Misplaced Pages

Dances for Harp and String Orchestra, in full in the original, Danses pour harpe chromatique avec accompagnement d'orchestre d'instruments à cordes (Dances for chromatic harp with string orchestra accompaniment), is a 1904 work by Claude Debussy. There are two sections: Danse sacrée and Danse profane, and the work is sometimes billed accordingly. It is a two-movement work, of about ten minutes' duration.

Background

By 1904 Claude Debussy was established as one of France's leading composers. His 1902 opera Pelléas et Mélisande had brought him international fame, and he had been appointed a Chevalier of the Légion d'honneur the following year. Gustave Lyon, director of the Pleyel harp-making company, had invented a new type of instrument – the chromatic harp – with no pedals but with an additional set of strings, slanting across the others, enabling harpists to play any note in the chromatic scale with either hand. Lyon commissioned Debussy to write a work for the new instrument, originally for the competitions at the Brussels Conservatoire, where a class had been established for the study of the ancient harp in its modernised form.

Premiere and reception

The work was premiered on 6 November 1904 at one of the Concerts Colonne at the Châtelet Theatre in Paris, with Lucile Wurmser-Delcourt as soloist. It had a mixed reception. Pierre Lalo, music critic for Le Temps, usually an admirer of Debussy, wrote, "It really seems as though the Dances are not by M. Debussy, but by some of his unfortunate imitators and one would like to be able to say as much, rather than being forced to recognise that M. Debussy is beginning to imitate himself". When the Dances were first heard in London, The Musical Times commented, "At least it can be said that they held the attention if they did not at once excite admiration". After the American premiere The New York Times described the Dances as "music of distinctive charm and flavor".

Publication and later performances

The work was published in 1904 by Éditions Durand in Paris and Novello in London. Arrangements for other combinations of instruments followed; Durand published versions for piano and strings, piano duet, harp and piano, violin and piano, and cello and piano. The title of the original score was expanded by Durand to read "Danses pour harpe chromatique ou harpe à pédales, ou piano avec accompagnement d'orchestre d'instruments à cordes". The published work is dedicated to Lyon.

The work was first heard in Britain in June 1908 in the piano and orchestra version, with Julius Harrison as soloist and Granville Bantock conducting. The original version was given at the Bechstein Hall in February 1909 by the Société de Concerts Français. Wurmser-Delcourt was the soloist; in her American début, she again played the Danses, at a concert in Aeolian Hall, New York, in December 1919, but did not give the US premiere, which was in December 1916 in a concert at the same venue, when Carlos Salzedo was the soloist in the Dances and in the first American performance of Maurice Ravel's Introduction and Allegro.

Music

Both dances are in D, the first principally in Dorian mode and the second principally in Lydian. The theme of the Danse sacrée appears to have been borrowed from that of the Danse du voile, by Debussy's friend Francisco de Lacerda.

The Danse sacrée is marked Très modéré, the metronome mark is ♩ =120 and the time is
₂. The strings begin in the first seven bars and then the harp enters pianissimo, doux et soutenu. The Danse profane – marked modéré, ♩ =152, and
₄ – is a slow swirling waltz, with its theme alternating with more animated interludes, before fading to a quiet conclusion. The two dances are of approximately equal duration, typically lasting about ten minutes between them.

Debussy's biographer Léon Vallas, calling the music "simple and pleasantly harmonious", comments, "The use of the ancient modes, as well as certain details of the instrumentation, may possibly recall Erik Satie's Gymnopédies".

Recordings

Recordings include:

Notes, references and sources

Notes

1. According to the musicologist Albert Birch in a study of the modern development of the harp, "the Danses are now commonly played on the pedal harp, and are in fact easier on this than on the chromatic harp for which they were conceived".
2. Some typical playing times from versions in the Recordings section: Chalifoux: 5m:8s and 4m:59s; Challan: 5:19 and 5:14; Langlamet: 4:27 and 4;57; Laskine: 4:27 and 4:32

References

1. "Music: Pelléas et Mélisande", The Times, 22 May 1909, p. 13
2. Dietschy, p. 126
3. Avis, Peter (1992). Notes to EMI CD set 7243 5 85171 2 5
4. ^ Vallas, p. 167
5. Birch, p. 195
6. "Concerts-Colonne", Le Figaro, 6 November 1904, p. 5
7. Lalo, Pierre. "Musique", Le Temps, 29 November 1904, p. 3
8. ^ "London Concerts", The Musical Times, 1 April 1909, p. 259
9. ^ "French Harpist Plays", The New York Times, 29 December 1919, p. 7
10. "New Foreign Publications", The Musical Times, 1 August 1904, p. 551
11. ^ Debussy, title page
12. "Birmingham School of Music", Birmingham Daily Gazette, 25 June 1908, p. 4
13. "Music", The Times, 22 February 1909, p. 10
14. "Programs of the Week", The New York Times, 3 December 1916, p. 10
15. Lesure, François (2008), Notes to a CD Debussy and Lacerda. See also Ferguson, Joan Laurel (1988), "Francisco de Lacerda and Claude Debussy's Danses: sacrée et profane", The American Harp Journal 11/4, pp. 13-15.
16. Debussy, p. 1
17. Debussy, p. 10
18. Halbreich, Harry (2014). Notes to Timpani CD 1C 1207

Sources

• Birch, Albert (1969). "The Modern Development of the Harp". In Anthony Baines (ed.). Musical Instruments Throughout the Ages. London: Penguin. ISBN 978-0-14-020347-9.
• Debussy, Claude (1904). Danses. Paris: Durand. OCLC 21808571.
• Dietschy, Marcel (1990). A Portrait of Claude Debussy. Oxford: Clarendon Press. ISBN 978-0-19-315469-8.
• Vallas, Léon (1973) . Claude Debussy, His Life and Works. New York: Dover. ISBN 978-0-486-22916-4.

• Concertante works by Claude Debussy
• 1904 compositions
• Harp concertos
• Compositions for string orchestra