Misplaced Pages

Florinda Donner (originally Regine Margarita Thal, later Florinda Donner-Grau) is an American writer and anthropologist known as one of Carlos Castaneda's "witches" (the term for three women who were friends of Castaneda).

Early life

Donner was born Regine Margarita Thal in Amberg, Bavaria in Germany on February 15, 1944 to parents Rudolf Thal and Katarina Claussnitzer who in 1946 migrated to Venezuela when Donner was a child.

She studied anthropology gaining a bachelor's degree at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), in 1972, and a master's degree in 1972. She did not complete her post-graduate degree, letting her graduate studies lapse in 1977, after having advanced to doctoral candidacy. While studying she met Castaneda and worked with him on developing his thinking.

Writing

In addition to working on Castaneda's books, she wrote several books about indigenous healing, sorcery and lucid dreaming.

Shabono controversy

In 1982 Florinda Donner published a book, Shabono: A Visit to a Remote and Magical World in the South American Rain Forest, a narrative of living among the Yanomami Indians in the Venezuelan Amazon rainforest. The title is the Yanomami word for shelter, shabono.

Though the book was initially praised as a compelling account of Yanomami culture, in 1983 controversy broke out when an article in American Anthropologist accused the book of not being based on original ethnographic work, but instead being a patchwork made of previously published ethnographic accounts. Rebecca De Holmes, the author of the critique, stated that it was unlikely that Donner had spent any amount of time among the Yanomami. Particularly she criticized Donner for having plagiarized the biographical account of the Brazilian woman Helena Valero, who grew up as a captive among the Yanomami, without acknowledging having borrowed large parts of her life story. Another critical review, by Dr. Debra Picchi, argues that the book was invalid as social science because of the author's autobiographical focus on her personal development and experience, rather than on describing the Yanomami people. One critic suspected that Donner had worked from the many ethnographic movies about the Yanomami and argued that in that case her book could be considered an interpretive study of the visual documentary data.

The validity of De Holmes' critique was largely accepted by the anthropological community. Even though Donner did not anywhere claim that her book was based on having actually lived among the Yanomami, she was roundly criticized for having used the ethnographic writing genre without her work in fact being based on anthropological methods. Eventually her former doctoral committee at UCLA published a letter in the Newsletter of the American Anthropological Association, in which they expressed their disbelief in Donner's account, stating that she was present in Los Angeles during the period in which she supposedly lived among the Yanomami. When the book was published they were not aware that the author was their former student, as she had changed her name in the meantime.

Some scholars later wondered why her book was criticized for being unscientific, even though it never made any explicit claims to scientific authority. Combined with the controversy generated by the writings of Carlos Castañeda, the controversy about Donner's book contributed to sparking the ethnography "crisis of representation" of the 1980s, represented by the "Writing Culture" movement. The book is now generally considered "anthropologically-inspired fiction".

Disappearance

After the death of her mentor Carlos Castaneda in 1998, Florinda and four other women who followed Castaneda disappeared from Los Angeles, California. One of the women's bodies, Patricia Lee Partin, was discovered in Death Valley in 2003, but the location of the rest remains a mystery. The last time Florinda was seen was the day after Castaneda's death.

Works

• Shabono: A Visit to a Remote and Magical World in the South American Rain Forest. Delacorte Press. 1982. ISBN 978-0-440-07828-9.
• The Witch's Dream: A Healer's Way of Knowledge. Simon & Schuster. 1985. ISBN 978-0-671-55198-8.
• Being-in-Dreaming: An Initiation Into the Sorcerers' World. Harper Collins. 1992. ISBN 978-0-06-250192-9.

See also

• List of people who disappeared
• List of solved missing person cases

References

Citations

1. ^ Price-Williams, Edgerton & Langness (1983).
2. De Holmes (1983).
3. Picchi (1983).
4. Collier (1988), p. 78.
5. Pratt (1988), p. .
6. Ramos (1987).
7. Meares (2021).

Works cited

• Collier, John. Jr. (1988). "Visual Anthropology and the future of ethnographic film". In Rollwagen, Jack R. (ed.). Anthropological Filmmaking: Anthropological Perspectives on the Production of Film and Video for General Public Audiences. Psychology Press.
• De Holmes, R. B. (1983). "Shabono: Scandal or Superb Social Science?". American Anthropologist. 85 (3): 664–667. doi:10.1525/aa.1983.85.3.02a00130. JSTOR 678669.
• Meares, Hadley (September 2, 2021). "The Witches Of Westwood And Carlos Castaneda's Sinister Legacy". LAist. Retrieved 2024-02-19.
• Picchi, D. (1983). "Shabono: A Visit to a Remote and Magical World in the Heart of the South American Jungle by Florinda Donner". American Anthropologist. 85 (3): 674–675. doi:10.1525/aa.1983.85.3.02a00190. JSTOR 678675.
• Pratt, Mary Louise (1988). "Fieldwork in Common Places". In Clifford, James; Marcus, George (eds.). Writing Culture: The Poetics and Politics of Ethnography.
• Price-Williams, D. R.; Edgerton, R. B.; Langness, L. L. (December 1983). "Journey to a Shabono". Anthropology News. 24 (9). American Anthropological Association: 2–7. doi:10.1111/an.1983.24.9.2.6.
• Ramos, A. R. (1987). "Reflecting on the Yanomami: Ethnographic Images and the Pursuit of the Exotic". Cultural Anthropology. 2 (3): 284–304. doi:10.1525/can.1987.2.3.02a00020. S2CID 144771198.

• 1944 births
• Living people
• 20th-century American women
• American women anthropologists
• American women writers
• German emigrants to Venezuela
• Neoshamanism
• New Age writers
• People from Amberg
• University of California, Los Angeles alumni
• Venezuelan expatriates in the United States
• Writers from Los Angeles
• 1990s missing person cases
• Missing person cases in California
• Venezuelan women anthropologists