Misplaced Pages

Catherine Magennis
Countess of Tyrone
Coat of arms
Born	Catherine Magennis Before 1574 Ulster, Ireland
Died	15 March 1619 Naples, Italy
Spouse(s)	Hugh O'Neill, Earl of Tyrone
Issue	Shane (John) O'Neill Brian O'Neill Conn O'Neill
Father	Hugh Magennis, Baron of Iveagh
Mother	Annabel Reilly

Catherine O'Neill, Countess of Tyrone (née Magennis; before 1574 – 15 March 1619) was an Irish aristocrat. She was the fourth and final wife of Hugh O'Neill, Earl of Tyrone, a leading Gaelic lord in Ireland during the late Elizabethan and early Stuart eras.

Catherine was part of the Magennis dynasty, a powerful family in County Down which enjoyed favour from the Crown. Refined and well-educated, she was betrothed to O'Neill in a political marriage during the Nine Years' War.

Due to increasing hostility against her husband and his allies, Catherine reluctantly fled to mainland Europe in 1607. She was separated from her children and settled with her husband in Rome, receiving minimal support from Philip III of Spain and Pope Paul V. After her husband's death, Catherine faced major financial difficulties and constantly petitioned the Spanish government for their assistance. She died in Naples with many payments in arrears.

Early life

Catherine was born into the Magennis family of Rathfriland, one of the most powerful families in early Ulster. She was born no later than 1573. Her father was Sir Hugh Magennis, Baron of Iveagh, who had married Lady Annabel Reilly. Catherine's father was in favour with the Crown. He was granted his territory and Barony by the English, and was described as "the civilest of all the Irish in those parts".

Catherine was raised at the family seat at Dundrum Castle, County Down, which overlooked Dundrum Bay and the Mourne Mountains. She was well-educated and "accustomed to a comfortable way of life", and was reputed to be a lady of "excellent education and character". Peter Lombard described her as "young in years indeed, but full grown in education, character, prudence and piety". Like her husband's previous wife Mabel Bagenal, she was said to be young and attractive.

Marriage

When her father died in 1596, he was succeeded by her brother Arthur Roe Magennis. Arthur joined the Irish confederacy in the Nine Years' War against England. The unification between the Magennis family and confederacy leader Hugh O'Neill was sealed with Catherine's betrothal to O’Neill. Their marriage was very unlike O'Neill's "whirlwind courtship" of Mabel Bagenal - this was a political marriage maneuvered by the Magennis family. The couple married sometime before 16 August 1597. Catherine was O'Neill's fourth and final wife. O'Neill jilted the daughter of Angus MacDonald, 8th of Dunnyveg, to marry Catherine instead.

In 1597, a night-time raid forced Catherine and her husband to flee into the woods in the south of Armagh. Two years later, Catherine was present in O'Neill’s camp outside Newry. One English officer noted that at this time, the confederates often travelled with their wives, probably because the Crown's failed 1599 Irish campaign created a sense of safety in the Irish.

Despite victories at the Battle of the Yellow Ford and Battle of Curlew Pass, around 1602 the Irish alliance began to suffer major losses due to Lord Deputy Mountjoy's scorched earth tactics. This put a great deal of pressure on O'Neill, now in his middle age. Upset with setbacks, he began drinking heavily and took his frustrations out on Catherine.

Catherine and O'Neill had three sons: Shane (1599 – 1641), Conn Ruadh (c. 1602 – in or after 1622), and Brian (c. 1604 – 1617). Catherine also had many elder step-children from her husband's past relationships.

Post-war

O'Neill's surrender in March 1603 marked the end of the Nine Years' War. Throughout 1603–1607, O'Neill was repeatedly antagonised by English officials who wished to see his undoing. Despite the terms of his treaty with the Crown, O'Neill continued his correspondence with the Spanish government. This was unknown to Catherine.

Reportedly O’Neill considered "putting away" Catherine in December 1605, and it was rumored that he had assembled a group of clerics to explore his options. In response to this, Catherine allegedly confronted her husband, warning him that if he didn't stop his abuse, she "would discover him so far as to infer again to rebellion or to lose his head." O'Neill dismissed his plan.

English administrator Arthur Chichester heard about the strain on their marriage, and sent officer Toby Caulfield to recruit Catherine as a double agent. According to Caulfield, Catherine was in a "querulous and complaining humour." She complained she was "weary of unquiet life". Caulfield confided that he could protect her from O'Neill’s "drunken tyranny" and she could "be revenged on him for all his injuries at once." In return, he requested information about O’Neill’s war plans. Catherine responded that she had no such information and "would not, for all the world, however, much she hated him, be known to accuse him of anything that should endanger his life." She also swore that O'Neill would never impart such secrets to her. Nevertheless, she deflected Caulfield by pledging to stay vigilant of O'Neill's anti-English activities.

Flight of the Earls

In September 1607, facing potential arrest for treasonous activities, Catherine's husband made a "snap decision" to leave Ireland for continental Europe, along with ninety of his followers. He arrived at their Dungannon residence, collected Catherine and sent out messengers to gather their three children. Shane and Brian arrived in time, but five-year-old Conn, who was living with his foster-family, could not be located. O'Neill "sought him diligently, but... was overtaken with shortness of time."

Catherine was reluctant to leave her life in Ireland, and particularly upset by Conn's absence. According to an English account of their departure, "the countess being exceedingly weary slipped down from her horse and weeping said she could go no further." O'Neill responded by threatening her with his sword "if she did not pass on with him and put on a more cheerful countenance".

Catherine ultimately accompanied her husband and two sons into exile. Conditions on their boat were extremely poor, with the noblewomen on the boat especially troubled by the harsh journey. They arrived in France, not Spain as expected, due to storms; they then made their way north to the Spanish Netherlands. Many of the noblewomen were compelled to leave their children behind in St Anthony's College, Leuven, under the supervision of the Franciscans. Catherine reluctantly left Shane and Brian in Leuven, then continued with her husband to Rome.

For part of the journey, the women had to abandon their coaches and travel through the harsh winter on horseback. For a well-educated, high-born noble such as Catherine, her new circumstances would have been extremely upsetting and isolating. In Rome, the couple received a small pension from Pope Paul V.

Lord Deputy Arthur Chichester placed Conn in the custody of English officer Sir Tobias Caulfeild. Caulfeild received a warrant allowing him to seize Catherine's goods "in consideration that had kept the child in his own care, and found him in meat and drink".

In Rome

Once she was settled in Rome, Catherine's distress did not subside. She found the Italian climate, the separation from her children, and her diminished lifestyle all unacceptable. Catherine asked to return to Leuven to reunite with her children, but her petitions were constantly denied by Spanish authorities. It seems her husband also refused to let her relocate to Leuven. When Catherine pleaded for her health, frequently complaining about the "city's air", the authorities suggested she go to Naples or Sicily. A doctor who arrived in Rome to attend to her ailing husband confirmed that Catherine was sick. He treated her and she showed marked improvement.

It was later suggested that once in Rome she had an affair with Robert Lombard, the nephew of Peter Lombard, the Catholic Archbishop of Armagh, who was a noted supporter of the Earl. Robert Lombard was a spy for the Crown and may have attempted to get information from the Countess about her husband, which he relayed on to London and Dublin. Similiarly, historian Robert Dunlop suggests that O'Neill married a fifth time, for mention is made of a young Countess of Tyrone during his residence in Rome.

Hugh O'Neill died on 20 July 1616, and Catherine was left with the responsibilities for O'Neill's family and retainers. In August 1617, Catherine learned that her son Brian, aged 13, had been hanged in his bedroom in Brussels. At the time it was inconclusive whether this was a murder or suicide. Historians Paul Walsh and John O'Hart believe Brian was murdered by an English assassin. Catherine's step-sons Hugh and Henry died from illness in 1609 and 1610 respectively. These deaths only intensified her increasing isolation. Furthermore, she became estranged from her oldest son Shane over her late husband's will. According to the will, she would receive 172 crowns per month - short of her Spanish pension of 550 crowns per month. The remaining 378 crowns per month would be split amongst O'Neill's dependents. However, if Catherine failed to maintained "herself honorably,... not a penny is to be given to her."

The unhappy retainers asked the late earl's secretary, Henry O'Hagan, to inform Shane that his mother was refusing to give them the money bequeathed to them. The claimants asked for Shane's support and even suggested that Catherine be "enclosed in a convent of nuns". They cautioned Shane to send someone to Rome, to deposit his late father's money and valuable in a bank before Catherine could. Historian Jerrold Casway believes this saga exposes the Irish refugees' "extreme dependency", as well as Catherine's estrangement from her husband and his retainers.

Shane and Catherine disputed over her share of the Earl's pension as well as the maintenance of his dependents. The late Earl's trusted friend and former Spanish ambassador to Rome, Count de Castro, asked Philip III of Spain for compassion towards Catherine's "miserable state, alone and without property in a foreign land... with no other protection than that of Your Majesty." He requested funds to allow Catherine to "travel proportionate to her quality and to the manner in which she must be escorted". After much debate, Phillip concurred. In September 1616, he directed Castro's successor, Cardinal Borja y Velasco, to grant Catherine the same allowance as her late husband, to the frustration of O'Neill's dependents.

Despite the royal grant, Catherine failed to receive any compensation, and without this the dependents also suffered. Throughout 1617 she unsuccessfully petitioned for her monthly stipend. She eventually escaped to Naples to evade creditors, to alleviate her poor health and to be closer to her new benefactor Pedro Téllez-Girón, 3rd Duke of Osuna. On 22 June 1618, Catherine described herself to Philip III as "this afflicted and unprotected widow," who feared "less to die of hunger than to become the ridicule of the English." In response, Philip ordered a prompt payment to her.

Death and legacy

Catherine died on 15 March 1619 in Naples, in poor health and with many unpaid pension payments still owed to her. Shane, then a colonel in the Spanish army, was greatly upset by her death. Modern historians characterise Catherine's life on the Continent as tragic and lonely. Her fate highlights the extreme dependency faced by the Irish refugees and embodies the high-risk politics typical of her husband's marriages.

Conn, her son left behind in Ireland, was raised in England and educated at Eton College as a Protestant. He was committed to the Tower of London on 12 August 1622, where he probably died.

Notes

1. She was "more than half" her husband's age when they married c. 1597. Her husband Hugh O'Neill was born c. 1550.
2. Arthur had previously married O'Neill's daughter Sarah, and he was later made 1st Viscount Iveagh by James VI and I.
3. Dunlop believed Conn was illegitimate, though Walsh and Casway claim that Catherine Magennis was Conn's mother.
4. Robert Dunlop incorrectly believed that Catherine died in 1607 in Leuven.

References

Citations

1. ^ Casway 2016, p. 73.
2. Guinness 1932, p. 96.
3. Casway 2016, pp. 70, 73.
4. Graham 1938.
5. ^ Casway 2016, p. 69.
6. ^ Dunlop 1895, p. 196.
7. ^ Walsh 1930, p. 20.
8. ^ Guinness 1932, p. 97.
9. ^ Casway 2003, p. 61.
10. Walsh 1930, pp. 20–21.
11. Casway 2016, p. 69, 73.
12. Casway 2003, p. 57.
13. O'Byrne, Emmett (October 2009). "MacDonnell (Nic Dhomhnaill), Fiona (Fionnghuala) ('Iníon Dubh')". Dictionary of Irish Biography. doi:10.3318/dib.006337.v1. Archived from the original on 18 April 2024.
14. O'Neill 2021, pp. 3–4.
15. O'Neill 2021, p. 4.
16. O'Neill 2017, pp. 13–14, 90–92.
17. Lennon 1995, p. 303.
18. O'Neill 2017, pp. 108–109.
19. Walsh 1957, p. 10.
20. ^ Walsh 1930, p. 31.
21. ^ Casway 2016, p. 74.
22. ^ Walsh 1930, pp. 31–32.
23. Walsh 1930, pp. 9, 31.
24. Walsh 1930, pp. 29–30.
25. O'Neill 2017, p. 193.
26. ^ McGurk, John (August 2007). "The Flight of the Earls: escape or strategic regrouping?". History Ireland. 15 (4). Archived from the original on 18 April 2024.
27. Casway 2016, pp. 73–74.
28. ^ Morgan, Hiram (September 2014). "O'Neill, Hugh". Dictionary of Irish Biography. doi:10.3318/dib.006962.v1. Retrieved 3 May 2024.
29. ^ Knox 2002, p. 26.
30. ^ Casway 2016, pp. 74–75.
31. ^ McCavitt 2002, p. 220.
32. ^ Casway 2016, p. 75.
33. Casway, Jerrold (2011). "Florence Conry, the Flight of the Earls, and Native-Catholic Militancy". New Hibernia Review / Iris Éireannach Nua. 15 (3): 111–125. ISSN 1092-3977. JSTOR 23068131.
34. Casway, Jerrold (2009). "O'Donnell, Nuala". Dictionary of Irish Biography. doi:10.3318/dib.006696.v1. Retrieved 18 April 2024.
35. Meehan 1868, p. 284.
36. ^ Casway 2003, p. 62.
37. ^ Casway 2016, p. 76.
38. Walsh 1930, p. 9.
39. O'Hart, John (1892). "O'Neill (No.2) Irish genealogy". Irish Pedigrees; or the Origin and Stem of the Irish Nation. 1 (5 ed.). Archived from the original on 7 October 2024. Retrieved 21 September 2024.
40. FitzPatrick, Elizabeth (August 2007). "San Pietro in Montorio, burial-place of the exiled Irish in Rome, 1608-1623". History Ireland. 15 (4). Archived from the original on 1 March 2024.
41. Walsh 1957, pp. 7–9.
42. Casway 2003, pp. 62, 63.
43. ^ Casway 2003, p. 63.
44. ^ Casway 2016, p. 77.
45. ^ Casway 2003, p. 64.

Sources

• Casway, Jerrold (2003). "Heroines or Victims? The Women of the Flight of the Earls". New Hibernia Review / Iris Éireannach Nua. 7 (1): 56–74. ISSN 1092-3977. JSTOR 20557855.
• Casway, Jerrold (2016). "Catherine Magennis and the Wives of Hugh O'Neill". Seanchas Ardmhacha: Journal of the Armagh Diocesan Historical Society. 26 (1): 69–79. ISSN 0488-0196. JSTOR 48568219.
• Dunlop, Robert (1895). "O'Neill, Hugh, third Baron of Dungannon and second Earl of Tyrone 1540?–1616". In Lee, Sidney (ed.). Dictionary of National Biography. Vol. XLII. New York: MacMillan and Co. pp. 188–196. OCLC 8544105.
• Graham, John K. (1938). "The Birth-Date of Hugh O'Neill, Second Earl of Tyrone". Irish Historical Studies. 1 (1): 58–59. ISSN 0021-1214. JSTOR 30006560.
• Guinness, Henry S. (1932). "Magennis of Iveagh". The Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland. 2 (1): 96–102. ISSN 0035-9106. JSTOR 25513625.
• Knox, Andrea (1 January 2002). ""Women of the Wild Geese": Irish Women, Exile, and Identity in Spain, 1596–1670". Quidditas. 23 (1).
• Lennon, Colm (1995). Sixteenth Century Ireland – The Incomplete Conquest. Dublin: St. Martin's Press. ISBN 978-07171-3947-7.
• Meehan, Charles Patrick (1868). The fate and fortunes of Hugh O'Neill, earl of Tyrone, and Rory O'Donel, earl of Tyrconnel; their flight from Ireland, their vicissitudes abroad, and their death in exile. University of California Libraries. Dublin, J. Duffy.
• McCavitt, John (2002). The Flight of the Earls. Gill & MacMillan. ISBN 9780717130474.
• O'Neill, James (2017). The Nine Years War, 1593-1603: O'Neill, Mountjoy and the Military Revolution. Dublin: Four Courts Press. ISBN 9781846827549.
• O'Neill, James (January 2021). "Spouses, spies and subterfuge: the role and experience of women during the Nine Years War (1593-1603)". Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy. 121C: 1–24. doi:10.3318/PRIAC.2021.121.02. hdl:10468/11583.
• Walsh, Micheline (April 1957). The O'Neills in Spain (PDF). Archived (PDF) from the original on 1 July 2024.
• Walsh, Paul (1930). Walsh, Paul (ed.). THE WILL AND FAMILY OF HUGH O NEILL, EARL OF TYRONE [WITH AN APPENDIX OF GENEALOGIES] (PDF). Dublin: Sign of the Three Candles.

• Irish emigrants to Italy
• 17th-century Irish people
• Flight of the Earls
• People of the Nine Years' War (Ireland)