Misplaced Pages

Victim blaming: Difference between revisions

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
Browse history interactively← Previous editNext edit →Content deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 23:24, 28 April 2013 editAnomieBOT (talk | contribs)Bots6,557,818 editsm Dating maintenance tags: {{Fact}}← Previous edit Revision as of 13:46, 6 May 2013 edit undoMy very best wishes (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users56,376 edits rv - providing notable examples is perfectly appropriateNext edit →
Line 23: Line 23:
James Martin Harding (1997) , p.143 quotation: {{quotation|The mechanisms of this ideological affinity between Baraka and Wagner can be seen in a short critique of Wagner that Adorno wrote directly after the Second World War—at a time when Adorno was perhaps his most direct in singling out the proto-fascist tendencies in Wagner's corpus and character. Adorno criticizes Wagner's having bated his conductor Herman Levi so that he would seem to bear the responsibility for Wagner's subsequent insulting dismissal of him. This, for Adorno, is a classic example of blaming the victim. The anti-Semitic sub-text to the dismissal, viz., that as a Jew Levi supposedly desired and brought the dismissal upon himself, "bears witness to the existence of one of the most sinister features of the Fascist character even in Wagner's time: the paranoid tendency of projecting upon others one's own violent aggressiveness and then indicting, on the basis of this projection, those whom one endows with pernicious qualities" (Adorno "Wagner, Nietzsche and Hitler" 158).}} James Martin Harding (1997) , p.143 quotation: {{quotation|The mechanisms of this ideological affinity between Baraka and Wagner can be seen in a short critique of Wagner that Adorno wrote directly after the Second World War—at a time when Adorno was perhaps his most direct in singling out the proto-fascist tendencies in Wagner's corpus and character. Adorno criticizes Wagner's having bated his conductor Herman Levi so that he would seem to bear the responsibility for Wagner's subsequent insulting dismissal of him. This, for Adorno, is a classic example of blaming the victim. The anti-Semitic sub-text to the dismissal, viz., that as a Jew Levi supposedly desired and brought the dismissal upon himself, "bears witness to the existence of one of the most sinister features of the Fascist character even in Wagner's time: the paranoid tendency of projecting upon others one's own violent aggressiveness and then indicting, on the basis of this projection, those whom one endows with pernicious qualities" (Adorno "Wagner, Nietzsche and Hitler" 158).}}
</ref> </ref>
Shortly after Adorno and others at the Berkley research group formulated their influential and highly debated '']'' (F for fascist), published in '']'' (1950), which included among the ] traits of the scale the "contempt for everything discriminated against or weak."<ref> By Espen Hammer p.63</ref> After Adorno, also other authors, like professor ], have described victim blaming as a characteristic fascist trait.<ref>Kriss Ravetto (2001) '''' (Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press, 2001), ISBN 13: 978-0-8166-3743-0{{Page needed|date=July 2011}}</ref> A typical infamous expression of victim blaming is the "asking for it" idiom, used in phrases like "a raped woman in a short skirt was asking for it."{{fact|date=April 2013}} Shortly after Adorno and others at the Berkley research group formulated their influential and highly debated '']'' (F for fascist), published in '']'' (1950), which included among the ] traits of the scale the "contempt for everything discriminated against or weak."<ref> By Espen Hammer p.63</ref> After Adorno, also other authors, like professor ], have described victim blaming as a characteristic fascist trait.<ref>Kriss Ravetto (2001) '''' (Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press, 2001), ISBN 13: 978-0-8166-3743-0{{Page needed|date=July 2011}}</ref> A typical infamous expression of victim blaming is the "asking for it" idiom, used in phrases like "a raped woman in a short skirt was asking for it."{{fact}}


===Opposing views=== ===Opposing views===
], a social and personality psychologist, argued that blaming the victim is not necessarily fallacious.<ref>{{cite book|last=Baumeister|first=Roy|title=Evil: Inside Human Violence and Cruelty|year=1999|publisher=Holt|isbn=0-8050-7165-2}}{{Page needed|date=July 2011}}</ref> He argued that showing the victim's responsibility can be insightful contrary to typical explanations of violence and cruelty, which incorporate the trope of the innocent victim. According to Baumeister, in the classic telling of "the myth of pure evil," the innocent, well-meaning victims are going about their business when they are suddenly assaulted by wicked, malicious evildoers. In actuality, the situation is more complicated and it is mostly—though not always—the case that the victim has done something to either provoke the ire of the offender or to aid their actions, although the subsequent actions may outweigh the scale of the "victim's" initial offense. ], a social and personality psychologist, argued that blaming the victim is not necessarily fallacious.<ref>{{cite book|last=Baumeister|first=Roy|title=Evil: Inside Human Violence and Cruelty|year=1999|publisher=Holt|isbn=0-8050-7165-2}}{{Page needed|date=July 2011}}</ref> He argued that showing the victim's responsibility can be insightful contrary to typical explanations of violence and cruelty, which incorporate the trope of the innocent victim. According to Baumeister, in the classic telling of "the myth of pure evil," the innocent, well-meaning victims are going about their business when they are suddenly assaulted by wicked, malicious evildoers. In actuality, the situation is more complicated and it is mostly—though not always—the case that the victim has done something to either provoke the ire of the offender or to aid their actions, although the subsequent actions may outweigh the scale of the "victim's" initial offense.

==Notable instances==
In 2005, Australian Muslim preacher ] gave a speech in Australia that was covered in Europe and the U.S. in which he blamed women themselves for being rape victims.<ref>{{cite magazine|url=http://www.forbes.com/sites/realspin/2013/04/23/theres-nothing-homegrown-about-the-boston-terror-attacks/ |author= |title=There's Nothing 'Homegrown' About The Boston Terror Attacks |publisher=Forbes |date=18 April 2012 |accessdate=28 April 2013}}</ref><ref>{{cite news|url=http://www.smh.com.au/news/opinion/muslim-rage-burns-in-our-backyard/2005/07/20/1121539032464.html |author= |title=Muslim rage burns in our backyard |publisher=The Sydney Morning Herald |date=21 July 2005 |accessdate=23 April 2013}}</ref><ref name="theaustralian1">{{cite news|url=http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/breaking-news/aussie-cleric-feiz-mohammad-calls-for-beheading-of-dutch-mp-geert-wilders/story-fn3dxity-1225914033334 |title=Aussie cleric Feiz Mohammad calls for beheading of Dutch MP Geert Wilders |publisher=The Australian |date= 3 September 2010|accessdate=22 April 2013}}</ref><ref name="autogenerated4">{{cite news|url=http://www.sify.com/news/oz-muslim-leaders-criticise-islamic-cleric-s-call-for-beheading-dutch-politician-news-others-kjgp4gfddgg.html |author= |title=Oz Muslim leaders criticise Islamic cleric's 'call for beheading' Dutch politician |publisher=Sify.com |date=6 September 2010 |accessdate=22 April 2013}}</ref> He said: "A victim of rape every minute somewhere in the world. Why? No one to blame but herself. She displayed her beauty to the entire world... Strapless, backless, sleeveless, showing their legs, nothing but satanic skirts, slit skirts, translucent blouses, miniskirts, tight jeans: all this to tease man and appeal to his carnal nature.<ref name=women>, by Miranda Devine, ''The Sydney Morning Herald'', 24 April 2005.</ref><ref>{{cite news|url=http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2006/10/28/1161749357803.html |title=How a vile sermon of ignorance has done Australia a big favour |author=Miranda Devine |publisher=The Sydney Morning Herald |date= |accessdate=23 April 2013}}</ref>

In a case that became famous in 2011, an 11-year-old rape victim who suffered repeated gang rapes in Cleveland, Texas, was accused by the defense attorney of being a seductress who lured men to their doom.<ref name="slate1">{{cite news|last=Adams |first=Sam |url=http://www.slate.com/blogs/xx_factor/2012/11/29/cleveland_texas_rape_case_defense_attorney_calls_pre_teen_victim_a_spider.html |title=Cleveland, Texas rape case: Defense attorney calls pre-teen victim a spider, but that's his job |publisher=Slate |date=29 November 2012 |accessdate=28 April 2013}}</ref> "Like the spider and the fly. Wasn't she saying, 'Come into my parlor, said the spider to the fly?' ", he asked a witness.<ref name="slate1"/> The ''New York Times'' ran an article uncritically reporting on the way many in the community blamed the victim, for which the newspaper later apologized.<ref name="slate1"/><ref>{{cite news|url=http://www.mediabistro.com/fishbowlla/ny-times-defends-victim-blaming-coverage-of-child-rape-case_b24236 |author= |title=NY Times Defends Victim Blaming Coverage of Child Rape Case |publisher=Mediabistro.com |date=10 March 2011 |accessdate=28 April 2013}}</ref><ref>{{cite news|url=http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/03/10/new-york-times-texas-rape_n_834147.html |author= |title=New York Times Texas Rape Story Draws Fire |publisher=Huffingtonpost.com |date=10 March 2011 |accessdate=28 April 2013}}</ref>

In a case that attracted worldwide coverage, when a woman was raped and killed in India in December 2012, Indian government officials and political leaders blamed the victim for her outfit and being out late at night.<ref>{{cite web|last=Darby |first=Brandon |url=http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Peace/2013/01/06/Indian-Leaders-Call-Dead-Rape-Victim-a-Whore-Among-Other-Cruel-Statements |title=Indian Leaders Blame Deceased Rape Victim, Western Culture for Attack |publisher=Breitbart.com |date=7 January 2013 |accessdate=28 April 2013}}</ref><ref>{{cite news|url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/worldviews/wp/2013/01/04/amid-rape-fiasco-indias-leaders-keep-up-insensitive-remarks/ |author= |title=Amid rape fiasco, India’s leaders keep up insensitive remarks |publisher=Washington Post |date=4 January 2013 |accessdate=28 April 2013}}</ref>


==Secondary victimization== ==Secondary victimization==

Revision as of 13:46, 6 May 2013

For the book entitled "Blaming the Victims", see Blaming the Victims.

Victim blaming occurs when the victim(s) of a crime, an accident, or any type of abusive maltreatment are held entirely or partially responsible for the transgressions committed against them (regardless of whether the victim actually had any responsibility for the incident). Blaming the victim has traditionally emerged especially in racist, sexist, and classist forms. However, this attitude may exist independently from these views and even be at least half-official in some countries.

People familiar with victimology are much less likely to see the victim as responsible. Knowledge about a prior relationship between victim and perpetrator increases perceptions of victim blame for rape, but not for robbery.

Coining of the phrase; Racism

William Ryan coined the phrase "blaming the victim" in his 1971 book Blaming the Victim. In the book, Ryan described victim blaming as an ideology used to justify racism and social injustice against black people in the United States. Ryan wrote the book to refute Daniel Patrick Moynihan's 1965 work The Negro Family: The Case for National Action (usually simply referred to as the Moynihan Report).

Moynihan had concluded that three centuries of horrible treatment at the hands of whites, and in particular the uniquely cruel structure of American slavery as opposed to its Latin American counterparts, had created a long series of chaotic disruptions within the black family structure which, at the time of the report, manifested itself in high rates of unwed births, absent fathers, and single mother households in black families. Moynihan then correlated these familial outcomes, which he considered undesirable, to the relatively poorer rates of employment, educational achievement, and financial success found among the black population. Moynihan advocated the implementation of government programs designed to strengthen the black nuclear family.

Ryan objected that Moynihan then located the proximate cause of the plight of black Americans in the prevalence of a family structure in which the father was often sporadically, if at all, present, and the mother was often dependent on government aid to feed, clothe, and provide medical care for her children. Ryan's critique cast the Moynihan theories as attempts to divert responsibility for poverty from social structural factors to the behaviors and cultural patterns of the poor. Ryan's book was described as "a devastating critique of the mindset that causes us to blame the poor for their poverty and the powerless for their powerlessness".

The phrase "blaming the victim" was quickly adopted by advocates for crime victims, in particular rape victims accused of abetting their victimization (see Victimology), although this usage is conceptually distinct from the sociological critique developed by Ryan.

History

Although Ryan popularized the phrase, the phenomenon of victim blaming is well established in human psychology and history; for instance there are plenty of examples in the Christian and Ebraic Old Testament, in which tragedies and catastrophes are justified and blamed on the victims for their faults as sinners.

During the New Culture Movement, Chinese writer Lu Xun made the famous saying 可憐之人必有可恨之處 (A pitiful person must have one's abominable qualities), which was considered as victim blaming.

In 1947 Theodor W. Adorno defined what would be later called "blaming the victim," as "one of the most sinister features of the Fascist character". Shortly after Adorno and others at the Berkley research group formulated their influential and highly debated F-scale (F for fascist), published in The Authoritarian Personality (1950), which included among the fascist traits of the scale the "contempt for everything discriminated against or weak." After Adorno, also other authors, like professor Kriss Ravetto, have described victim blaming as a characteristic fascist trait. A typical infamous expression of victim blaming is the "asking for it" idiom, used in phrases like "a raped woman in a short skirt was asking for it."

Opposing views

Roy Baumeister, a social and personality psychologist, argued that blaming the victim is not necessarily fallacious. He argued that showing the victim's responsibility can be insightful contrary to typical explanations of violence and cruelty, which incorporate the trope of the innocent victim. According to Baumeister, in the classic telling of "the myth of pure evil," the innocent, well-meaning victims are going about their business when they are suddenly assaulted by wicked, malicious evildoers. In actuality, the situation is more complicated and it is mostly—though not always—the case that the victim has done something to either provoke the ire of the offender or to aid their actions, although the subsequent actions may outweigh the scale of the "victim's" initial offense.

Notable instances

In 2005, Australian Muslim preacher Feiz Mohammad gave a speech in Australia that was covered in Europe and the U.S. in which he blamed women themselves for being rape victims. He said: "A victim of rape every minute somewhere in the world. Why? No one to blame but herself. She displayed her beauty to the entire world... Strapless, backless, sleeveless, showing their legs, nothing but satanic skirts, slit skirts, translucent blouses, miniskirts, tight jeans: all this to tease man and appeal to his carnal nature.

In a case that became famous in 2011, an 11-year-old rape victim who suffered repeated gang rapes in Cleveland, Texas, was accused by the defense attorney of being a seductress who lured men to their doom. "Like the spider and the fly. Wasn't she saying, 'Come into my parlor, said the spider to the fly?' ", he asked a witness. The New York Times ran an article uncritically reporting on the way many in the community blamed the victim, for which the newspaper later apologized.

In a case that attracted worldwide coverage, when a woman was raped and killed in India in December 2012, Indian government officials and political leaders blamed the victim for her outfit and being out late at night.

Secondary victimization

A rape victim is especially stigmatized in cultures with strong customs and taboos regarding sex and sexuality. For example, society may view a rape victim (especially one who was previously a virgin) as "damaged". Victims in these cultures may suffer isolation, be disowned by friends and family, be prohibited from marrying, be divorced if already married, or even killed. This phenomenon is known as secondary victimization.

Secondary victimization is the re-traumatization of the sexual assault, abuse, or rape victim through the responses of individuals and institutions. Types of secondary victimization include victim blaming and inappropriate post-assault behavior or language by medical personnel or other organizations with which the victim has contact. Secondary victimization is especially common in cases of drug-facilitated, acquaintance, military sexual trauma and statutory rape.

Rape shield laws

Main article: Rape shield law

In the United States and Canada, rape is unique in that it is the only crime in which there are statutory protections designed in favor of the accuser. These were enacted in response to the common defense tactic of "putting the accuser on trial". Typical rape shield laws prohibit cross-examination of the accuser (alleged victim) with respect to certain issues, such as her or his prior sexual history, or the manner in which she or he was dressed at the time of the rape. Most states and the federal rules, however, provide exceptions to the rape shield law where evidence of prior sexual history is used to provide an alternative explanation for physical evidence, where the defendant and the alleged victim had a prior consensual sexual relationship, and where exclusion of evidence would violate the defendant's constitutional rights.

Just-world hypothesis

Main article: Just-world hypothesis

The just world hypothesis describes the phenomenon that people believe that the world is one in which actions have appropriate and predictable consequences. This phenomenon has been widely studied by social psychologists since Melvin J. Lerner conducted seminal work on the belief in a just world in the early 1960s.

Much psychological research on this has focused on victim blaming and derogation.

Family honour and sexual purity

Another factor involving social relationships is a family response to sexual violence that blames women without punishing men, concentrating instead on restoring lost family honor. Such a response creates an environment in which rape can occur with impunity.

While families will often try to protect their women from rape and may also put their daughters on contraception to prevent visible signs should it occur, there is rarely much social pressure to control young men or persuade them that coercing sex is wrong. Instead, in some countries, there is frequently support for family members to do whatever is necessary including murder to alleviate the shame associated with a rape or other sexual transgression. In cases where the victim was a single pregnant female, the offender was either acquitted of murder or received a reduced sentence.

See also

3

Notes

  1. Gregory Meyerson and Michael Joseph Roberto Fascism and the Crisis of Pax Americana
  2. Mony, Prem; Sankar, Kiruba; Thomas, Tinku; Vaz, Mario (2011). "Strengthening of local vital events registration: lessons learnt from a voluntary sector initiative in a district in southern India". Bulletin of the World Health Organization. 89 (5): 379–84. doi:10.2471/BLT.10.083972. PMC 3089385. PMID 21556306.
  3. Fox, K. A.; Cook, C. L. (2011). "Is Knowledge Power? The Effects of a Victimology Course on Victim Blaming". Journal of Interpersonal Violence. doi:10.1177/0886260511403752.
  4. Bieneck, S.; Krahe, B. (2010). "Blaming the Victim and Exonerating the Perpetrator in Cases of Rape and Robbery: Is There a Double Standard?". Journal of Interpersonal Violence. 26 (9): 1785–97. doi:10.1177/0886260510372945. PMID 20587449.
  5. ISBN 9780394417264
  6. Cole (2007) pp.111, 149, 213
  7. Downs (1998) p. 24
  8. ^ Kirkpatrick (1987) p. 219
  9. Kent (2003)
  10. Illinois state U. archives.
  11. Ryan, William (1976). Blaming the Victim. Vintage. ISBN 0-394-72226-4.
  12. Blaming the Victim. "publisher's description". Amazon.com. Retrieved 27 August 2012.
  13. ^ Robinson (2002) p.141
  14. Adorno, TW (1947) Wagner, Nietzsche and Hitler in Kenyan Review Vol.ix (1), p. 158
  15. James Martin Harding (1997) Adorno and "A writing of the ruins": essays on modern aesthetics and Anglo-American literature and culture, p.143 quotation:

    The mechanisms of this ideological affinity between Baraka and Wagner can be seen in a short critique of Wagner that Adorno wrote directly after the Second World War—at a time when Adorno was perhaps his most direct in singling out the proto-fascist tendencies in Wagner's corpus and character. Adorno criticizes Wagner's having bated his conductor Herman Levi so that he would seem to bear the responsibility for Wagner's subsequent insulting dismissal of him. This, for Adorno, is a classic example of blaming the victim. The anti-Semitic sub-text to the dismissal, viz., that as a Jew Levi supposedly desired and brought the dismissal upon himself, "bears witness to the existence of one of the most sinister features of the Fascist character even in Wagner's time: the paranoid tendency of projecting upon others one's own violent aggressiveness and then indicting, on the basis of this projection, those whom one endows with pernicious qualities" (Adorno "Wagner, Nietzsche and Hitler" 158).

  16. Adorno and the political By Espen Hammer p.63
  17. Kriss Ravetto (2001) The unmaking of fascist aesthetics (Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press, 2001), ISBN 13: 978-0-8166-3743-0
  18. Baumeister, Roy (1999). Evil: Inside Human Violence and Cruelty. Holt. ISBN 0-8050-7165-2.
  19. "There's Nothing 'Homegrown' About The Boston Terror Attacks". Forbes. 18 April 2012. Retrieved 28 April 2013. {{cite magazine}}: Cite magazine requires |magazine= (help)
  20. "Muslim rage burns in our backyard". The Sydney Morning Herald. 21 July 2005. Retrieved 23 April 2013.
  21. "Aussie cleric Feiz Mohammad calls for beheading of Dutch MP Geert Wilders". The Australian. 3 September 2010. Retrieved 22 April 2013.
  22. "Oz Muslim leaders criticise Islamic cleric's 'call for beheading' Dutch politician". Sify.com. 6 September 2010. Retrieved 22 April 2013.
  23. "Muslim cleric: women incite men's lust with 'satanic dress'", by Miranda Devine, The Sydney Morning Herald, 24 April 2005.
  24. Miranda Devine. "How a vile sermon of ignorance has done Australia a big favour". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 23 April 2013.
  25. ^ Adams, Sam (29 November 2012). "Cleveland, Texas rape case: Defense attorney calls pre-teen victim a spider, but that's his job". Slate. Retrieved 28 April 2013.
  26. "NY Times Defends Victim Blaming Coverage of Child Rape Case". Mediabistro.com. 10 March 2011. Retrieved 28 April 2013.
  27. "New York Times Texas Rape Story Draws Fire". Huffingtonpost.com. 10 March 2011. Retrieved 28 April 2013.
  28. Darby, Brandon (7 January 2013). "Indian Leaders Blame Deceased Rape Victim, Western Culture for Attack". Breitbart.com. Retrieved 28 April 2013.
  29. "Amid rape fiasco, India's leaders keep up insensitive remarks". Washington Post. 4 January 2013. Retrieved 28 April 2013.
  30. "Factsheets: Trauma of Victimization – Secondary Injuries". Svfreenyc.org. 21 August 2012. Retrieved 27 August 2012.
  31. Attention: This template ({{cite pmid}}) is deprecated. To cite the publication identified by PMID 10606433, please use {{cite journal}} with |pmid=10606433 instead.
  32. Lerner, M.J. & Montada, L. (1998). An Overview: Advances in Belief in a Just World Theory and Methods, in Leo Montada & M.J. Lerner (Eds.). Responses to Victimizations and Belief in a Just World (1–7). Plenum Press: New York.
  33. Wood K, Maepa J, Jewkes R. Adolescent sex and contraceptive experiences: perspectives of teenagers and clinic nurses in the Northern Province. Pretoria, Medical Research Council, 1997 (Technical Report).
  34. Hadidi M, Kulwicki A, Jahshan H (2001). "A review of 16 cases of honour killings in Jordan in 1995". International Journal of Legal Medicine. 114 (6): 357–359. doi:10.1007/s004140000166. PMID 11508804.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)

References

Further reading

  • Janoffbulman, R (1985). "Cognitive biases in blaming the victim". Journal of Experimental Social Psychology. 21 (2): 161–177. doi:10.1016/0022-1031(85)90013-7.
  • Maes, JüRgen (1994). "Blaming the victim: Belief in control or belief in justice?". Social Justice Research. 7: 69–90. doi:10.1007/BF02333823.
  • McCaul, Kevin D.; Veltum, Lois G.; Boyechko, Vivian; Crawford, Jacqueline J. (1990). "Understanding Attributions of Victim Blame for Rape: Sex, Violence, and Foreseeability1". Journal of Applied Social Psychology. 20: 1–26. doi:10.1111/j.1559-1816.1990.tb00375.x.
  • Summers, Gertrude; Feldman, Nina S. (1984). "Blaming the Victim Versus Blaming the Perpetrator: An Attributional Analysis of Spouse Abuse". Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology. 2 (4): 339–47. doi:10.1521/jscp.1984.2.4.339.

External links

Manipulation (psychology)
Positive manipulation
Negative manipulation
Other manipulation
Related manipulation topics
Sexual abuse
Forms
Sociological
theories
Laws
Related topics
Abuse
Types
Related topics
Bullying
Types
Elements
Organizations
Experts
Academics
Activists
Actions
Notable suicides
(List)
Murder–suicides
(incidents)
Related topics
Categories: