Misplaced Pages

The Leader, His Driver and the Driver's Wife is a 1991 British feature-length documentary film set during the final days of apartheid in South Africa, particularly centring on Eugène Terre'Blanche, founder and leader of the far-right Afrikaner Weerstandsbeweging (AWB). The film was directed by Nick Broomfield and first shown in 1991. It received an average of 2.3 million viewers during its screening on Channel 4. A year later it was the subject of legal action brought by the journalist, Jani Allan, in what was described as "the libel case of the summer". In 2006, Broomfield released a follow-up, His Big White Self.

Background

Throughout the film, Broomfield attempts to set up an interview with Terre'Blanche, who stubbornly breaks all of the plans he makes with him.

For the majority of the film, in which Broomfield is unable to get an interview with the leader himself, his attention is drawn to the driver and his wife (JP and Anita Meyer), hence the title (which alludes to the title of Peter Greenaway's 1989 film The Cook, the Thief, His Wife & Her Lover).

Broomfield also spent time with a town councillor and diamond mine owner named Johann, and his friend Anton. Broomfield had planned to interview Boervolk leader Piet Rudolph but when on the outskirts of Pretoria, a news broadcast informed them that he had been arrested, and Rudolph was a fugitive wanted in connection with the theft of some arms from an SA Defence Force base located in Pretoria. After his arrest in Pretoria, Rudolph was dubbed the "South African Bobby Sands" in reference to his proclamation that he would go on a hunger strike to promote his (and the AWB's) cause for a white homeland.

The film also makes light of the ongoing saga of trying to get an interview with the leader, something which Broomfield eventually manages to do, although he is only able to ask one question after Terre'Blanche takes particular offence when Broomfield and his crew turn up five minutes late for the interview. The film ends with Broomfield and his crew at an AWB rally where a crowd of 5,000 were expected, but in reality not even half that number are present. The credits roll soon after Terre'Blanche again breaks into fits of rage, citing supposed security violations committed by Broomfield's camera crew.

The documentary was released in the UK as a DVD boxset, together with His Big White Self, in April 2006.

Main characters

• Eugène Terre'Blanche.
• J.P Meyer. JP is 'the leader's' personal driver and a prominent member of the AWB party. Although the film was intended to focus largely on the leader, much of Broomfield and his crew's time is spent with JP and his wife. The film encounters JP shortly after his release from prison for his alleged involvement with white terrorists, notably his connection to Piet Rudolph. During much of the film, JP's personal nature largely displays elements of prejudice against black people. When asked by Broomfield if he ever felt sorry for Nelson Mandela when he was incarcerated on Robben Island, he simply replies that he doesn't feel sorry "for that bloody kaffir" (a racist term for a black person). He even proclaims himself to be a racist during the conversation. In spite of this, the film also follows JP's growing disillusionment with the AWB and their struggle for a white homeland, particularly after Piet Rudolph ends his hunger strike and calls on people to give up their weapons. Towards the end of the film, JP leaves his post as driver to the leader and it is later revealed at the film's conclusion that he left the AWB entirely, opening up a small electrical business.
• Anita Meyer. Anita is JP's long-suffering wife. Unlike most of the film's other characters, she clearly has a dislike for the leader. During a conversation with Broomfield, she sees Terre'Blanche as a domineering figure and tends not to speak of him in high regard. Anita works as a nurse and her chief concerns, according to Nick, are the distribution of condoms and the sterilisation of women. Like JP, she tends not to be very liberal in her views on black people and can be seen at an AWB rally smiling when a child proclaims that he'll hit any black child who attends his white school. She is also filmed with her pet cat, which is named Kaffir cat. The reason being, in her own words, is that the cat is black, and as "blacks are called kaffirs", it has seemingly been 'appropriately named'. Broomfield would later to go on to dub Anita of "kaffir cat fame" in his follow up film, in reference to the episode.
• Johann and Anton. Johann is a town councillor in Ventersdorp who also owns a diamond mine and tractor business. He is often seen throughout the film with his friend Anton. Both express prejudiced views on black people, including the belief that blacks should be forbidden from having sexual relations with whites, concluding that it will lead to the spread of AIDS, causing the depletion of the white population in South Africa. Johann is also seen at the town's local swimming pool, claiming it to be for whites only.

Libel suit

In 1992, the former columnist Jani Allan sued Channel 4, the British broadcaster, for libel, claiming that in the documentary The Leader, His Driver and the Driver's Wife she was presented as a "woman of easy virtue". Amidst a montage of photographs from Allan's earlier days as a photographic model, and quotes from her articles in the South African Sunday Times, Broomfield claimed that Jani Allan had had an affair with Terre'Blanche. The significance of the case led to its inclusion in the 1992 annual edition of Whitaker's Almanack.

During the libel case, Channel 4 denied the claim that the film had suggested Allan had had an affair with Terre'Blanche. Prior to the case, Allan had been awarded £40,000 in out-of-court settlements from the Evening Standard and Options magazine over suggestive remarks made about the nature of Allan's association with Terre'Blanche.

Allan was represented by Peter Carter-Ruck in the case, and Channel 4 was represented by George Carman. Carman described the case as rare in that it had "international, social, political and cultural implications".

The case sparked intense media interest in both Britain and South Africa, with several court transcripts appearing in the press; Allan told Carman, "Whatever award is given for libel, being cross-examined by you would not make it enough money." Several character witnesses were flown in from South Africa.

Terre'Blanche also submitted a sworn statement to the London court denying that he had had an affair with Allan. Allan's case was dealt a heavy blow by the statements of her former flatmate, Linda Shaw, the Sunday Times astrologer. Shaw admitted that she peeped through a keyhole and witnessed Allan in a compromising position with a man. Allan's QC, Charles Gray dismissed Shaw's "wildly unlikely" testimony and stressed the physical impossibility of her claim. He continued to express that her field of vision through the keyhole would not be sufficient to support her claim.

On day two of the court hearings, Allan's 1984 notebook was mysteriously delivered to Carman's counsel and used against her. This was investigated by the police, according to reports a "one-time friend" had taken the notebook from the home where Allan stayed with an English couple in 1989.

Allan's former husband Gordon Schachat provided evidence supporting claims Allan had made about sex, and insisted she was neither an extreme right-winger or anti-Semitic.

On day 11 of the case, Anthony Travers, a former British representative of the AWB, and spectator of the court, was stabbed. A court usher received a call saying Peter Carter-Ruck, Allan's lawyer, had been stabbed. This stemmed from a message by Travers, who was lying in an alleyway: he said to a passer-by, "tell Carter-Ruck I've been stabbed". It quickly spread that Carter-Ruck had been stabbed, followed by speculation that he was the intended victim.

During the court case, Allan's London flat was burgled. She said that she received a death threat on a telephone call in the court ushers' offices. The hotel room of a Channel 4 producer, Stevie Godson, was also ransacked.

Allan lost the case on 5 August 1992. The judge found that Channel 4's allegations had not defamed Allan; he did not rule on whether or not there had been an affair. Reports emerged that Allan was considering an appeal and Terre'Blanche also expressed the possibility that he might sue the broadcaster for libel. Following the verdict, Allan reiterated her stance "I am not, nor have I ever been, involved with Terre'Blanche".

Soon after, several publications speculated about political forces at play during the case. The Independent published details of what it called "dirty tricks" used during the libel case. Allan suggested that pro-government forces in South Africa wanted her to lose the case so that Terre'Blanche would be "irreparably damaged" in the eyes of his "God fearing Calvinist followers". Another interpretation is that the AWB wanted to steal a manuscript of a book she was writing about the organisation. The AWB countered these claims, although Travers described the book as "dynamite." The South African business newspaper Financial Mail published a lead story on 6 August detailing the "theory" that F.W. de Klerk had orchestrated the libel case to discredit Terre'Blanche and the far right movement in South Africa.

In 1995, during an interview with SABC, Allan accused witnesses in the case of being paid to lie.

In a 2002 BBC film, Get Carman: the trials of George Carman QC, Allan's case was dramatised together with other high-profile Carman cases.

The libel suit is mentioned amid a montage of photos and camera footage of Jani Allan and reporters outside the London court in 1992 in the 2006 Nick Broomfield film His Big White Self, a sequel to The Leader, His Driver and the Driver's Wife, the documentary that spawned the libel suit.

References

1. Victim dragged into TV film 'for sex angle', The Guardian. 4 August 1992. p.2
2. "Diary". The Independent. 13 August 1992. Retrieved 11 June 2023.
3. "Channel 4 sued". The Independent. 21 July 1992. Retrieved 11 June 2023.
4. "What's This Channel 4?". Channel 4. Archived from the original on 9 November 2007. Retrieved 21 April 2020.
5. Marsden, Hilary. Whitaker's Almanack1992. J Whitaker & Sons.
6. Ward, Stephen (6 August 1992). "Jani Allan fights on despite 300,000 pounds libel costs". The Independent. Retrieved 11 June 2023.
7. Hoge, Warren (8 January 2000). "George Carman, Libel Suit Whiz, Dies". The New York Times. Retrieved 11 June 2023.
8. Dyer, Clare (16 April 2000). "Judging history". The Guardian. Retrieved 11 June 2023.
9. "Courtroom 14: the Owl has landed". The Independent. 25 July 1992. Retrieved 11 June 2023.
10. Dreyer, Nadine. A Century of Sundays: 100 Years of Breaking News in the Sunday Times, 1906–2006. Zebra.
11. "Jani Allan jury asked to identify 'enemy of truth'". The Independent. 4 August 1992. Retrieved 11 June 2023.
12. ^ Cohen, Nick; Connett, David; McGreal, Chris (9 August 1992). "Four dirty tricks they played during the Jani Allan case: Nick Cohen and David Connett in London and Chris McGreal in Johannesburg peer into the murky background surrounding last week's Jani Allan libel case". The Independent. Retrieved 11 June 2023.
13. "Journalist in libel case 'celibate'". The Independent. 24 July 1992. Retrieved 11 June 2023.
14. Ward, Stephen (28 July 1992). "Witness had sex 'to help libel action by friend'". The Independent. Retrieved 11 June 2023.
15. Man stabbed in pub near Jani Allan court hearing The Independent. 4 August 1992
16. "Century of Sundays". Carte Blanche (TV series). 3 May 2006. Archived from the original on 27 September 2006.
17. Allan may appeal The Independent. 7 August 1992
18. Terre-Blanche threatens to sue Channel 4 The Independent. 10 August 1992
19. Quote Unquote The Independent. 8 August 1992
20. Jani Allan libel case: Misunderstanding and comic relief. The Times. 6 August 1992, p.3
21. "JANI ALLAN – BORN AGAIN CHRISTIAN". Sapa. 2 January 1995. Archived from the original on 27 September 2007.
22. "Judgement day". New Statesman. 8 April 2002.

External links

• The Leader, His Driver and the Driver's Wife at IMDb

• 1991 films
• Afrikaner Weerstandsbeweging
• Films directed by Nick Broomfield
• 1990s English-language films
• Documentary films about apartheid
• Documentary films about politicians
• South African documentary films
• British documentary films
• 1991 documentary films
• 1990s British films
• English-language documentary films