- 2024 – Ryan Hunter (OT/G), Toronto Argonauts
- 2023 – Dejon Allen (OT), Toronto Argonauts
- 2022 – Stanley Bryant (OT), Winnipeg Blue Bombers
- 2021 – Stanley Bryant (OT), Winnipeg Blue Bombers
- 2020 – season cancelled - COVID-19
- 2019 – Chris Van Zeyl (OT), Hamilton Tiger-Cats
- 2018 – Stanley Bryant (OT), Winnipeg Blue Bombers
- 2017 – Stanley Bryant (OT), Winnipeg Blue Bombers
- 2016 – Derek Dennis (OT), Calgary Stampeders
- 2015 – SirVincent Rogers (OT), Ottawa RedBlacks
- 2014 – Brett Jones (C), Calgary Stampeders
- 2013 – Brendon LaBatte (OG), Saskatchewan Roughriders
- 2012 – Jovan Olafioye (OT), BC Lions
- 2011 – Josh Bourke (OT), Montreal Alouettes
- 2010 – Ben Archibald (OT), Calgary Stampeders
- 2009 – Scott Flory (OG), Montreal Alouettes
- 2008 – Scott Flory (OG), Montreal Alouettes
- 2007 – Rob Murphy (OT), BC Lions
- 2006 – Rob Murphy (OT), BC Lions
- 2005 – Gene Makowsky (OT), Saskatchewan Roughriders
- 2004 – Gene Makowsky (OT), Saskatchewan Roughriders
- 2003 – Andrew Greene (OG), Saskatchewan Roughriders
- 2002 – Bryan Chiu (C), Montreal Alouettes
- 2001 – Dave Mudge (OT), Winnipeg Blue Bombers
- 2000 – Pierre Vercheval (OG), Montreal Alouettes
- 1999 – Uzooma Okeke (OT), Montreal Alouettes
|
- 1998 – Fred Childress (OG), Calgary Stampeders
- 1997 – Mike Kiselak (C), Toronto Argonauts
- 1996 – Mike Kiselak (C), Toronto Argonauts
- 1995 – Mike Withycombe (OG), Baltimore Stallions
- 1994 – Shar Pourdanesh (OT), Baltimore CFLers
- 1993 – Chris Walby (OT), Winnipeg Blue Bombers
- 1992 – Robert Smith (OT), Ottawa Rough Riders
- 1991 – Jim Mills (OT), BC Lions
- 1990 – Jim Mills (OT), BC Lions
- 1989 – Rod Connop (C), Edmonton Eskimos
- 1988 – Roger Aldag (OG), Saskatchewan Roughriders
- 1987 – Chris Walby (OT), Winnipeg Blue Bombers
- 1986 – Roger Aldag (OG), Saskatchewan Roughriders
- 1985 – Nick Bastaja (OT), Winnipeg Blue Bombers
- 1984 – John Bonk (C), Winnipeg Blue Bombers
- 1983 – Rudy Phillips (OG), Ottawa Rough Riders
- 1982 – Rudy Phillips (OG), Ottawa Rough Riders
- 1981 – Larry Butler (OG), Winnipeg Blue Bombers
- 1980 – Mike Wilson (OT), Edmonton Eskimos
- 1979 – Mike Wilson (OT), Edmonton Eskimos
- 1978 – Jim Coode (OT), Ottawa Rough Riders
- 1977 – Al Wilson (C), BC Lions
- 1976 – Dan Yochum (OT), Montreal Alouettes
- 1975 – Charlie Turner (OT), Edmonton Eskimos
- 1974 – Ed George (OG), Montreal Alouettes
|
