Mary Lily Kenan Flagler Bingham (1867–1917) was an American philanthropist and heiress who became notorious when she married one of the richest men of the Gilded Age. Mary Lily outlived her first husband, Henry Flagler, inherited his huge fortune, married again three years later, and died under suspicious circumstances at age fifty. She left the millions she inherited to members of her family and to the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
Childhood
Before she became famous and extraordinarily wealthy, Mary Lily grew up in an affluent household. She was the daughter of William Rand Kenan Sr and Mary Hargrave Kenan, Mary Lily was born in Duplin County, on June 14, 1867. When she was little, her father was a life insurance agent. By the late 1870s, her family lived in Wilmington, North Carolina Mary Lily attended Amy Bradley's Tileston school in Wilmington. Mary Lily was well-educated for a woman in the late 19th century: she both attended school in Wilmington, and attended Peace College in Raleigh. Kenan was also well known for her musical abilities and according to one account, she was North Carolina's “reigning belle” because of her vivaciousness, beauty, and accomplishments. By this time, Mary Lily had become well acquainted with some of the richest members of Wilmington society. She traveled with the Mr. and Mrs. Pembroke Jones and became socially intimate with the Jones’ friend, Henry Walters, as well as Mr. and Mrs. Henry Flagler.
Marriages
Mary Lily Kenan married the much-older Henry Morrison Flagler in 1901. She was his third wife. Henry Morrison Flagler was 72 years old. She was 34, but it wasn't only the age gap that scandalized the nation. In order to marry Mary Lily, Henry Morrison Flagler had to obtain a divorce from his second wife, who had become mentally ill over the course of their marriage. At that time, one had to cite certain specific reasons for divorce, as no-fault divorce did not yet exist. Henry changed his legal residence to Florida, and persuaded the Florida legislature to allow divorce on the grounds of insanity. He was criticized for this action, partly due to societal attitudes toward Divorce in the United States, and partly because of her mental state. According to the Goldsboro Argus, “a Man who would thus cast off an aged wife, blameless herself, is simply beyond execration.”
When the couple married in 1901 in Duplin County, Flagler gave Mary Lily Kenan “…a check for $1,000,000, and $3,000,000 in bonds as a wedding present.” After their marriage, Henry lavished gifts and attention on Mary Lily. Henry built Whitehall, a “….75-room, 100,000-square-foot Gilded Age mansion…as a wedding present for his wife, Mary Lily Kenan Flagler. The couple used the home as a winter retreat from 1902 until Flagler's death in 1913, establishing the Palm Beach season for the wealthy of the Gilded Age.”
Henry Flagler died in 1913, and passed the majority of his wealth on to Mary Lily. Three years later, Mary Lily married a college friend of her brother's, whom she had dated previously in the 1890s. She and Judge Robert Worth Bingham married in New York City, at the home of Mr. and Mrs. Pembroke Jones in 1916. This second marriage did not last long. Mary Lily Kenan Flagler Bingham died in July 1917.
Death
Mary Lily Kenan Bingham's death also sparked scandal and controversy. Mary Lily died after a short illness, and, according to the Wilmington Morning Star, “…the news of her death produced a profound shock in the family and among many friends in the city and in other cities of the State…” Mary Lily was buried on July 31, 1917, after a service in the residence of Mary Lily's sister Sarah. The shock of Mary Lily's death seems to have quickly turned to suspicion about how she died. Headlines spoke of a “tragic mystery,” “foul play” and “murder” and seemed to imply that Mary Lily's husband may have had something to do with her death. Before they married, Judge Bingham waived his rights to the Flagler fortune and most of the estate was left to Mary Lily's birth family members. Judge Bingham did receive $5 million, and some of the concerns about him seem to have stemmed from this inheritance, which was a late addition to Mary Lily's will.
So rather than remaining at rest in Oakdale Cemetery, Mary Lily Kenan Flagler Bingham's body was exhumed in September 1917, with armed guards stationed around the gravesite as her body was dug up in the night. The autopsy was requested by Graham Kenan, Mary Lily's sister Sarah's husband, not Robert Bingham. Despite these irregularities and mysterious circumstances, no charges were ever levied against anyone in the matter of Mrs. Bingham's death. Bingham went on to be an ambassador to England in the 1930s, and parlayed Mary Lily's money into a newspaper empire. The results of the autopsy were never released. Rumors of syphilis, drug use, alcoholism, and murder have swirled around the life of Mary Lily Kenan Flagler Bingham ever since.
The estate left was vast – “…estimated to be worth all the way from $65,000,000 to $130,000,000.”
Legacy
Mary Lily's marriage to Henry Flagler helped make her entire family extremely wealthy. William R. Kenan Jr. and her sisters Jessie Kenan Wise and Sarah Graham Kenan and niece Louise Wise, were all recipients of her will's largess. So was the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. While Mary Lily Kenan attended Peace College at a time when women were not admitted to the University of North Carolina, one of her greatest legacies is the Kenan Professorship Fund, considered to be a milestone endowment in the university's history, consisting of $75,000 per annum in memory of her father and two uncles, who were university alumni. Mary Lily's legacy of giving to UNC was enhanced by the actions of her brother William and her sister Sarah, who both donated generously to UNC after they inherited millions from their sister.
References
- ^ "Carolina's Early Benefactors: Mary Lily Kenan Flager Bingham". The Carolina Story: A Virtual Museum of University History. University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Retrieved 27 March 2023.
- “W. R. Kenan Jr.,…a brother of the late Mrs. Mary Lily Kenan Flagler, and who inherited by her will much of her vast fortune….” Goldsboro Daily Argus, August 6, 1921
- 1870 Census, William R. Kenan, Duplin County, Kenansville, NC
- 1879-1880 Wilmington city directory
- ^ Walter E. Campbell, Across Fortune’s Tracks: A Biography of William Rand Kenan, Jr. (UNC Press, 1996)
- ^ “The career of the Late Henry M. Flagler,” The Concord Daily Tribune, May 21, 1913. P. 1
- “Flager_Kenan” Goldsboro Daily Argus, August 24, 1901, p. 4
- “Flagler-Kenan Wedding,” The Caucasian, Clinton, NC, August 29, 1901, p. 3
- "Whitehall". Henry Morrison Flager Museum. Palm Beach, Florida: Flager Museum. 2022. Retrieved 27 March 2023.
- “Marriage of Mrs. M. Flagler” Saint Albans Daily Messenger, November 15, 1916, p. 5
- “W. R. Kenan Jr.,…a brother of the late Mrs. Mary Lily Kenan Flagler, and who inherited by her will much of her vast fortune….” Goldsboro Daily Argus, August 6, 1921. P. 1
- “Mrs. Robert Bingham Dead,” Wilmington Morning Star, July 28, 1917, p. 10
- “Funeral of Mrs. Bingham, Wilmington Morning Star, August 1, 1917
- ^ “Foul Play Suspected in Flagler Case,” The Statesville Sentinel, September 24, 1917, p. 7
- “Suspect Murder of Mrs. Robert Bingham,” Fort Wayne News, Indiana, September 20, 1917, p. 1
- Tragic Mystery in Death of Mrs. Robert W. Bingham,” Buffalo Times, September 21, 1917, p. 2
- Mrs. Robert W. Bingham’s Body Secretly Exhumed and Autopsy Performed,” Asheville Citizen-Times, September 24, 1917, p.1
- Exhumation Permission, Charles T. Nesbitt, Consolidated Board of Health, September 18, 1917. Accessed at North Carolina Room, New Hanover County Public Library in Kenan family file, note on top says “From Oakdale Cemetery Records.”
- ^ David Leon Chandler, Henry Flagler: The Astonishing Life and Times of the visionary Robber Barron who Founded Florida (New York: MacMillan, 1986)
- David Leon Chandler, “The Binghams of Louisville: The Dark History Behind One of America’s Great Fortunes. Crown, 1989.
- "Scandal Lingers, 80 years later,” Wilmington Star, January 31, 1988, p. 5C
- Stephanie Murphy-Lupo, "A century after Henry Flagler’s widow died, questions remain about her death." Florida Weekly, August 23, 2017.
- “$5,000,00 For Judge Bingham,” Concord Times, July 22, 1918, p. 6
- "Carolina's Early Benefactors". The Carolina Story: A Virtual Museum of University History. University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Retrieved 27 March 2023.