Jesse James Dunn - Misplaced Pages

Jesse James Dunn


3rd Chief Justice of the Oklahoma Supreme Court
In office January 11, 1910 – January 1911
Preceded by	Matthew John Kane
Succeeded by	John B. Turner
Justice of the Oklahoma Supreme Court
In office November 16, 1907 – September 1, 1913
Preceded by	Position established
Succeeded by	Robert H. Loofbourrow

Personal details
Born	October 2, 1867 Channahon, Will County, Illinois
Died	July 28, 1926 Oakland, Alameda County, California

Jesse James Dunn (1867-1926) was a judge on the Oklahoma Supreme Court.

Early life and education

Dunn was born on October 2, 1867, at Channahon, Will County, Illinois to James McCann and Alta Fiorina (née Lewis) Dunn. In 1857, James McCann Dunn worked for a contractor delivering freight to the new Fort Leavenworth, Kansas, but in 1858, he returned to his parents' home and went into some unspecified business, until he enlisted in the Union Army, then was assigned to Company A, 97th Regiment Illinois Infantry, later transferred to Company D, 37th Regiment Illinois Infantry, and on detached service in the ambulance corps after October 16, 1864. He was honorably discharged August 15, 1865, at New Orleans, Louisiana.

When J. J. was only three years old, his parents took him to Noxubee County, Mississippi, where the three of them lived with J. M.'s parents for six years. Then they moved to El Paso in Woodford County, Illinois, where they lived until 1885. They moved on to Garden City in Finney County, Kansas, where J. J. went to work in a store owned by his father, as well as working as a farmhand.

He had begun reading law in 1889 in the Garden City, Kansas office of George Lynn Miller. In 1892, Jesse enrolled in the University of Kansas Law School, and graduated with a Bachelor of Laws Degree on June 7, 1893.

Life in Oklahoma

Jesse James Dunn and his father James McCann Dunn came to Oklahoma Territory in time to participate in the 1893 Land Run, leaving the rest of the family at home in Garden City, Kansas.

On September 16, 1893, Jesse made the run and was successful in finding a site in the new community of Alva, Oklahoma Territory where he settled down and opened a law partnership with George Lynn Miller, who later married Jesse's eldest sister.

In 1894, Jesse Dunn became a candidate for the Populist Party to become the County Judge of Woods County in Oklahoma Territory. He came within three votes of winning the nomination. He gained sufficient public exposure to win both the party nomination and the general election in 1896. He was reelected in 1898. Dunn resigned the position in 1901, after completing his second term. He returned to practice law in Alva, where he now formed a partnership with Francis Marion Cowgill. Meanwhile, the Populist Party continued to decline, so Dunn affiliated with the Democratic Party under William Jennings Bryan's leadership.

Dunn was elected President of the Oklahoma Territory Bar Association in 1903, (serving through 1903-4). He was also unanimously elected chairman of the Oklahoma Territory Democratic Committee. In this new position, he managed the party's strategy to win the next election for the Territory's single representative to the U. S. Congress. Although the Democrats did not win that election, it did not cost Dunn any credibility with party officials. He was made the manager for the campaign to elect delegates to the 1906 Oklahoma Constitutional Convention. The resulting delegation was composed of 99 Democrats,1 Independent and 12 Republicans. His skill and ability as a leader and organizer were confirmed.

Williams credits Judge Dunn with unifying the remaining Populists with the regular Democrats in and after the 1906 election. In 1909, the newly constituted Oklahoma Supreme Court adopted a rotation plan for choosing a chief justice. It was agreed that Justice Matthew John Kane and Judge Dunn were equally eligible, so the court decided that Kane should serve the first year of the 1909-11 term, and Dunn should serve the second. On the second Monday of January 1911, John B. Turner was elected as Chief Justice, replacing Dunn.

Move to California

Dunn resigned his seat, effective September 1, 1913 and announced that he planned to move to Oakland, California, where he and Judge John Yule, an uncle of Mrs. Dunn, had formed a partnership to practice law. Their firm was known as Dunn, White and Aiken from March 1, 1914 until it was dissolved by the surviving partners on December 31, 1938.

Death

Dunn died at Livermore Sanitarium in Oakland on July 28, 1926. Biographer Robert Williams did not identify the cause of death. He did report that the judge was survived by his widow, Saidee (née Matson), and three children: Claud, who was married but had no children, Constance (Mrs. J. M. Rutherford), who had two young sons, and Dorothea (Mrs. D. G. White), who had no children.

Legacy

In 1935, The Administration Building of the Northwestern State Teachers' College at Alva, Oklahoma burned down. After it was replaced, the new building was named by the Oklahoma Legislature as "Jesse Dunn Hall."

Electoral history

1907 Oklahoma Supreme Court District 5 election
	Candidate	Votes	%	±%
Democratic	Jesse James Dunn	130,050	56.5	*New*
Republican	D.A. Crafton	99,869	43.4	New
Democratic gain from		Swing	N/A

Notes

The source document spelled the county name as "Noxuby", but some other sources indicate the official spelling is "Noxubee."
Thoburn's History of Oklahoma asserted that Dunn also attended Illinois State Normal School (renamed as Illinois State University at Normal in 1965) and the Garden City (Kansas) Business College before enrolling in the University of Kansas. Thorburn did not give any details about Dunn's fields of studies, dates of attendance or whether he graduated at either of these schools.
Thereafter, the biography by Williams refers to him as Judge Dunn, apparently to distinguish him from his father.
Thoburn wrote that Dunn was the Woods County Attorney from 1896 to 1900.
Although Dunn had died on July 28, 1926, the partners decided that his name was so valued in the profession that they wished to keep it in their firm after his demise. The body of Williams' article incorrectly gave the death date as July 27, but the author corrected his own mistake in his note 10, saying that the Associated Press and the Dunn Family had confirmed that July 28 is correct.

References

^ Williams, Robert L. "Judge Jesse James Dunn." Chronicles of Oklahoma. Vol. XVIII, March 1940. No.1. pp. 3-12. Accessed May 26, 2019.
^ "Supreme Court of Oklahoma Associate Justices - Hon. Jesse J. Dunn." Medico-legal Journal. Vol.26, No. 1, June, 1908. pp. 113-114 Accessed August 29, 2019.
Thoburn, Joseph Bradfield. "Jesse J. Dunn." History of Oklahoma. Vol. 5. 1916. p. 2160. Accessed February 7, 2020.
Thoburn, Joseph Bradford. "Jesse J. Dunn." A Standard History of Oklahoma, Volume 5, p. 2160. American Historical Society. Chicago and New York. 1916. Accessed August 14, 2019.
Williams, R. L. "The Judicial History of Oklahoma." Proceedings of the Fifth Annual Meeting of the Oklahoma State Bar Association. p. 159. December 21,22, 1911. Accessed January 7, 2020.
"1907-1912 Results" (PDF). oklahoma.gov. Oklahoma State Election Board. Retrieved 23 September 2023.

Categories: