| Porky Minch | |
|---|---|
| Mother character | |
 Porky in EarthBound | |
| First game | EarthBound (1994) |
| Created by | Shigesato Itoi |
| In-universe information | |
| Species | Human |
| Gender | Male |
Porky Minch (Japanese: ポーキー・ミンチ, Hepburn: Pōkī Minchi), known in the localization as Pokey Minch, is a character in the Mother series, also called EarthBound. He is one of the main antagonists of EarthBound, and the main antagonist of its sequel, Mother 3. He is the neighbor of the protagonist, Ness, but eventually finds himself under the influence of the main antagonist, Giygas, whom he aides in the final battle. He eventually flees after Giygas' defeat. In Mother 3, he is responsible for much death and destruction, having traveled through time and manipulating an island of people to suit his whims.
Porky was created by Shigesato Itoi, who discussed how his bad disposition was caused by parental neglect, and how Porky viewed his actions as having fun rather than being evil. He has received similar commentary from critics, who comment that Porky was someone who wanted a good family and friends, but fell to evil because of his loneliness.
Concept and creation
Porky Minch was created for EarthBound, titled Mother 2 in Japan, by the game's director, Shigesato Itoi. In the localized version, he was called Pokey. Itoi discussed how his bad disposition may have been caused by being neglected by his parents. He described Porky as a representation of humanity in Mother 3, noting how he didn't think Porky viewed himself as evil, instead stating that Porky thought he was just having fun. In the Japanese version of EarthBound, Porky is depicted being physically punished by his father, but the English version was changed to simply being refused access to dessert for a decade.
Appearances
Porky appears in EarthBound as one of its main antagonists, called Pokey in English. He is initially a neighbor to the protagonist, Ness, joining him temporarily while searching for his brother, Picky. He separates from the team when they return with Picky, getting physically punished by his father for going out at night. Porky later appears along Ness' journey, revealing that he was now a minion of Giygas, the main villain of the game. He appears multiple times throughout the game trying to prevent Ness and his friends from defeating Giygas. He finally appears in the fight against Giygas in the past, operating a spider robot and battling Ness. After Giygas is defeated, Porky flees, and later leaves a note taunting Ness and challenging him to come find him.
He appears once again in Mother 3, though he spends much of the game operating in the background. In Mother 3, an army known as the Pigmasks is wreaking chaos across the Nowhere Islands, modifying animals and killing people. One Chimera's attack kills the protagonist Lucas' mother, Hinawa, and causes his brother, Claus, to go missing, the Pigmasks take Claus away, and he is made into a mechanical Chimera to serve Porky.
Lucas and his friends are later invited to New Pork City by Porky, now known as its king, where they discover that the Nowhere Islands were established when people from the rest of the world fled to it, losing their memories in the process. Porky, having traveled through time, eventually discovers the island, and decides to play with it. Once they reach the top of the Empire Porky Building, they discover that Porky is actually extremely old and frail, explaining that his goal was to use Claus, one of the only two who could pull the needles, to awaken the Dark Dragon, killing everyone but the Dark Dragon and himself. They battle Porky, who eventually hides himself in the Absolutely Safe Capsule, ensuring that it would be impossible for him to die, but also impossible for him to exit.
A pop-up shop themed after New Pork City in Mother 3 was set up, featuring merchandise themed after Porky, as well as other characters from the series. Porky also appeared in Super Smash Bros. Brawl, where he acts as a boss opponent.
Reception
Porky has received generally positive reception. Destructoid writer Chad Concelmo discussed how sad Porky's descent was in EarthBound, noting how his "playful, rotund" features are lost by the end of the game, instead replaced by a sickly aesthetic. RPGFan staff discussed Porky as an RPG villain, comparing him to a combination of "every kid you ever hated in grade school as well as billionaire fascists of both fiction and history".
In an article discussing parenthood in the Mother series and what it represents, The A.V. Club writer William Hughes felt that Porky's abusive father and uncaring mother may have been what caused Porky to become such a horrible person as an adult. He further argued that Pokey helps reinforce the notion that a loving mom is necessary to have a "semblance of sympathetic goodness in their lives". He also drew comparisons between Pokey and Giygas in this respect, noting how Giygas remains sympathetic due to having a loving mother, despite having a neglectful father. Musician Kenichi Maeyamada felt he was only interested in money and power, contrasting him to EarthBound's main cast due to their single-minded progression. He discussed how Mother 3 reflected how Porky seemed to view Ness, and in light of the Porky in Ness' mind, made him feel sad over Porky. He also felt that his motivations for his actions came from loneliness.
Translator Clyde Mandelin discussed the localization changes, particularly changing Porky's parents to be less harsh towards him. He believed that this had the effect of a reduced examination of Porky's abusive household in the English version. Author Laure Trintignant discussed Porky's abuse, echoing the sentiment that the localization took away from Porky's character. They suggested that the fact that Porky's animosity towards Ness derived from Ness having a dad who cared about his family.
References
- EarthBound Player's Guide. Nintendo of America, Inc. 1995. p. 119.
- "ゲームの5割はユーザーのなかにある". Nindori. Archived from the original on February 1, 2014. Retrieved February 16, 2024.
- Lehtinen, Santeri. "Censorship in video games: a comparative case study of EarthBound and Mother 2" (PDF). Dalarna University. Archived (PDF) from the original on February 16, 2024. Retrieved February 18, 2024.
- December 15, 2023. "クリスマス間近の渋谷に「MOTHER3」のニューポークシティがやってきた。ユニークなグッズで一杯の「ニューポーク・パルコ・シティ」レポート". 4gamer. Archived from the original on February 19, 2024. Retrieved February 18, 2024.
{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link) - Concelmo, Chad (March 10, 2011). "The Memory Card .81: A prayer for Ness". Destructoid. Archived from the original on January 6, 2024. Retrieved February 18, 2024.
- Sollosi, Michael; Andreff, Hilary; Padilla, Eva (July 3, 2020). "Retro Encounter 243 – RPG Villains: Pokey Minch". RPGFan. Archived from the original on January 6, 2024. Retrieved February 18, 2024.
- Hughes, William (September 21, 2016). "EarthBound's absent dad reveals its mother-loving heart". The A.V. Club. Archived from the original on January 6, 2024. Retrieved February 16, 2024.
- Maeyamada, Kenichi (December 27, 2012). "【ヒャダイン】「MOTHER2」という，奇跡のゲーム". 4gamer. Archived from the original on February 16, 2024. Retrieved February 18, 2024.
- Mandelin, Clyde. "Ending". Legends of Localization. Archived from the original on February 19, 2024. Retrieved February 18, 2024.
- Trintignant, Laure (2022). Ludothèque n° 17: EarthBound. Third Editions. ISBN 978-2-37784-354-1. Archived from the original on March 12, 2024. Retrieved February 18, 2024.
| Mother series | ||
|---|---|---|
| Games |  | |
| People | ||
| Characters | ||
| Related | ||
