Misplaced Pages

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Lobbuss (talk | contribs) at 22:32, 27 August 2007 (ask any Brisker if the Brisker Rov said to vote! This is just slander!). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

The relationship between Haredim and Zionism has always been a difficult one. Even before the establishment of the State of Israel, the majority of Haredi Jewry was opposed to Zionism. However, after the de facto creation of the state, each individual movement within Orthodox Judaism charted its own path in their approach to the State of Israel.

History

Ashkenazic religious Jews, both Chasidim and Perushim, started to immigrate to Erets Yisroel in the 18th century, long before the founding of the Zionist movement, and continued to do so in the 19th century. Karliner chasidim had an early foothold, and the Lelover Rebbe settled there in 1850. Tsanz established itself in Tsfas in the 1870s, and Ruzhin had a major presence in Yerusholayim (Jerusalem) at about the same time. During the 19th century there was a vibrant Haredi community in yerushalayim. In 1925 the Imrei Emes of Ger established the Yeshivas Sfas Emes in Yerusholayim.

The advent of secular Zionism, whose goal was to transplant Jews to the Land of Israel in a society devoid of Torah values, was the antithesis of the aims of Jews who were already established there.

After 1918, immigration was controlled by the by the British, who had been given a mandate over Palestine by the League of Nations. They restricted immigration of Jews, and operated a quota by means of certificates. The distribution of these certificates was in the hands of the Jewish Agency for Palestine, a Zionist organization. The allocation of certificates to Haredi Jews was severely restricted so as not to compromise the goal of a secular state.

After World War II

After World War II many Jewish refugees found themeselves in displaced person camps. The Zionists controlled a camp for Jewish refugee children in Tehran where they operated an anti-religious policy in an effort to cut off Haredi children from their spiritual roots. To a large extent they were successful, and many children from Haredi homes were dispatched to irreligious settlements.

Post-1948

Rabbi Joel Teitelbaum, the first Satmar Rebbe, in his book "VaYoel Moshe," calls the creation of the Israeli state an "act of Satan", blames Zionism for the Holocaust and calls it the greatest form of spiritual impurity in the entire world. Some Orthodox, and some Hasidic groups, have either adopted his approach, or do not oppose it. However, the Satmar approach is one of Hareidi Judaism's approaches.

The Agudat Israel which represents many groups, including most of the Lithuanian Haredi world and major Hasidic groups such as Ger and Belz, has adopted a stance of passive support for the State of Israel, motivated by pragmatism. They attempt to change the secular character of the State of Israel from within, by participating in national elections and sending their representatives to the Israeli parliament, the Knesset.

The Lubavitcher Rebbe Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson went even so far as to say that negotiating land-for-peace is a violation of Jewish Law - this, however, without accepting the ideology of Zionism, which is still perceived within Chabad-Lubavitch as a wrong ideology.

There is also a growing group of Orthodox Jews known as Hardalim. They are formerly Modern Orthodox Religious Zionists who moved towards Haredi Judaism in their observance of Jewish law. Socially, however, they form a part of the Religious Zionist world and not of the Haredi world.

Background

The Talmud, in Ketubot 111a, mentions that the Jewish people have been bound by three oaths: 1) not to ascend to Eretz Yisrael (the Land of Israel) as a group using force; 2) not to rebel against the nations of the world; and 3) not to delay the coming of Moshiach, the Jewish messiah, through their own sins. Many consider the establishment of the state of Israel to be a violation of these oaths.

This passage of the Talmud is based on a mystical meaning of the verse "I adjure you, O daughters of Jerusalem, by the gazelles or by the hinds of the field, that you neither awaken nor arouse the love while it is desirous." This verse is found thrice in Shir HaShirim, (Song of Songs), verses 2:7, 3:5, 8:4.

In Poland and Hungary in 1920s, most Haredi Jewish movements, including almost the entire Hasidic world, were opposed to Zionism. In some cases this opposition was only mild and passive; in other cases it was very strong. The strongest forms of anti-Zionism originated in Hungary, where in 1920 a group of twelve leading rabbis condemned Zionism in very strong words. It was followed by a similar declaration in 1925. These movements opposed the establishment of a State, but were largely not opposed to moving to and living in the physical boundaries of the area known to Jews as Eretz Yisroel, the 'Land of Israel.'

Hasidic movements opposing Zionism strongly are, amongst others, Satmar, Bobov, Munkacz, Vizhnitz, Toldos Aharon, Dushinsky, Pshevorsk, Tosh and many others.

Amongst the Orthodox rabbinical leadership, religious Zionists form a minority.

Different Haredi groups on the issue of Zionism

Groups which are generally opposed to the State of Israel

Lithuanian ('Litvish') Haredi Judaism

A number of Lithuanian leaders like the Chazon Ish (1878-1953), Rav Shach (1898-2001), and Rabbi Yosef Sholom Eliashiv, have expressed strongly anti-Zionist views. Examples of this are found in lectures and letters of Rav Shach. The main newspaper of the Litvish world, the Yated Neeman, regularly publishes articles strongly criticizing Zionism, naming it a 'heretical movement'. The main Litvish community does, however, vote. Rabbi Yosef Sholom Eliashiv urges his students to vote for the Degel HaTorah list. Rabbi Shimshon Dovid Pincus, quoted in the book of his speeches about Purim, explains that in each generation the Yetzer Hara (evil inclination) appears in different forms. Examples he gives are the Enlightenment and communism. He goes on to explain that nowadays Zionism is a form of the Yetzer Hara.

Satmar

The Satmar Hasidic movement, whose previous Rebbe, Rabbi Joel Teitelbaum wrote in the 1960s an extensive critique of Zionism entitled Vayoel Moshe (see Sefer Vayoel Moshe below), counts more than 100,000 members. This does not include a number of smaller and related anti-Zionist Hungarian Hasidic groups who align themselves with Satmar.

Historically, Satmar has played a major role in Jerusalem's Edah HaChareidis rabbinical council; the last two Satmar Rebbes, Rabbi Joel Teitelbaum and Rabbi Moshe Teitelbaum, succeeded each other as its President, with Rabbi Joel serving from 1953 until his death in 1979, and his nephew and successor Rabbi Moshe leading it from 1979 until his death in 2006. All movements affiliated with the Edah accept Rabbi Joel Teitelbaum's Vayoel Moshe as binding.

Satmar and Neturei Karta are often confused by people not aware of the difference between these movements. While certain elements of Neturei Karta actively cooperate with Arab and Islamic movements calling for the destruction of Israel, Satmar Hasidim have never done this, as per opposition of their leaders.

Central Rabbinical Congress (CRC)

The Central Rabbinical Congress or CRC is an American rabbinical organization which consists mainly of Satmar and some smaller but similar Hasidic groups. It is centered in New York's Kiryas Joel, Williamsburg, and Boro Park. In 1986 the CRC publicized the following declaration:

It is our duty to denounce those who invoke the name of the Almighty in vain. It is our holy obligation and our moral responsibility to call on them: Stop using these falsehoods and heresies to justify yourselves and your misdeeds. The Jewish faith, as transmitted by the Almighty to our forefathers has not and will never countenance the zionist and nationalistic doctrines of the state of Israel. These false doctrines are compounded of atheism and anti-religious zionism, ideologies alien to Judaism. Let them not be misrepresented to the world as Jewish.

Dushinsky

In July 1947, less than a year before the actual founding of the state, Rabbi Yosef Tzvi Dushinsky, who was both the leader of the Dushinsky movement and the Ashkenazi Haredi Chief Rabbi of Jerusalem, of the Edah HaChareidis rabbinical council, delivered a personal statement on behalf of the Edah HaChareidis to the United Nations, declaring his "definite opposition to a Jewish state in any part of Palestine." In 2002, Grand Rabbi Yisroel Moshe Dushinsky, son of Rabbi Yosef Tzvi, wrote a praising letter of recommendation to a new edition of the Satmar Rebbe's book Vayoel Moshe.

Edah HaChareidis

The Edah HaChareidis is Jerusalem's council of anti-Zionist Haredim. In 1947, Chief Rabbis Yosef Tzvi Dushinsky and Zelig Reuven Bengis delivered a statement to the United Nations in which they declared their opposition to a Jewish state, fearing that "a Jewish state would be a rallying point for anti-Semitism and thus an actual danger to the Jewish people." Since then, the Edah has developed itself as the largest mainstream anti-Zionist body. It includes groups such as the Jerusalem branch of Satmar and Dushinsky. The rebbes of both of these movements have at times been the Chief Rabbis and Presidents of the Edah.

Neturei Karta

A small ad hoc group holding this ideology is Neturei Karta, with bases mainly in Jerusalem, Beit Shemesh and New York. An extreme faction of Neturei Karta which openly display support for Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmedinejad and the Palestine Liberation Organization as well as Hamas has been condemned by nearly all other anti-Zionist Haredim, including Satmar and the Edah HaChareidis.

Groups which are generally supportive of the State of Israel

Ger and Belz Hasidim

The Ger and Belz Hasidic movements have adopted a pragmatic stance of co-existence with the State of Israel. While both movements have a history of anti-Zionism before the establishment of the State just like that of all other Hasidic movements, their positions are comparatively mild. While they do not say prayers for the State of Israel, they do vote, and Ger mildly opposes withdrawals from the occupied territories. Ger and Belz are two of the most influential movements behind the Israeli political party Agudat Yisrael, which together with the Litvishe Degel HaTorah forms United Torah Judaism.

Chabad-Lubavitch

The previous generations of Chabad-Lubavitch leadership have been very critical of Zionism. The fifth Rebbe of Chabad, Rabbi Sholom Dovber Schneersohn wrote that "those who assist the Zionists will pay at the Day of Judgment, because they are causing the masses to sin."

However, the last Lubavitcher Rebbe expressed overwhelming support for the State's military endeavors, strongly condemning any transfers of land as against Jewish law. His reasoning, however, was not based on any theological argument. Rather, he argued that the safety of the Jewish people was paramount, and physical presence of so many Jews in one place meant that the borders of that place had to be protected. Nonetheless, he did draw support for his statements from the notion in the Torah that the land of Israel was given to the Jewish people, and that Jewish ownership of the land could not be overcome by mere political interests. Nonetheless, he refused to call the state by name, claiming that the holy land exists independent of any authority that sees itself as sovereign over the land. He further criticized feelings of nationalism connected to the State of Israel, claiming that the only thing that unites Jews is the Torah, not a secular state that happens to be planted on holy land.

Hardal

The Hardal community is a community of people who support the state of Israel. Hardal itself is an acronym for Haredi Dati Leumi. Dati Leumi refers to religious Jews who are Zionists. The Hardal community is based largely on the teachings of Rabbi Abraham Isaac Kook.

Sephardim

The vast majority of Sephardi Rabbis were supportive of Sephardim and to date no significant non-Ashkenazi Rabbi has ever had a theological problem with Zionism. As A. Torczyner, an emissary of the World Zionist Organization wrote after a visit to Tunis in 1913,” Opposition, especially of the sort we find here in Europe is non-existent. The G-d-fearing regard our movement with warmth and reverence.” Sephardi Rabbis are generally supportive of Zionism which leads some to postulate that religious anti-Zionism is psychological and social rather than theological..

Haredi books about Zionism

Several books on the issue of Zionism were written by different rabbis.

Sefer Vayoel Moshe

Vayoel Moshe was written by the Satmar Rebbe Joel Teitelbaum (1887-1979). It consists of three parts: Maamar Shalosh Shevuos (three oaths), Maamar Yishuv Eretz Yisroel (settling the Land of Israel), and Maamar Loshon HaKodesh (the holy tongue). The first part, which is the main part of the book, discusses the three oaths mentioned in Ketubot 111a - that the Jewish people are not allowed to ascend to Eretz Yisrael by force, that the Jewish people are not allowed to rebel against the nations of the world, and that the Jewish people may not by their sins delay the coming of Moshiach, the Jewish messiah. It is primarily a book of Halacha, Jewish law. In the book, Rabbi Teitelbaum refers to religious Zionism as a major desecration of G-d's name, blames Zionism for the Holocaust, and refers to Zionist leaders such as Theodor Herzl as 'heretics'.

Kuntres Al HaGeulah VeAl HaTemurah

Also written by the Satmar Rebbe, Rabbi Joel Teitelbaum, this small book consists of inspirational polemics against Zionism. He wrote it in 1967 as a rebuttal to those who said that the Six Day War was a divine miracle that showed God's support for the Zionist State, saying instead it was a test from God to see whether we would follow the Torah or be lead astray by miracles which seemed to support Zionism in the eyes of the masses. He compared this to the miracles that are often done by idolators in support of their religions, inasmuch as Judaism is not based on miracles, but rather the national revelation on Sinai.

Eim HaBanim Semeicha

Eim HaBanim Semeicha was written by Rabbi Shlomo Teichtal, and published in 1943. Teichtal grew up as a staunch anti-Zionist Chasid of the Munkatsher Rebbe. However, during the Holocaust, Rabbi Teichtal changed his position from the one he espoused in his youth. The physical product of that introspection is the book, Eim HaBanim Semeicha, in which he specifically retracts his previous viewpoints, and argues that the true redemption can only come if the Jewish people unite and rebuild the land of Israel. Many of his coreligionists viewed the book with skepticism, some going so far as to ban Rabbi Teichtal from their synagogues.

In the book, Rabbi Teichtal strongly criticizes the Haredim for not supporting the Zionist movement. When it was written, it was a scathing criticism of the Jewish Orthodox establishment, and Agudas Israel in particular.

He writes:

It is clear that he who prepares prior to the Sabbath will eat on the Sabbath (Avodah Zarah, 3a), and since the Haredim did not toil, they have absolutely no influence in the Land (of Israel). Those who toil and build have the influence, and they are the masters of the Land. It is, therefore, no wonder that they are in control... Now, what will the Haredim say? I do not know if they will ever be able to vindicate themselves before the heavenly court for not participating in the movement to rebuild the Land. (p. 23)

Involvement with the State

Among Haredi anti-Zionist movements, opinions differ on what attitude to take now that de facto a state exists. Some movements remained actively anti-Zionist, while others lowered their voice; some refuse to vote, while others do vote; some accept money from the government, while others will not.

Many Chassidic Rebbes with followers in the land of Israel, including the Gerer Rebbe, the Belzer Rebbe, the Lubavitcher Rebbe, and others have encouraged their followers to vote in Israeli elections. Lubavitcher Chassidim are encouraged to join the Israeli Defense Forces, in order to ensure the state's security (inasmuch as the State's security is inextricably entwined with the safety of the Jewish people who live within its borders).

Meanwhile the Edah HaChareidis rabbinical council of Jerusalem and its associated communities, including Satmar, Dushinsky, Toldos Aharon and Toldos Avrohom Yitzchok, do not vote and do not accept government money. Around election days, posters by the Edah HaChareidis are posted throughout Haredi neighborhoods of Jerusalem proclaiming that it is forbidden to vote in the elections, and that doing so is a grave sin. The Edah HaChareidis and its affiliated movements do recognize the authority of the Israeli police in criminal matters.

The main newspaper of the Litvish world, the Yated Neeman, regularly publishes articles strongly criticizing Zionism, naming it a 'heretical movement'. The main Litvish community does vote, as per the instructions of their leaders. The Lithuanian leadership, most notably Rabbi Yosef Sholom Eliashiv, instructs his students to vote for the Degel HaTorah list. Indeed, one Degel HaTorah representative, Rabbi Uri Lupolianski, is as of 2007 the mayor of Jerusalem.

See also

• Zionism
• Religious Zionism
• Anti-Zionism
• Neturei Karta
• Haredi Judaism
• Hasidic Judaism

References

1. Yaldei Tehran
2. Yaldei Tehran
3. Introduction to Sefer Vayoel Moshe
4. Sefer Vayoel Moshe, Maamar Sholosh Shevuos, Siman 27
5. Sefer Vayoel Moshe, Hakdamah os Hey
6. http://www.myjewishlearning.com/ideas_belief/LandIsrael/modern_landisrael/QuestioningZionism/Neturei_Karta.htm Reprinted with the permission of The Continuum International Publishing Group from The Encyclopedia of Judaism, edited by Jacob Neusner, Alan Avery-Peck, and William Scott Green.
7. Sefer Shomer Emunim by R' Aharon Roth, Sefer Asifas Michtovim, by R' Avrohom Yitzchok Kohn foundational books of the Toldos Avrohom movement, passim.
8. http://www.cjnews.com/pastissues/99/mar31-99/front2.htm
9. "Torah and Religious Zionism", by Cyril Domb, World Zionist Organization
10. Yated Ne'eman article
11. * Record Online
    • Israel National News
12. Introduction to Yalkut Amarim Vayoel Moshe by all members of the Badatz - Edah HaChareidis
13. Middle East Policy Council, Journal, Winter 1990-91, Number 35: JEWISH CRITICISM OF ZIONISM, Edward C. Corrigan
14. Introduction to Yalkut Amarim Vayoel Moshe
15. Middle East Policy Council, Journal, Winter 1990-91, Number 35: JEWISH CRITICISM OF ZIONISM, Edward C. Corrigan
16. Karasi v'Ein Onah, a compilation of all of the Lubavither Rebbe's addresses concerning the Holy Land.
18. Eim HaBanim Semeichah

• Haredi Judaism
• Zionism
• Jews and Judaism-related controversies