The Carlos Bandeirense Mirandópolis hoax involved a false article created on the Portuguese Misplaced Pages. The "Carlos Bandeirense Mirandópolis" page was created in 2010 by two Brazilian lawyers who wanted to prank an intern. The article claimed that Mirandópolis was a Brazilian jurist and professor who had met the composer Chico Buarque and participated in the Diretas Já movement. Mirandópolis ended up being cited in a decision by the Rio de Janeiro Court of Justice [pt] (TJ-RJ), in a documentary about Diretas Já, and in an undergraduate thesis. The page was deleted in 2016 after a report was published on the G1 news portal and aired on the GloboNews television channel. Professors cited the case as a reason to be cautious with information found on the Internet.
Article
The article on Carlos Bandeirense Mirandópolis was created on the Portuguese Misplaced Pages on August 16, 2010, by two Brazilian lawyers, Victor Nóbrega Luccas and Daniel Tavela Luís. Realizing that it was common for interns to take information from the Internet without verification, they created the article to prank one of them. They asked the intern to research the "Public Association Offer" theory, which does not exist. To give more credibility to the false theory, they created a page for Mirandópolis, identifying him as its author. According to the article, Mirandópolis was a jurist and professor at the Faculty of Law of the Pontifical Catholic University of São Paulo (PUC-SP). He would have been persecuted during the Brazilian military dictatorship and exiled in Paris. There, he would have met the composer Chico Buarque and inspired his composition "Samba de Orly [pt]". The article also said that Mirandópolis later returned to Brazil and actively participated in the Diretas Já movement. The article included a photo of the mayor of Vienna, Michael Häupl, saying that it was a photo of Mirandópolis.
During the article's existence, Mirandópolis was cited in the vote of a judge in a decision by the Rio de Janeiro Court of Justice [pt] (TJ-RJ), in the documentary Diretas Já, and in an undergraduate thesis.
Revelation of the hoax
The hoax was revealed on February 23, 2016, through a report that was published on G1 and aired on the GloboNews television channel. They contacted PUC-SP, which said they never had a professor with that name, and also Chico Buarque's team, which said Buarque did not know Mirandópolis. Additionally, the report contacted TJ-RJ, which said that the mention made by the judge had sources from the memory center page of the PUC of Rio de Janeiro (PUC-RJ) and the Diretas Já film. However, PUC-RJ said that the information was not on their website. The G1 report was also covered in the Migalhas [pt] newspaper. Victor Nóbrega said he was surprised by Mirandópolis's other mentions: "The thing took on a proportion that we never imagined. I expected it to appear on some blogs, but not in a more serious source. I laughed out loud. But, while it's funny on one hand, it's sad on the other because people are not using the Internet correctly."
In its original article, G1 interviewed professors to comment on the case, who generally said that caution was necessary with information found on the Internet. On the same day the report was published, the article was deleted by administrator Leon Saudanha. On February 24, G1 published comments from Saudanha and the Wikimedia Foundation, which manages Misplaced Pages, about the case. In 2017, the case was mentioned in a doctoral thesis as an example of legal fake news and by professors from the Mackenzie Presbyterian University on their website, urging "caution with research sources". Lawyer João Taborda da Gama, writing for Diário de Notícias on the topic "Can a judge cite Misplaced Pages?", cited Mirandópolis as an example to support his opinion that "it depends a lot on the purpose of the citation, never being able to be the sole source of a conclusion given the mutability and reliability of Misplaced Pages not being absolute". In 2023, the name "Carlos Bandeirense Mirandópolis" was used as the complainant in a Public Prosecutor's Office (MP) inquiry. When questioned, they said that "the identity of the representative is irrelevant since the MP investigates the facts and could act even on its own initiative".
References
- ^ Passarinho, Nathalia (February 24, 2016) . "Perfil falso na Wikipédia é citado em decisão judicial e trabalho acadêmico" [Fake Misplaced Pages profile cited in court ruling and academic paper]. G1 (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original on August 30, 2024. Retrieved July 14, 2024.
- "Sobre a notícia publicada: Carlos Bandeirense Mirandópolis" [About the news published: Carlos Bandeirense Mirandópolis] (in Brazilian Portuguese). Núcleo de Memória da PUC-Rio. February 23, 2016. Archived from the original on July 14, 2024. Retrieved July 14, 2024.
- "Advogados criam perfil falso na Wikipédia e jurista fictício aparece em documentário e decisão" [Lawyers create fake Misplaced Pages profile and fictitious jurist appears in documentary and ruling]. Migalhas (in Brazilian Portuguese). February 23, 2016. Retrieved July 14, 2024.
- Passarinho, Nathalia (February 24, 2016). "Após reportagem do G1, perfil de jurista fictício na Wikipédia é apagado" [After G1 report, fictitious jurist's Misplaced Pages profile is deleted]. G1 (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original on July 14, 2024. Retrieved July 14, 2024.
- Sbizera, José Alexandre Ricciardi (2017). "Linguagem, direito e literatura: Estilhaços heurísticos para pensar as relações entre o riso, o jurista e o leitor" [Language, law and literature: Heuristic shards for thinking about the relationship between laughter, the jurist and the reader] (PDF) (in Brazilian Portuguese). Federal University of Santa Catarina. p. 65. Archived (PDF) from the original on July 14, 2024. Retrieved July 14, 2024.
- Pinto, Felipe Chiarello de Souza; Junqueira, Michelle Asato (May 3, 2017). "Uma mentira repetida mil vezes torna-se verdade?" [Does a lie repeated a thousand times become the truth?] (in Brazilian Portuguese). Mackenzie Presbyterian University. Archived from the original on July 14, 2024. Retrieved July 14, 2024.
- Gama, João Taborda da (December 9, 2018). "Nunca é só isso" [It's never just that]. Diário de Notícias (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original on March 2, 2021. Retrieved July 14, 2024.
- Calore, Lucas (June 19, 2023). "Viagem de vereadores ao Guarujá se torna inquérito no Ministério Público" [Councillors' trip to Guarujá becomes an inquiry at the Public Prosecutor's Office]. Jornal Cidade (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original on July 14, 2024. Retrieved July 14, 2024.
