Misplaced Pages

The Famine Within is a Canadian documentary film, directed by Katherine Gilday and released in 1990. The film explores the issue of women's body image, and the prevalence of eating disorders. The film was narrated by Rebecca Jenkins.The Famine Within is an exploration of the contemporary obsession with body size and shape among North American women. Through the use of conventional documentary interviews and narration in conjunction with striking evocative imagery, the film presents women sharing their own experiences suffering with an eating disorder. The direct testimony of many women who have suffered from the body obsession – dancers, mothers, career women, athletes, bulimics, fat women, anorexics, young girls - with the views of leading experts, this work explores the kind of hunger that cannot be satisfied by food. The film is less about illness associated with food, but more raises questions about why so many women are worried about gaining weight or “being fat” The film premiered at the 1990 Festival of Festivals. It was subsequently broadcast by TVOntario.

Significance

The Famine Within was significant film for the time as it was a direct commentary on the rising numbers of eating disorders among women. The film explores the effects of an ideal feminine beauty on girls and women today, as well as, the social and ideological consequences of their obsession with diet and exercise. Among the many matters discussed are contemporary notions of the superwoman (an image combining thinness and status); the muddled and extreme moral judgments placed on fatness and obesity in our culture; the relation of the Garden of Eden myth to contemporary concepts relating women to food and nature; the ideological implications of the current “fitness” craze. The film is less about illness associated with food, but more raises questions about why so many women are worried about gaining weight or “being fat”.

Participants

Written by producer-director Katherine Gilday and narrated by actress Rebecca Jenkins featuring various models filmed in a studio. The various women interviewed are all different ages, shapes, and sizes; they range from therapists to patients, from teachers to pupils, from experts to amateurs, and from little girls to young women to gray eminences. With the exception of Paul Ernsberger who is a medical researcher all the participants in the film are women. (9) All the women who speak in the film are white and middle-class, with the exception of the original two-hour TV special.

Themes

Eating disorders, body image, consumerism, mass media

Awards

It won the Genie Award for Best Feature Length Documentary at the 12th Genie Awards.

Praise and Criticism

Cynthia Lucia of Cinéaste states that the film is moving, highly-charged, and “conceptually and visually polished”. She also observed that a scene in which a model carries a perfectly-proportioned mannequin instead of a brief case is probably an attempt by Gilday to add visual variety, but instead seems “forced and almost silly”. - Cynthia Lucia, Cinéaste, NY: 1991.

In a subsequent interview with Katherine Gilday in Cinéaste, she refers to a critic at The Village Voice who was concerned that The Famine Within only presents the internal psychological issues and concerns regarding women’s relationship with their weight. Gilday believes she was clearly portraying a “culturally-determined mode of oppression” (5).

Some criticism the film received was that it did not attempt to discuss how cultures outside North America approach the issue of women and weight.(10) In addition, Jonathan Rosenbaum a feminist film scholar criticized the film for its lack of diversity in subjects, featuring only white middle-class women in the 90-minute version. However the full two-hour TV special did hear from women of colour.

The film was praised by Gail Vanstone in her dissertation on Studio D’s films stating that it was “a meticulous well researched documentary that analyses the contemporary problem of North American women’s self image. Mostly composed of talking heads the famine within nevertheless manages to hold together remarkably well. The film presents the case that the modern image of the tall, rail thin supermodel runs counter to nature and ideology and that women are tyrannized by cultural ideals of beauty imposed upon them by patriarchy and the diet industry to the point where one painfully thin young women (who speaks for many) say “I’d rather be dead than fat’”.

References

1. ^ "Feeding our fear of the bathroom scale". Kingston Whig-Standard, October 22, 1990.
2. ^ "Women's bodies: A painful obsession Toronto filmmaker explores the emptiness that food can't satisfy". Toronto Star, September 6, 1990.
3. "The Festival", Human Rights Film Festivals, Palgrave Macmillan, 2015, doi:10.1057/9781137454249.0020, ISBN 9781137454249, S2CID 217750194
4. ^ "4. Documenting Lives / Les documents biographiques", Documenting a Province/Chronique d'une province, University of Toronto Press, 2003-01-31, doi:10.3138/9781442673991-009, ISBN 9781442673991
5. "Frederic, Harold, (19 Aug. 1856–19 Oct. 1898), author, journalist; London representative New York Times", Who Was Who, Oxford University Press, 2007-12-01, doi:10.1093/ww/9780199540884.013.u186154
6. "Brilliant portrait of a dark obsession: Compelling documentary explores the debilitating eating disorders that reflect North American society's unnatural ideal of the female form". The Globe and Mail, September 20, 1990.
7. Fleming, Keith (August 2015). "HumanitiesP.E. Bryden."A Justifiable Obsession": Conservative Ontario's Relations with Ottawa, 1943–1985. University of Toronto Press. x, 318. $34.95". University of Toronto Quarterly. 84 (3): 308–310. doi:10.3138/utq.84.3.308. ISSN 0042-0247. S2CID 163019957.
8. "Picks and Pans Review: The Famine Within". PEOPLE.com. Retrieved 2019-03-26.
9. "Black Robe sweeps top Genie awards". Ottawa Citizen, November 27, 1991.
10. Gili, Jean Antoine (1991). "Marcello Pagliero, cinéaste italo-français". 1895 Mille Huit Cent Quatre-vingt-quinze. 10 (1): 43–60. doi:10.3406/1895.1991.967. ISSN 0769-0959.

External links

• The Famine Within at IMDb
• The Famine Within at the National Film Board of Canada catalog

• 1990 films
• 1990 documentary films
• Canadian documentary films
• Best Documentary Film Genie and Canadian Screen Award winners
• National Film Board of Canada documentaries
• Films about eating disorders
• Documentary films about mental disorders
• 1990s English-language films
• 1990s Canadian films
• Documentary films about women
• English-language documentary films