Frankenberger thesis - Misplaced Pages

Claim of Adolf Hitler's Jewish descent

The Frankenberger thesis, also Frankenreiter thesis, is a thesis which has been contested by historians that claims Adolf Hitler's paternal grandfather was Jewish.

Referring to the parentage of Hitler's father Alois Hitler — who was born in 1837 as the illegitimate son of the housemaid Anna Maria Schicklgruber, which has not been clarified with absolute certainty — the Frankenberger thesis asserts that the unknown father of Hitler's father was a Jewish merchant from Graz named Leopold Frankenberger [es] (or Frankenreiter) or his son and that Adolf Hitler was therefore a "quarter Jew" in the sense of the Nuremberg Race Laws later imposed by his own regime.

Origin

The Frankenberger thesis in its final form goes back to Hans Frank's memoirs published under the title In the Face of the Gallows. Frank, who had acted as Hitler's lawyer in the late 1920s and early 1930s, states that he was commissioned by Hitler in 1930 to discreetly investigate the various rumors circulating in the press and public at the time alleging Hitler's Jewish descent.

According to Frank, during detailed research he was able to unearth some circumstantial evidence that made these rumors appear not entirely unreasonable: Hitler's grandmother Anna Maria Schicklgruber worked as a housemaid or cook in the house of a Jew from Graz named Frankenberger in the 1830s. In 1837, when she was very pregnant, she returned to her home village, where her son Alois was born. The column for the child's father was left blank in the baptismal register, but Anna Maria Schicklgruber received financial support from Frankenberger for the next 14 years.

It is disputed whether any Jews lived in Graz at the time of Alois Hitler's birth in 1837. The same is true for the similarly named Bohemian town Gratzen (now Nové Hrady, Czech Republic) which is closer to Schicklgruber's native region.

Frank's motivations

Some suggest that Frank (who turned against Nazism after 1945 but remained an anti-Semitic fanatic until his execution) made the claim that Hitler had Jewish ancestry as a way of proving that Hitler was really a "Jew" and not an "Aryan", and in this way "proved" that the Third Reich's crimes were the work of the "Jewish" Hitler. The full anti-Semitic implications of Frank's story were borne out in a letter entitled "Was Hitler a Jew?", written to the editor of a Saudi newspaper in 1982 by a German man living in Saudi Arabia. The writer accepted Frank's story as the truth, and added since Hitler was a Jew, "the Jews should pay Germans reparations for the War, because one of theirs caused the destruction of Germany".

But Jewish-American author Ron Rosenbaum suggested another reason for Frank's story:

On the other hand, a different version of Frank emerges in the brilliantly vicious, utterly unforgiving portrait of him by his son, Niklas Frank, who (in a memoir called In the Shadow of the Reich) depicts his father as a craven coward and weakling, but one not without a kind of animal cunning, an instinct for lying, insinuation, self-aggrandizement. For this Hans Frank, disgraced and facing death on the gallows for following Hitler, fabricating such a story might be a cunning way of ensuring his place in history as the one man who gave the world the hidden key to the mystery of Hitler's psyche. While at the same time, revenging himself on his former master for having led him to this end by foisting a sordid and humiliating explanation of Hitler on him for all posterity. In any case, it was one Frank knew the victors would find seductive.

Historical evaluation

The validity of the Frankenberger thesis has been questioned in historical research since its inception. Consequently, it is rejected by most researchers. Both Frankenberger's paternity and his status as a Jew are questioned.

As early as 1956, Franz Jetzinger, author of Hitler’s Youth, pointed out that "the name Frankenberger does not sound Jewish at all" and that it must therefore "first be proven" that Frankenberger—even if he was actually the father of Alois Hitler—actually was a Jew. Jetzinger also emphasized that "any evidence" was missing for alleged alimony payments. His conclusion is therefore: "Frank's report is at most sufficient to suspect Jewish descent, he does not guarantee a certainty."

In the 1960s, the archives of the city of Graz came to the conclusion that the alleged Frankenberger was probably identical to Leopold Frankenreiter: On the one hand, not a single Frankenberger could be found in the lists of residents of the city of Graz for the period in question and, on the other hand, this name corresponded to that Name attributed by Hitler's nephew William Patrick Hitler to Hitler's grandmother's employer. However, Frankenreiter was not of Jewish descent, but had been baptized Catholic with his entire family. However, even after this correction, the name Frankenberger remained the one to be found much more frequently in the literature.

Joachim Fest judged that "the lack of verifiable evidence makes the thesis appear extremely questionable". Although Frank had little reason to knowingly falsely ascribe Hitler Jewish ancestors, "the thesis can hardly stand up to serious discussion". The "actual meaning" of the thesis lies "less in its objective validity". "Far more decisive and psychologically significant" was "that Hitler had to see his origins cast into doubt by Frank's results. Adolf Hitler did not know who his grandfather was." Brigitte Hamann, on the other hand, wrote that "here the angry anti-Semite Frank wanted to blame the hated Jews for an allegedly Jewish Hitler and unsettle them with rumours".

Notable historians who dismiss the thesis are Ian Kershaw, Robert Payne, Walter Görlitz, Anton Joachimsthaler, Christian Graf von Krockow, John Toland, Brigitte Hamann and Ernst Deuerlein.

Apart from serious historical research, the "revelation" of Hitler's "Jewish descent" has been taken up again and again by publications with a popular scientific, conspiracy theory or sensationalist impact. It is characteristic of this literature, which is almost unmanageable in its breadth, that it attempts to present source material that has been known for decades, in particular Frank's rumours, as new knowledge and in doing so fails to mention the continuous and almost unanimously skeptical and negative reception by the leading Hitler biographers.

In May 2019, American psychologist Leonard Sax wrote an article titled "Aus den Gemeinden von Burgenland: Revisiting the question of Adolf Hitler's paternal grandfather" which attempts to provide evidence for the antisemitic conspiracy theory that Hitler had Jewish ancestry and that was the basis for his antisemitism. Sax points out that many Jews lived in places without official sanction and demonstrated the existence of a settled Jewish community in Graz before the law formally permitted their residence, saying that "Contemporary historians have largely dismissed Frank's claim, primarily on the grounds that there were purportedly no Jews living in Graz in 1836, when Hitler's father Alois Schicklgruber was conceived. This consensus can be traced to a single historian, Nikolaus von Preradovich," a Nazi sympathizer, "who claimed that 'not a single Jew' (kein einziger Jude) was living in Graz prior to 1856. No independent scholarship has confirmed Preradovich's conjecture. In this paper, evidence is presented that there was in fact 'a small, now settled community' (eine kleine, nun angesiedelte Gemeinde)—of Jews living in Graz before 1850." And that "The hypothesis that Hitler's paternal grandfather was Jewish, as claimed by Hans Frank, may fit the facts better than the alternative hypothesis that Hitler's paternal grandfather was Johann Georg Hiedler or Johann Nepomuk Hiedler."

However, historian Richard J. Evans has questioned Sax's findings. Evans wrote, "even if there were Jews living in Graz in the 1830s, at the time when Adolf Hitler's father Alois was born, this does not prove anything at all about the identity of Hitler's paternal grandfather." And, that, "There is no contemporary evidence that Hitler's mother was ever in Graz, or that there was a Jewish family called Frankenberger living there. There was a family in Graz called Frankenreiter but it was not Jewish. No correspondence between Hitler's father or paternal grandmother has ever been found. Nor is there any evidence for Frank's claim that Hitler's half-nephew knew about it and was blackmailing Hitler, as Frank claimed." Also, Evans noted that Sax is not a historian, but a psychiatrist, and that Sax seems to be motivated by attempting to prove Hitler had Jewish ancestry as a way to explain his antisemitism.

References

Hans Frank: Im Ansicht des Galgens. 1955, p. 320.
"Hitler gegen Hitler". Profil online. 5 February 2005. Archived from the original on 2014-10-15. Retrieved 2022-05-02.
Rosenbaum 1998, pp. 21, 30–31.
Rosenbaum 1998, p. 30.
Rosenbaum 1998, p. 31.
Rosenbaum 1998, p. 25.
Franz Jetzinger: Hitlers Jugend. Phantasien, Lügen – und die Wahrheit. 1956, p. 32.
City of Graz: Historisches Jahrbuch der Stadt Graz. Vol. 2–4, 1969, p. 8–10.
^ Joachim Fest: Hitler. Eine Biografie. 1973, p. 32.
^ Brigitte Hamann: Hitlers Wien. Piper, Munich 1997, p. 77.
Kershaw: Hitler, 1889–1936. Hubris. 2000, p. 8.
Payne: The Life and Death of Adolf Hitler. 1973, p. 6.
Görlitz: Adolf Hitler. 1960, p. 13.
Anton Joachimsthaler: Korrektur einer Biographie. 1989, p. 11.
Krockow: Hitler und seine Deutschen. 2001, p. 12.
John Tolad: Hitler. 1976, p. 246.
Deuerlein: Der Aufstieg der NSDAP in Augenzeugenberichten. 1968, p. 63.
Sax, Leonard (2019). "Aus den Gemeinden von Burgenland: Revisiting the question of Adolf Hitler's paternal grandfather". Journal of European Studies. 49 (2): 143–162. doi:10.1177/0047244119837477.
https://www.leonardsax.com/JES_MS.pdf
"Who was Hitler's grandfather? Why should you care? | Leonard Sax MD PhD | Physician, Psychologist, and Author". 26 July 2019.
https://www.amazon.com/ANGESICHT-GALGENS-Erkenntnisse-Geschrieben-Justizgef%C3%A4ngnis-ebook/dp/B0797WXN4Z/ref=tmm_kin_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&qid=&sr=
"Study suggests Adolf Hitler's paternal grandfather was Jewish". 8 August 2019.
^ "Historians cast doubt on Hitler Jewish heritage claims". The Times of Israel. 7 August 2019.

Sources

Rosenbaum, Ron (1998). Explaining Hitler. New York: Random House. ISBN 9780679431510.

External links

Categories: