Misplaced Pages

West-Park Presbyterian Church
View from the corner of Amsterdam Avenue and 86th Street
General information
Architectural style	Richardsonian Romanesque / Romanesque Revival
Town or city	New York, New York
Country	United States
Coordinates	40°47′16″N 73°58′29″W / 40.78778°N 73.97472°W / 40.78778; -73.97472
Construction started	1889
Completed	1884, 1890
Cost	? (1884) $100,000+ (1890)
Client	The Presbytery of New York
Technical details
Structural system	Brown and red sandstone masonry
Design and construction
Architect(s)	Leopold Eidlitz Henry Franklin Kilburn
Website
www.westparkpresbyterian.org

West-Park Presbyterian Church is a Romanesque Revival Presbyterian church located on the corner of Amsterdam Avenue at 86th Street on the Upper West Side of Manhattan in New York City. It consists of a main sanctuary and chapel.

Congregation history

The congregation was founded in 1852 as the 84th Street Presbyterian Church, building its first chapel of timber in 1854 on 84th Street and West End Avenue, to designs by one of the city's most prominent architects, Prague-born Leopold Eidlitz. The church changed its name to Park Presbyterian Church in 1887. The name became West-Park Presbyterian (alternatively spelled West Park) when the midtown West Presbyterian Church (founded 1829) merged with Park Presbyterian in 1911.

Church building

The small congregation moved north in Upper Manhattan. Upon moving to the Upper West Side, one wealthy new pastor (from 1879), Anson Phelps Atterbury (1855–1931), proposed a grand church in the hopes that the congregation would expand along with the rest of the neighborhood. That pastor commissioned Leopold Eidlitz to build a diminutive midblock brick Romanesque Revival chapel in 1884, a style Eidlitz described as "muscular" Romanesque and considered appropriate to an evangelical Protestant church. After a further $100,000 was raised, the main sanctuary was built in 1889–90 on the abutting corner site, to designs by Henry Franklin Kilburn in intricately carved brown and red sandstone in a stylistic continuation of Eidlitz's Romanesque chapel but re-cladding that brick chapel in sandstone and adding an offset diminutive tower. The corner features a giant ribbed bell-domed belltower, which dominates the neighborhood and if not for the competing heights of apartment towers "would be one of the West Side's loveliest landmarks," according to the AIA Guide to NYC.

In 2016, the church hosted SONNET REMIX 2, a celebration of Shakespeare's Sonnets featuring artists presenting the sonnets including Stairwell Theater, Carman Moore, Jason Trachtenburg, Joel Gold, Ariana Karp, Matt and Rafferty of Evolfo.

Preservation

In the 1980s, the church was re-pointed with cement, which has resulted in substantial erosion of the soft sandstone. Around the same time, the church installed a new elevator for handicap accessibility in the parish house (the original chapel).

In the early 2000s, the congregation hired a developer to address their financial situation, diminished attendance, and role in society. Their findings proposed the replacement of the complex with an eighteen- to twenty-three-story residential tower and a smaller new corner glass church, designed by the architectural firm of Franke, Gottsegen & Cox. The design featured a "prow-shaped base of stone," with a sweeping 125-foot glass carillon tower providing "a luminous well of light." The current social outreach and education facilities would be doubled and the modern design, the architects asserted, would create a sense of refuge and "communitarian communality." The architects described the design: "...the crisscrossing of the structure, like a canopy of trees, but you won't be able to see the top, which we think is an expression of sacredness," adding, "the sanctuary is very flexible and interfaith use is possible so that space can be shared with other denominations."

In response, activists organized the "Friends of West-Park" to protest the development while concurrently working toward a viable alternative plan as well as funds. The group principally feared the loss of air and light with the new tower. The co-chairman of Friends of West-Park stated that the group was not interested "in telling the church that it had to maintain itself for the community good without the community taking some role formed a development company capable of doing what say and working on a partnership with the church." The "Friends" suggested selling Eidlitz's chapel for redevelopment to a non-profit, probably a school, to offset the cost of renovation, with neighboring buildings preparing to lease air rights. Most of the external walls would be preserved, restoring the sandstone and stained glass but not the original roof shape nor the forty-foot interior, which would be gutted. Its sanctuary would be raised to gallery level and fitted with movable seating; since divided windows already exist, the alteration would not be externally evident, leaving the commercially ideal ground floor for other uses, possibly social outreach or educational. One architect responsible for the sympathetic second plan explained that "successful rehabilitation allows the character and original intent of the first architect to come through. So the question is, If not every square inch is sacred turf, how much modification can the structure bear without losing what makes it special?" Rev. Brashear of West-Park was quoted as receptive to the community input but stated that the congregation, trustees, and various levels of the Presbytery are still deciding the unprotected church's fate.

The congregation moved to share space in 2008 with the neighboring Renaissance Revival-styled, Saints Paul and Andrew United Methodist Church (1897), protected as a city landmark and itself a product of a 1937 denominational merger.

The church was designated as an Individual Landmark by the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission on January 12, 2010.

In April 2022, it was announced that the West-Park congregation would seek permission to demolish the building under the hardship provision of the New York Landmarks Law, citing their inability to provide or source funds for repairs. The building had been surrounded since 2001 by a sidewalk shed that shielded pedestrians from potential falling masonry, and the congregation had paid $45,000 in fines since 1993. The congregation initially estimated the cost of repairs at $30 to $50 million, but this figure was disputed by the neighborhood's Councilmember Gale Brewer. A successful appeal would allow for the sale of the church site to Alchemy Properties, who will replace the existing structure with a residential building that incorporates worship space for the congregation. Opponents of the demolition included actors Matt Damon, Mark Ruffalo, and Wendell Pierce; rapper Common; and filmmaker Kenneth Lonergan. Although an independent analysis published in October 2023 found that the church would be very expensive to repair, West-Park withdrew its application to demolish the church in January 2024.

See also

• National Register of Historic Places listings in Manhattan from 59th to 110th Streets
• List of New York City Designated Landmarks in Manhattan from 59th to 110th Streets

References

1. ^ Mosette Broderick and Lauren Jacobi of the Committee to preserve West-Park Presbyterian Church of the Friends of West-Park, a not-for-profit NY State corporation. Landmark: West-Park Presbyterian Church; West-Park Presbyterian: Landmarking a Cultural and Architectural Icon (October 2007)
2. ^ New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission. West Park Presbyterian Church
3. Zaveri, Mihir (January 5, 2024). "Upper West Side Church Championed by Celebrities Won't Be Razed for Now". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved February 28, 2024.
4. Stern, Robert A. M.; Mellins, Thomas; Fishman, David (1999). New York 1880: Architecture and Urbanism in the Gilded Age. Monacelli Press. pp. 770, 772, 773. ISBN 978-1-58093-027-7. OCLC 40698653.; Robert Miles Parker, The Upper West Side, New York (New York: Harry N. Abrams, 1988), p.125.
5. Kathryn E. Holliday, Leopold Eidlitz: Architecture and Idealism in the Gilded Age (New York: W. W. Norton and Company, 2008), p.171
6. ^ J. Russiello, A Sympathetic Planning Hierarchy for Redundant Churches: A Comparison of Continued Use and Reuse in Denmark, England and the United States of America (MSc Conservation of Historic Buildings, University of Bath, 2008), pp 26–31.
7. "Block 1217 Lot 1"; The Upper West Side Book
8. Norval White and Elliot Willensky, AIA Guide to New York City, rev. ed., (New York: Collier Books, 1978), p.196.
9. "West Park Presbyterian Church". west park presbyterian. June 22, 2016.
10. Wirednewyork.com
11. ^ Brozan, Nadine (April 25, 2004). "Sacred Space But Earthly Challenges". The New York Times. Retrieved January 6, 2024.
12. "Wired New York – Forum"
13. Saints Paul and Andrew United Methodist Church (1895–1897) by Robert H. Robertson on the northeast corner of West End Avenue and 86th Street. See Herbert R. Broderick, United Methodist Church of St. Paul and St. Andrew (New York: Citizens Committee to Preserve the Church of St. Paul and St. Andrew, 1980), p.4-12.
14. Andrew S. Dolkart and Nancy Goeschel, "Designation List 150: Church of St. Paul and St. Andrew," (New York: Landmarks Preservation Commission, 1981), p.1-4.
15. Norval White and Elliot Willensky, AIA Guide to New York City, rev. ed., (New York: Collier Books, 1978), p.185.
16. "Testimony before the Landmarks Preservation Commission", July 14, 2009 Council Member Gale A. Brewer, 6th District, West Side of Manhattan Archived May 27, 2010, at the Wayback Machine
17. The New York Landmarks Conservancy, "Sacred Sites: West-Park Presbyterian Church – Manhattan" (Retrieved May 5, 2011).
18. "REPORT: West-Park Presbyterian Church May be Razed". April 6, 2022.
19. "West Side Rag » the Answer Column: Why Has a Sidewalk Shed on 86th Street Been up for 18 Years?".
20. Lovinger, Joe (June 6, 2022). "West-Park Presyterian Church Development Blocked by Activists". The Real Deal. Retrieved January 6, 2024.
21. ^ Venugopal, Arun (May 6, 2022). "Bid to spare West Park Presbyterian Church from demolition wins Upper West Side committee's support". Gothamist. Retrieved January 6, 2024.
22. ^ Kvetenadze, Téa (June 13, 2023). "Manhattanites sound off on future of West Park Presbyterian Church on UWS". New York Daily News. Retrieved January 6, 2024.
23. Barron, James (November 8, 2023). "Matt Damon Joins Fight Over Upper West Side Church". The New York Times. Retrieved January 6, 2024.
24. Zaveri, Mihir (June 26, 2023). "Why Mark Ruffalo and Wendell Pierce Are Fighting for a Crumbling Church". The New York Times. Retrieved January 6, 2024.
25. Jones, Orion (November 6, 2023). "Preserve or Demolish: How One NYC Church Could Survive". The Real Deal. Retrieved January 6, 2024.
26. Hallum, Mark (October 31, 2023). "Study Sides With West-Park Church That Repairs Don't Have Enough ROI". Commercial Observer. Retrieved January 6, 2024.
27. Zaveri, Mihir (January 5, 2024). "West Park Presbyterian Church Will Not Be Demolished, For Now". The New York Times. Retrieved January 6, 2024.

• 19th-century Presbyterian church buildings in the United States
• Churches completed in 1884
• Churches completed in 1890
• Churches in Manhattan
• Leopold Eidlitz church buildings
• New York City Designated Landmarks in Manhattan
• Presbyterian churches in New York City
• Romanesque Revival church buildings in New York City
• Rundbogenstil churches
• Upper West Side