Misplaced Pages

McGee v. General Motors was a 1998 court case in which the jury awarded plaintiffs Robert and Connie McGee $60 million. The trial revealed hidden information about a General Motors fuel tank design. General Motors (GM) was alleged to have sacrificed vehicle safety measures in favor of additional profit. This case was featured on CNN, 60 Minutes, The New York Times, and USA Today.

Background

On July 3, 1991, Robert and Connie McGee were traveling with their children Kelly and Shane in their 1983 Oldsmobile Cutlass Cruiser. While stopped at a toll booth, the car was hit by a trailer which had disconnected from a truck several lanes away, driven by Curtis Cayton. The impact caused the trailer tongue-head to pierce the car's gas tank, resulting in a gasoline explosion.

After the accident, Shane McGee died as a result of severe burns to 98% of his body. Robert, Connie, and Kelly survived, but needed skin grafts to repair burn damage. Connie had to undergo reconstructive surgery due to extensive burns on her hands and face.

The McGees settled with the truck driver out of court, but sued General Motors for intentionally failing to provide adequate safety measures on the car.

Trial and Verdict

During the trial, testimony from several former General Motors engineers showed that the design of the fuel tank was too thin and placed too close to the ground. Also, internal documents showed that the placement of a metal shield could protect the most vulnerable parts of the gas tank and greatly improve safety, at a cost of $4.50 per vehicle.

The case was tried at the Broward County Circuit Court in Ft. Lauderdale, FL, and the plaintiffs were represented by Robert W. Kelley, John J. Uustal and Sheldon Schlesinger. General Motors was represented by James Feeney, Bud Kirk, Daniel Gerber, Terrence Russell and Jay Lefkowitz. On May 18, 1998, the jury returned a verdict of $60 million in compensatory damages, and ruled that both General Motors and Curtis Cayton were at fault.

See also

• Grimshaw v. Ford Motor Co.
• World-Wide Volkswagen Corp. v. Woodson
• General Motors of Canada Ltd v City National Leasing

References

1. ^ "Documents: GM knew of safety problems". CNN. February 14, 1998. Retrieved June 1, 2013.
2. ^ "Jury Orders GM to Pay Couple $33 Million Over Death of Son". Los Angeles Times. May 19, 1998. Retrieved June 1, 2013.
3. HENRY FITZGERALD JR (May 12, 1998). "Gm Cold-hearted, Attorney Says". Sun Sentinel. Archived from the original on December 24, 2013. Retrieved June 1, 2013.
4. ^ "Family Gets Relief". Sun Sentinel. May 19, 1998. Archived from the original on December 24, 2013. Retrieved June 1, 2013.
5. "$33M Jury Verdict Against GM". CBS News. February 11, 2009. Retrieved June 1, 2013.

v t e General Motors
Divisions and subsidiaries	Vehicle brands Buick Cadillac Chevrolet GMC Denali Hummer BrightDrop Service brands ACDelco BrightDrop Chevrolet Performance Cruise Dexron GM Certified Service GM Defense GM Financial OnStar Global subsidiaries Argentina Brazil Canada Chile Colombia Egypt Japan Mexico New Zealand GM Specialty Vehicles Cadillac Europe
Shareholdings	DMAX (60%) GM Korea (77%) HRL Laboratories (50%) Industries Mécaniques Maghrébines (20%) SAIC-GM (50%) SAIC-GM-Wuling (44%) Baojun
Products and technologies	Platforms Transmissions Hybrids Vehicles Engines I3 Family 0 SGE E-Turbo I4 Family 0 SGE Family 1 MGE Family II Ecotec V6 High Feature Gen V V8 Gen V Gemini V8 Electric EV1 BEV2 Ultium BEV3
Former divisions, joint ventures and subsidiaries	Allison Engine (1929–1995) Allison Transmission (1929–2007) Ally Financial (1919-2013) Atlantic Aircraft Bendix (24%) (1924–1948) Chevrolet Europe (2005-2016) Chevrolet-Saturn of Harlem (2006–2011) Cleveland Diesel (1938–1962) Dayton-Wright (1919–1923) Delco Electronics Delphi (1994–1999) Delta Motor Corporation (1997-2004) Detroit Diesel (1938–1988) DirecTV (1994–2003) Electro-Motive Diesel (1930–2004) Electronic Data Systems (1984–1996) Euclid Trucks (1953–1968) FAW-GM (2009–2019) Fisher Body (1925–1984) Fleetwood Metal Body (1925–1984) Frigidaire (1919–1980) Ghandhara Industries (1953–1963) GM-AvtoVAZ (2001–2019) GM Diesel (1949–1969) GM Diesel Division (1938–1987) GM Europe (1986–2017) GM India (1995–2020) GM South Africa (1913–2017) GM Thailand (2000–2020) GM Uzbekistan (2008–2019) GM Vietnam (1993–2018) GMAC Real Estate (1998–2008) GMC Heavy Trucks Holden (1948–2020) Holden Special Vehicles Hughes Aircraft (1985–1997) Hughes Electronics (1985–1997) Hughes Network Systems (1987–2003) HughesNet (1996–2003) Kettering University Maven (2016–2020) National City Lines NUMMI (1984–2009) New Venture Gear (36%, 1990–2002) Nexteer (2009–2010) North American Aviation (1933–1948) Nuvell (1997–2008) Opel (1931–2017) PanAmSat (1995–2003) Remy Electric (1918–1994) Rochester Products Terex United Australian (1989–1996) Vauxhall (1926–2017) Yellow Coach (1925–1943)
Facilities	GM Building (Broadway) GM Building (Detroit) GM Building (Manhattan) GM Technical Center GM Proving Grounds Factories (list) Renaissance Center General Motors Research Laboratory
People	William C. Durant (Founder) Mary Barra Alfred P. Sloan Tim Solso
Sponsorship	World of Motion Test Track (1999–2012 and from 2025 onwards under all of GM, Chevrolet only 2012–2024)
Related topics	History Companion make program Ignition switch recalls Motors Liquidation Company Motorama Reorganization Streetcar conspiracy 1945–46 strike 2007 strike 2019 strike Commercial Utility Cargo Vehicle Concept of the Corporation
Category Commons

• General Motors litigation
• Fuel containers
• Automotive safety
• 1998 in Florida
• 1998 in United States case law
• Florida state case law