The lengthy solo performance "Solo - In Memory of His Father Harry L." is essentially a suite, consisting of four discrete parts:

1. "Prologue" (0:00–2:39)
2. "Story Line" aka "Re: Person I Knew" (2:40–7:30)
3. "Turn Out the Stars" (7:31–12:28)
4. "Epilogue" (12:29–13:09)

(The remainder of the track consists of applause.)

Personnel

• Bill Evans – piano
• Chuck Israels – bass (except track 5)
• Arnold Wise – drums (except track 5)

Chart positions

References

1. "Bill Evans Discography," https://www.jazzdisco.org/bill-evans/discography/, Accessed 23 June 2024.
2. Pettinger, Peter, Bill Evans: How My Heart Sings, Yale University Press, 1998, p. 173.
3. Pettinger, p. 172.
4. "Bill Evans Discography."
5. Pettinger, p. 173.
6. Pettinger, p. 183
7. Pettinger, p. 187.
8. Bill Evans Discography."
9. Pettinger, p. 183.
10. "Bill Evans Discography."
11. ^ Yanow, Scott. "Bill Evans at Town Hall Review". AllMusic. Retrieved June 28, 2011.
12. Swenson, J., ed. (1985). The Rolling Stone Jazz Record Guide. USA: Random House/Rolling Stone. p. 74. ISBN 0-394-72643-X.
13. Cook, Richard; Morton, Brian (2008). The Penguin Guide to Jazz Recordings (9th ed.). Penguin. p. 457. ISBN 978-0-141-03401-0.
14. Pettinger, p. 172.
15. Shadwick, Keith, Bill Evans: Everything Happens to Me, Backbeat Books (2002), p. 129.
16. Pettinger, p. 173.
17. Pettinger, p. 151.
18. Pettinger, p. 172.
19. "Bill Evans Discography."
20. "Turn Out the Stars," https://secondhandsongs.com/work/120288/versions#nav-entity, Accessed 28 June 2024.
21. Distler, Jed, "Jean-Yves Thibaudet Plays Bill Evans," liner notes to Conversations with Bill Evans (London, 1997), p. 8.
22. Pettinger, p. 151.
23. "Blue in Green" from "Recordings," https://tierneysutton.com/tierney-sutton-discography/tierney-sutton-blue-in-green/, Accessed 28 June 2024.

External links

• The Bill Evans Memorial Library

• Bill Evans live albums
• 1966 live albums
• Verve Records live albums
• Albums recorded at the Town Hall