| Revision as of 20:02, 5 May 2007 editJustanother (talk | contribs)9,266 edits →Controversy: Again, let's go with what it says, not with what our POV wants it to say.← Previous edit | Revision as of 20:08, 5 May 2007 edit undoWikipediatrix (talk | contribs)9,623 edits I still like my version best. The YHRI isn't even remotely important enough to edit-war over, but it's the principle of the thing, don'tcha know.Next edit → | ||
| Line 22: | Line 22: | ||
| ==Controversy== | ==Controversy== | ||
| Controversy over Youth for Human Rights International is twofold. | |||
| ], the controversial Commissioner for the ], has accused the YHRI of being a Scientology "]" meant to attract and recruit the young. <ref name="weltcaberta"> {{cite web | url = http://www.welt.de/print-welt/article707504/Form_des_politischen_Extremismus.html | title = A form of political extremism | | accessdate = 2007-04-17 | author = Thomas Klatt | date = ] | publisher = ]}}</ref> However, Caberta has repeatedly come under fire for her bias and for suspicion of corruption after it was determined she had improperly received 75,000 dollars from anti-Scientology interests. These legal proceedings against Caberta were dropped upon her payment of a 7,500 euro fine. <ref></ref> | |||
| The first stems from the repeated failure on the part of the group to clearly identify its ties to the Church of Scientology. YHRI was founded by, and is largely staffed and financed by, Scientologists, and its message is based to a large extent on L. Ron Hubbard's writings. This has led to concerns that YHRI was pushing a Scientology agenda. | |||
| ⚫ | Germany considers Scientology to be a commercial organization and a form of political extremism that poses a threat to its democracy and constitution, themselves the basis of human rights in Germany. <ref> {{ cite web | url = http://www.germany.info/relaunch/info/archives/background/scientology.html | title = German Embassy statement on Scientology }} </ref> <ref>{{cite web | url = http://www.verfassungsschutz-bw.de/so/so_grunde.htm | title = Baden-Wuerttemberg Office for the Protection of the Constitution, Scientology }}</ref> | ||
| ⚫ | YHRI's failure to disclose its Scientology connection led to trouble with sponsors -- among them the Florida Holocaust Museum -- at a human rights march the group organized in ] in March 2007.<ref>{{cite web | url = http://www.sptimes.com/2007/04/07/Southpinellas/Tie_to_rights_march_w.shtml | title = Tie to rights march wasn't revealed | accessdate = 2007-04-14 | author = Meg Laughlin | coauthors = Rob Farley | date = ] | publisher = ]}}</ref> In another instance, the group was accused of luring unwitting high-schoolers to a forum run by Scientologists at the ] State ] in ].<ref |
||
| ⚫ | YHRI's failure to disclose its Scientology connection led to trouble with sponsors -- among them the Florida Holocaust Museum -- at a human rights march the group organized in ] in March 2007.<ref>{{cite web | url = http://www.sptimes.com/2007/04/07/Southpinellas/Tie_to_rights_march_w.shtml | title = Tie to rights march wasn't revealed | accessdate = 2007-04-14 | author = Meg Laughlin | coauthors = Rob Farley | date = ] | publisher = ]}}</ref> In another instance, the group was accused of luring unwitting high-schoolers to a forum run by Scientologists at the ] State ] in ].<ref>{{cite news | first = Anna | last = Patty | title = Unwitting high-schoolers lured to forum run by Scientologists | url = http://www.smh.com.au/news/national/unwitting-highschoolers-lured-to-forum-run-by-scientologists/2007/03/27/1174761471748.html | publisher = ] | date = ] | accessdate = 2007-03-28 | quote = }}</ref> | ||
| ⚫ | In each of the above cases the YHRI organizer responded that, while the Church of Scientology supported their group, it was a YHRI event, not a Church event and the message was human rights, not Scientology. |
||
| ⚫ | In each of the above cases the YHRI organizer responded that, while the Church of Scientology supported their group, it was a YHRI event, not a Church event and the message was human rights, not Scientology. | ||
| In 2005, administrators at a Los Angeles high school required students have their parents' permission before attending a YHRI event, after discovering the group's ties to Scientology. <ref>{{cite news | title = Scientology group sponsors school event | url = http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-9663283_ITM | date = ] | publisher = UPI Newstrack}}</ref> | In 2005, administrators at a Los Angeles high school required students have their parents' permission before attending a YHRI event, after discovering the group's ties to Scientology. <ref>{{cite news | title = Scientology group sponsors school event | url = http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-9663283_ITM | date = ] | publisher = UPI Newstrack}}</ref> | ||
| Line 37: | Line 38: | ||
| Scientology sees the stance of these countries as discrimination, <ref>CoS HR Dept: Documenting and Exposing Government Discrimination http://www.scientology.org/humanrights/photo/government-discrimination/index.htm</ref> and is presently conducting a campaign through the Church of Scientology International European Office for Public Affairs and Human Rights, and with the help of YHRI, in Europe. <ref>Church of Scientology International European Office for Public Affairs and Human Rights, News http://www.scientology-europe.org/ </ref> In Brussels last year, Julie Barreau, a reporter for Le Soir magazine, recorded the speaker of a Scientology meeting as saying: "We must take control of Belgium. Their intentions are the same as the Nazis. We have to educate the forces of the fourth Reich about human rights." <ref>{{cite web | first = Julie | last = Barreau | title = Scientology takes aim at Brussels | url = http://www.anti-scientologie.ch/lesoir-magazine.htm | publisher = Le Soir Magazine | date = ] | accessdate = 2007-04-16}}</ref> | Scientology sees the stance of these countries as discrimination, <ref>CoS HR Dept: Documenting and Exposing Government Discrimination http://www.scientology.org/humanrights/photo/government-discrimination/index.htm</ref> and is presently conducting a campaign through the Church of Scientology International European Office for Public Affairs and Human Rights, and with the help of YHRI, in Europe. <ref>Church of Scientology International European Office for Public Affairs and Human Rights, News http://www.scientology-europe.org/ </ref> In Brussels last year, Julie Barreau, a reporter for Le Soir magazine, recorded the speaker of a Scientology meeting as saying: "We must take control of Belgium. Their intentions are the same as the Nazis. We have to educate the forces of the fourth Reich about human rights." <ref>{{cite web | first = Julie | last = Barreau | title = Scientology takes aim at Brussels | url = http://www.anti-scientologie.ch/lesoir-magazine.htm | publisher = Le Soir Magazine | date = ] | accessdate = 2007-04-16}}</ref> | ||
| ], the Commissioner for the ], has accused the YHRI of being one of a number of Scientology-linked groups that mask their connection to the church and seek to attract and recruit the young. | |||
| ⚫ | Germany considers Scientology to be a commercial organization and a form of political extremism that poses a threat to its democracy and constitution, themselves the basis of human rights in Germany. <ref> {{ cite web | url = http://www.germany.info/relaunch/info/archives/background/scientology.html | title = German Embassy statement on Scientology }} </ref> <ref>{{cite web | url = http://www.verfassungsschutz-bw.de/so/so_grunde.htm | title = Baden-Wuerttemberg Office for the Protection of the Constitution, Scientology }}</ref> | ||
| ==See also== | ==See also== | ||
Revision as of 20:08, 5 May 2007
Template:ScientologySeries Youth for Human Rights International (YHRI) is a non-profit organization based in Los Angeles, California at 1332 L. Ron Hubbard Way, whose stated mission is "To teach youth around the globe about human rights, thus helping them to become valuable advocates for the promotion of tolerance and peace." Specifically, it promotes L. Ron Hubbard's thought and the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
Leadership
YHRI's president and founder is Mary Shuttleworth (formerly Mary Untiedt), former president of YHRI's parent organization International Foundation for Human Rights and Tolerance. She also founded the Applied Scholastics schools "Shuttleworth Academy" and "Mary's Schoolhouse". Shuttleworth holds an executive position at TXL Films the company who created the music video UNITED with YHRI. She is a Scientologist.
According to the newsletter Church of Scientology International, YHRI's Executive Director is Tim Bowles, former law partner of Bowles & Moxon, serving as general legal council for the Church of Scientology. Bowles also acts as an advisor to Scientology's Citizens Commission on Human Rights.
Lynsey Bartilson, who appears on the television series "Grounded for Life," is YHRI's most visible spokesperson. She was raised and remains a Scientologist, and her mother Laurie Bartilson was a former law partner at the at Moxon & Bartilson. In her online biography, she states that she worked as creative director and choreographer for the Scientology Celebrity Center’s “Kids on Stage for A Better World.”
Programs
YHRI has teamed with TXL Films (founded by Taron Lexton, son of YHRI founder Mary Shuttleworth ) to create the award-winning music video, "UNITED." In June 2006, they released 30 public service announcements for TV, illustrating each of the 30 rights in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights., which were created together with the Human Rights Department of the Church of Scientology International.
Activities
YHRI distributes material concerning L.Ron Hubbard's thought, the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights and YHRI programs to schoolchildren in a variety of developed nations, for example in the United States, Australia, the United Kingdom and the Czech Republic. It handed out a prize in Belgium, and held an awards ceremony for the same prize in Bulgaria. It is also active in Germany . It awarded one prize to a Chinese actress who promoted human rights on her web site, and another to a young Israeli Scientologist who screened its film, United, and distributed its materials in his school. . It held a conference in Zurich. It discussed plans to lecture and distribute its materials to schoolchildren in Ghana and Liberia. It advocated lower school fees in Uganda, and held a peace rally in Nigeria. In South Africa, Mary Shuttleworth's country of origin, it is pushing for a "human rights month." The organization's work is supported by the actor and Scientologist Tom Cruise and cooperates with other human rights organizations such as local chapters of Amnesty International.
Controversy
Ursula Caberta, the controversial Commissioner for the Scientology Workgroup of the Hamburg Interior Authority, has accused the YHRI of being a Scientology "front group" meant to attract and recruit the young. However, Caberta has repeatedly come under fire for her bias and for suspicion of corruption after it was determined she had improperly received 75,000 dollars from anti-Scientology interests. These legal proceedings against Caberta were dropped upon her payment of a 7,500 euro fine.
Germany considers Scientology to be a commercial organization and a form of political extremism that poses a threat to its democracy and constitution, themselves the basis of human rights in Germany.
YHRI's failure to disclose its Scientology connection led to trouble with sponsors -- among them the Florida Holocaust Museum -- at a human rights march the group organized in St. Petersburg, Florida in March 2007. In another instance, the group was accused of luring unwitting high-schoolers to a forum run by Scientologists at the New South Wales State Parliament House in Sydney.
In each of the above cases the YHRI organizer responded that, while the Church of Scientology supported their group, it was a YHRI event, not a Church event and the message was human rights, not Scientology.
In 2005, administrators at a Los Angeles high school required students have their parents' permission before attending a YHRI event, after discovering the group's ties to Scientology.
Another controversy stems from the problematic nature of Scientology's relationship to human rights in Europe. The Church of Scientology's Human Rights Department is concerned with religious tolerance there, and YHRI is part of its overall campaign. YHRI, known in German as "Jugend fuer Menschenrechte," is active in both Switzerland and Germany, organizing human rights conferences for youth to promote religious tolerance. Referring to the campaign, Antje Blumenthal, a member of the German parliament, expressed concern that the good intentions of the young were being misused.
Other European governments have concerns regarding Scientology and human rights. After the 1988 suicide of a Scientologist and the subsequent conviction of several Scientologists for fraud and abuse of trust, France began to monitor Scientology as a sect. A French human rights commission submitted to the Assemblee nationale in December 2006 a report including testimony of abuses on Scientology's part that harmed the physical and mental health of children.
Scientology sees the stance of these countries as discrimination, and is presently conducting a campaign through the Church of Scientology International European Office for Public Affairs and Human Rights, and with the help of YHRI, in Europe. In Brussels last year, Julie Barreau, a reporter for Le Soir magazine, recorded the speaker of a Scientology meeting as saying: "We must take control of Belgium. Their intentions are the same as the Nazis. We have to educate the forces of the fourth Reich about human rights."
See also
References
- (n.d.) About YHRI
- (n.d.) About Mary Shuttleworth
- (n.d.)Mary Shuttleworth
- (n.d.) About United
- International Youth Delegates Spark Human Rights Initiative at David Starr Jordan High School, Church of Scientology International, Human Rights News, October 7, 2005
- Youth For Human Rights International - Ghana Human Rights Tour, Church of Scientology International, Human Rights News Forum, June 3, 2006
- (n.d.)About Tim Bowles
- [http://www.prweb.com/releases/2006/1/prweb336245.htm Pepsi Honors Mother and Son as Everyday Freedom Heroes], Press Release, January 23, 2006
- (n.d.) About "United"
- (n.d.) Watch Ads
- http://www.theta.com/human-rights-education/20070314_hre_1.php
- St. Louis Post-Dispatch (Missouri), September 15, 2006, Title: Hoech sixth-grader attended U.N. human rights meeting
- The Analyst, May 31, 2006, Title: YHRI Holds Aids Awareness in Paynesville,
- Cornish Guardian, September 1, 2005, Title: Cornwall plays host to human rights festival
- Czech News Agency CTK, December 9, 2006, SCHEDULE OF CTK GENERAL NEWS IN ENGLISH, DECEMBER 10,
- New Vision, June 14, 2006, Title: Mande Wins Rights Award
- ^ Thomas Klatt (2007-01-09). "A form of political extremism". Die Welt. Retrieved 2007-04-17.
{{cite web}}: Check date values in:|date=(help); Cite has empty unknown parameter:|1=(help) - South China Morning Post, August 31, 2006, Title: Crusading for human rights
- The Jerusalem Post, June 23, 2006, Friday, Title: Haifa boy receives European Human Rights Award. Scientology-linked group rewards Scientologist's project,
- Hindustan Times, March 8, 2006, Title: Human rights is everyone's business,
- Public Agenda, May 29, 2006, Title: Human Rights Education Ventures to Be Established in Schools,
- Accra Mail (Ghana) - AAGM, November 6, 2006 Monday, Title: INCULCATE HUMAN RIGHTS EDUCATION INTO SCHOOL CURRICULUM
- The Analyst, June 7, 2006, Title: Youth Activist Suggests Edu Rights Ventures,
- Africa News, December 7, 2005, Title: Liberia; Take a Fresh Look At Liberia, Says Journalist, Activist
- The Monitor, February 27, 2007, Title: Youth Want Govt to Abolish School Fees,
- Africa News, March 21, 2007, Title: Human Rights Group Organises Peace Rally
- BuaNews, February 7, 2007, Title: Youth Group Urges South Africans to Celebrate Human Rights Month,
- SUNDAY HERALD SUN, January 1, 2006, Title: Tom and Katie's gift of rights,
- YHRI Collaborateurs]
- http://www.gerryarmstrong.org/50grand/cult/weber-ltr-2003-03-11.html
- "German Embassy statement on Scientology".
- "Baden-Wuerttemberg Office for the Protection of the Constitution, Scientology".
- Meg Laughlin (2007-04-07). "Tie to rights march wasn't revealed". St. Petersburg Times. Retrieved 2007-04-14.
{{cite web}}: Check date values in:|date=(help); Unknown parameter|coauthors=ignored (|author=suggested) (help) - Patty, Anna (2007-03-27). "Unwitting high-schoolers lured to forum run by Scientologists". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 2007-03-28.
{{cite news}}: Check date values in:|date=(help) - "Scientology group sponsors school event". UPI Newstrack. 2005-10-01.
{{cite news}}: Check date values in:|date=(help) - CoS Human Rights web site: Actions for Human Rights in Washington, D.C. http://www.scientology.org/humanrights/photo/washington-dc/index.htm
- Stamm, Hugo. "Scientologists tempt the young". Tages Anzeiger.
- Ibid.
- Barry James (1996-10-02). "Scientology Is Fighting For Its Future in France". The International Herald Tribune. Retrieved 2007-04-28.
- Craig Whitney (1996-11-23). "French Scientologist Sentenced After Church Member's Suicide". The New York Times. Retrieved 2007-04-28.
- Fenech, Georges (2006). "Investigative commission on the influence of sects and the consequences of their practices on the mental and physical health of children" (PDF). Retrieved 2007-04-16.
{{cite news}}: Unknown parameter|coauthors=ignored (|author=suggested) (help) - Curtis Krueger (1991-11-10). "SCIENTOLOGY'S CHILDREN". The St. Petersburg (Florida) Times.
- CoS HR Dept: Documenting and Exposing Government Discrimination http://www.scientology.org/humanrights/photo/government-discrimination/index.htm
- Church of Scientology International European Office for Public Affairs and Human Rights, News http://www.scientology-europe.org/
- Barreau, Julie (2006-05-17). "Scientology takes aim at Brussels". Le Soir Magazine. Retrieved 2007-04-16.
{{cite web}}: Check date values in:|date=(help)
External links
- Youth For Human Rights - Official website
- ScientologyToday.org: Youth For Human Rights
- Mary Shuttleworth nee Untiedt's statement of faith
- Lynsey Bartilson's official home page
- The International Foundation for Human Rights and Tolerance