Misplaced Pages

Sita Ram Goel: Difference between revisions

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.
Browse history interactively← Previous editContent deleted Content addedVisualWikitext
Revision as of 16:04, 2 December 2024 editMohanpande948 (talk | contribs)3 edits wrong informationTag: Visual edit← Previous edit Latest revision as of 04:38, 5 December 2024 edit undoQuillThrills (talk | contribs)253 edits previous edit misrepresented sources. going to assume good faith that reverting user didn’t read the source articles rather than assuming POV pushing. discuss on talk page before reverting.Tags: Mobile edit Mobile app edit iOS app edit App section source 
Line 22: Line 22:
| movement = | movement =
| notableworks = ''How I Became a Hindu''<br />''The Story of Islamic Imperialism in India''<br />''History of Hindu–Christian Encounters, AD 304 to 1996''<br />'']''<br />'']'' | notableworks = ''How I Became a Hindu''<br />''The Story of Islamic Imperialism in India''<br />''History of Hindu–Christian Encounters, AD 304 to 1996''<br />'']''<br />'']''
}}'''Sita Ram Goel''' (16 October 1921 – 3 December 2003) was an Indian scholar and historian. His work has been both celebrated for and criticized for its bias towards Hindu nationalism and its controversial portrayal of other religions, particularly Islam and Christianity.<ref>{{Cite web |date=2021-10-16 |title=Sita Ram Goel: The man who exposed Nehruvian fallacies and won our hearts with his mind |url=https://www.firstpost.com/india/sita-ram-goel-the-man-who-exposed-nehruvian-fallacies-and-won-our-hearts-with-his-mind-10060681.html |access-date=2023-10-02 |website=Firstpost |language=en}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web |title=For the RSS, Denouncing and Appropriating Ambedkar Go Hand in Hand |url=https://thewire.in/politics/ambedkar-appropriating-rss-bjp |access-date=2023-10-02 |website=The Wire}}</ref> }}'''Sita Ram Goel''' (16 October 1921 – 3 December 2003) was an Indian scholar and historian. His work has been celebrated for challenging the prevailing secular, ] narrative in Indian intellectual and cultural discourse, but also criticized for its alignment with the Hindu right.<ref>{{Cite web |date=2021-10-16 |title=Sita Ram Goel: The man who exposed Nehruvian fallacies and won our hearts with his mind |url=https://www.firstpost.com/india/sita-ram-goel-the-man-who-exposed-nehruvian-fallacies-and-won-our-hearts-with-his-mind-10060681.html |access-date=2023-10-02 |website=Firstpost |language=en}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web |title=For the RSS, Denouncing and Appropriating Ambedkar Go Hand in Hand |url=https://thewire.in/politics/ambedkar-appropriating-rss-bjp |access-date=2023-10-02 |website=The Wire}}</ref>


In his later career, Goel transitioned into a role as a commentator on Indian politics, aligning himself openly with Hindu nationalism, a stance that has generated significant debate and scrutiny among scholars and observers of Indian society and politics.<ref>{{cite book |chapter=Tolerance and Hierarchy: Accommodating Multiple Religious Paths in Hinduism |first=Richard H. |last=Davis |pages=361–362 |title=Religious Tolerance in World Religions |editor1-first=Jacob |editor1-last=Neusner |editor2-first=Bruce |editor2-last=Chilton |edition=2nd |publisher=Templeton Foundation Press |year=2008 |isbn=978-1-59947-136-5 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=z_695Vfox-0C |access-date=23 January 2012 }}{{Dead link|date=February 2023 |bot=InternetArchiveBot |fix-attempted=yes }}</ref><ref>{{cite book |chapter=The Indian Church: Catholicism and Indian Nationhood |first=Mathew N. |last=Schmalz |title=The Catholic Church and the nation-state: comparative perspectives |editor1-first=Paul Christopher |editor1-last=Manuel |editor2-first=Lawrence Christopher |editor2-last=Reardon |editor3-first=Clyde |editor3-last=Wilcox |publisher=Georgetown University Press |year=2006 |isbn=978-1-58901-115-1 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=-8gqfwcbTaAC |page=217 |access-date=23 January 2012}}</ref> In his later career, Goel transitioned into a role as a commentator on Indian politics, aligning himself openly with Hindu nationalism, a stance that has generated significant debate and scrutiny among scholars and observers of Indian society and politics.<ref>{{cite book |chapter=Tolerance and Hierarchy: Accommodating Multiple Religious Paths in Hinduism |first=Richard H. |last=Davis |pages=361–362 |title=Religious Tolerance in World Religions |editor1-first=Jacob |editor1-last=Neusner |editor2-first=Bruce |editor2-last=Chilton |edition=2nd |publisher=Templeton Foundation Press |year=2008 |isbn=978-1-59947-136-5 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=z_695Vfox-0C |access-date=23 January 2012 }}{{Dead link|date=February 2023 |bot=InternetArchiveBot |fix-attempted=yes }}</ref><ref>{{cite book |chapter=The Indian Church: Catholicism and Indian Nationhood |first=Mathew N. |last=Schmalz |title=The Catholic Church and the nation-state: comparative perspectives |editor1-first=Paul Christopher |editor1-last=Manuel |editor2-first=Lawrence Christopher |editor2-last=Reardon |editor3-first=Clyde |editor3-last=Wilcox |publisher=Georgetown University Press |year=2006 |isbn=978-1-58901-115-1 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=-8gqfwcbTaAC |page=217 |access-date=23 January 2012}}</ref>

Latest revision as of 04:38, 5 December 2024

Indian activist, writer and publisher (1921–2003)
This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these messages)
The neutrality of this article is disputed. Relevant discussion may be found on the talk page. Please do not remove this message until conditions to do so are met. (March 2019) (Learn how and when to remove this message)
This article relies excessively on references to primary sources. Please improve this article by adding secondary or tertiary sources.
Find sources: "Sita Ram Goel" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (March 2019) (Learn how and when to remove this message)
The examples and perspective in this article may not include all significant viewpoints. Please improve the article or discuss the issue. (March 2019) (Learn how and when to remove this message)
(Learn how and when to remove this message)

Sita Ram Goel
Sita Ram GoelSita Ram Goel
Born(1921-10-16)16 October 1921
Punjab Province, British India
Died3 December 2003(2003-12-03) (aged 82)
Occupation
  • Historian
  • Writer
  • publisher
Alma materUniversity of Delhi
PeriodLate 20th century
GenreHistory, Politics, Comparative Religion
SubjectHinduism, Dharmic traditions, Christianity, Islam, Communism, Indian politics, British Imperialism
Notable worksHow I Became a Hindu
The Story of Islamic Imperialism in India
History of Hindu–Christian Encounters, AD 304 to 1996
Catholic Ashrams
Hindu Temples: What Happened to Them

Sita Ram Goel (16 October 1921 – 3 December 2003) was an Indian scholar and historian. His work has been celebrated for challenging the prevailing secular, Nehruvian narrative in Indian intellectual and cultural discourse, but also criticized for its alignment with the Hindu right.

In his later career, Goel transitioned into a role as a commentator on Indian politics, aligning himself openly with Hindu nationalism, a stance that has generated significant debate and scrutiny among scholars and observers of Indian society and politics.

Life

Early life

Sita Ram Goel was born to a Hindu family in Punjab, in 1921; though his childhood was spent in Calcutta. The family looked upon Sri Garib Das, a nirguna saint comparable to Kabir and Nanak, as its patron saint and his verses, "Granth Saheb", were often recited at their home.

Goel graduated in history from the University of Delhi in 1944. As a student, he was a social activist and worked for a Harijan Ashram in his village. His sympathies for the Arya Samaj, the Harijans and the Indian freedom movement, along with his strong support for Mahatma Gandhi, brought him into conflict with many people in his village; Goel also learned to speak and write Sanskrit during his college days.

Works

Hindu View of Christianity and Islam (1993)

In 1993 the MP Syed Shahabuddin, who in 1988 asked for the ban on The Satanic Verses, demanded a ban on Ram Swarup's book Hindu View of Christianity and Islam. Goel and Swarup went into hiding because they feared that they could get arrested. The court accepted a bail and the authors came out of hiding. Arun Shourie and K. S. Lal protested against the ban.

Colin Maine's The Dead Hand of Islam

In 1986, Goel reprinted Colin Maine's essay The Dead Hand of Islam . Some Muslims filed a criminal case against Goel, alleging that it violated Sections 153A and 295A of the Indian Penal Code and similar articles of the Indian Customs Act.

The judge discharged Goel and referred to the earlier court precedent "1983 CrLJ 1446". Speaking of the importance of that precedent, the judge in his discussion said: "If such a contention is accepted a day will come when that part of history which is unpalatable to a particular religion will have to be kept in cold storage on the pretext that the publication of such history would constitute an offence punishable under Sec. 153A of the Penal Code. The scope of S-153A cannot be enlarged to such an extent with a view to thwart history. (...) Otherwise, the position will be very precarious. A nation will have to forget its own history and in due course the nation will have no history at all. (...) If anybody intends to extinguish the history (by prohibiting its publication) of the nation on the pretext of taking action under the above sections, his act will have to be treated as malafide one."

The Calcutta Quran Petition

Goel published The Calcutta Quran Petition with Chandmal Chopra in 1986. On 31 August 1987, Chopra was arrested by the police and kept in custody until 8 September for publishing the book with Goel. Goel absconded to avoid arrest.

Hindu Temples – What Happened to Them

There were proposals in November 1990 in Uttar Pradesh to ban Goel's book Hindu Temples - What Happened to Them.

Legacy

Sita Ram Goel has been described by Koenraad Elst as an "intellectual kshatriya". David Frawley said about Goel that he was "modern India's greatest intellectual kshatriya", and "one of India's most important thinkers in the post-independence era". According to Frawley, "Sitaram followed a strong rationalistic point of view that did not compromise the truth even for politeness sake. His intellectual rigor is quite unparalleled in Hindu circles..."

Books and booklets

English

Author

  • The China debate; whom shall we believe?, Calcutta: Society for Defence of Freedom in Asia, 1953, 50 p.
  • Mind Murder in Mao-land, Calcutta: Society for Defence of Freedom in Asia, 1953, 53 p.
  • Communist Party in China: a study in treason., Calcutta: Society for Defence of Freedom in Asia, 1953, 106 p.
  • China is red with peasants' blood, Calcutta: Society for Defence of Freedom in Asia, 1953, 92 p.
  • CPI conspires for civil-war: analysis of a secret document, Calcutta: Society for Defence of Freedom in Asia, 1953, 56 p.
  • Red brother or yellow slave ?, Calcutta: Society for Defence of Freedom in Asia, 1953, 82 p.
  • Nehru's fatal friendship, New Delhi: Society for Defence of Freedom in Asia, 1955, 29 p.
  • Netaji and the CPI, Calcutta: Society for Defence of Freedom in Asia, 1955, 72 p.
  • In defence of Comrade Krishna Menon : a political biography of Pandit Nehru, New Delhi: Bharati Sahitya Sadan, 1963, 272 p. A reprint with changes would appear in 1993 as the Volume I of Genesis and growth of Nehruism.
  • Hindu society under siege, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1981, 48 p. A revised edition released in 1994.
  • How I Became a Hindu, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1982, 67 p. A third enlarged edition would appear in 1993, 106 p.
  • The Story of Islamic Imperialism in India, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1982, 126 p. A second enlarged edition would appear in 1994, 138 p.
  • Defence of Hindu Society, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1983, 96 p. A second edition would appear in 1987 and a third enlarged one in 1994, 118 p.
  • Muslim separatism : causes and consequences, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1983, 123 p. A second revised edition will appear in 1995, 128 p.
  • Perversion of India's political parlance, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1984, 60 p.
  • History of heroic Hindu resistance to Muslim invaders, 636 AD to 1206 AD, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1984, 48 p. Another edition would be released in 1994, 58 p.
  • The emerging national vision, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1984, 15 p.
  • St. Francis Xavier : the man and his mission, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1985, 16 p.
  • Papacy, its doctrines and history, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1986, 118 p.
  • Catholic Ashrams: adopting and adapting Hindu dharma, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1988, 100 p.
  • History of Hindu–Christian Encounters, AD 304 to 1996, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1989, 405 p. A second revised and enlarged edition would appear in 1996, 530 p.
  • Hindus and Hinduism : Manipulation of meanings, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1993, 24 p.
  • Islam vis-a-vis Hindu temples, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1993, 66 p.
  • Genesis and growth of Nehruism. vol. 1, Commitment to Communism, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1993, 231 p. Reprint with changes of the 1963 book In defence of Comrade Krishna Menon.
  • Stalinist "historians" spread the big lie, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1993, 38 p.
  • Jesus Christ : an artifice for aggression, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1994, 114 p.

Editor

  • Hindu temples, what happened to them : Vol. I, A preliminary survey, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1990, 191 p. With Arun Shourie et al. Volume II would be released in 1993, 440 p.
  • Freedom of expression : secular theocracy versus liberal democracy, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1998, 179 p. Mostly articles.
  • Time for stock taking, whither Sangh Parivar?, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1997, 468 p. Criticisms of the BJP and RSS, including their responses.
  • Vindicated by Time: the Niyogi Committee report on Christian missionary activities, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1998, 1006 p. A reprint, with an introduction by Goel, of the official report on the missionaries' methods of subversion and conversion, from 1956.

Prefaces, introductions or commentaries

  • Introduction to Joseph Stalin's World Conquest in Instalments, Calcutta: Society for Defence of Freedom in Asia, 1952, 56 p.
  • Commentary of Mao Zedong's The conquest of China, Calcutta: Society for Defence of Freedom in Asia, 1954, 276 p.
  • Preface to Chandmal Chopra's The Calcutta Quran Petition, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1986, 71 p. A third revised and enlarged edition would appear in 1999, with more writing by Goel, 325 p.
  • Preface to Tipu Sultan: Villain Or Hero? : an Anthology, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1993, 85 p.
  • Preface to the reprint of Mathilda Joslyn Gage's Woman, Church and State (1997, ca. 1880). A feminist critique of Christianity.

Hindi

Author

  • Pathabhṛshṭa, 1960.
  • Saikyularijma : deśadroha kā dūsrā nāma, 1983.Yashpal Sharma would translate it into English as India's secularism, new name for national subversion, New Delhi: Voice of India, 1999, 107 p.
  • Udīyamāna raṣṭra-dṛṣṭi, 1983.
  • Hindū samāja : saṅkeṭoṃ ke ghere meṃ, 1988.
  • Saptaśīla, 1999.

Translator

See also

References

Citations

  1. "Sita Ram Goel: The man who exposed Nehruvian fallacies and won our hearts with his mind". Firstpost. 16 October 2021. Retrieved 2 October 2023.
  2. "For the RSS, Denouncing and Appropriating Ambedkar Go Hand in Hand". The Wire. Retrieved 2 October 2023.
  3. Davis, Richard H. (2008). "Tolerance and Hierarchy: Accommodating Multiple Religious Paths in Hinduism". In Neusner, Jacob; Chilton, Bruce (eds.). Religious Tolerance in World Religions (2nd ed.). Templeton Foundation Press. pp. 361–362. ISBN 978-1-59947-136-5. Retrieved 23 January 2012.
  4. Schmalz, Mathew N. (2006). "The Indian Church: Catholicism and Indian Nationhood". In Manuel, Paul Christopher; Reardon, Lawrence Christopher; Wilcox, Clyde (eds.). The Catholic Church and the nation-state: comparative perspectives. Georgetown University Press. p. 217. ISBN 978-1-58901-115-1. Retrieved 23 January 2012.
  5. This is a separate collection of hymns by Garibdas and a few other Bhakti saints. Not to be confused with holy-book of The Sikhs
  6. Goel, Sita Ram, "How I became a Hindu" Archived 30 September 2007 at the Wayback Machine, Chapter 1
  7. Goel, Sita Ram, "How I became a Hindu", Chapter 2
  8. Goel, Sita Ram, "How I became a Hindu", Chapter 3
  9. Shahabuddin, Syed. "You did this with satanic forethought, Mr. Rushdie." Times of India. 13 October 1988.
  10. In Syed Shahabuddin's letter to P.M. Sayeed, Minister of State in the Ministry of Home Affairs on 20 August 1993. Sita Ram Goel:The Calcutta Quran Petition., Chapter 1.
  11. ^ S.R. Goel, ed.: Freedom of Expression, 1998
  12. ^ K. Elst: "Banning Hindu Revaluation", Observer of Business and Politics, 1 December 1993
  13. Freedom of expression – Secular Theocracy Versus Liberal Democracy (1998, edited by Sita Ram Goel) ISBN 81-85990-55-7
  14. Elst, 1991.
  15. "Elst 1991". Archived from the original on 27 September 2007.
  16. e.g. in India's only communalist: In commemoration of Sita Ram Goel; Edited by Koenraad Elst; Voice of India, New Delhi. (2005)
  17. "David Frawley Books - How I Became A Hindu My Discover Of Vedic Dharma - Journalistic Work (Page8)". hindubooks.org.
  18. "Hindu Society Under Siege".
  19. "How I Became Hindu".

Sources

Further reading

External links

Works of Sita Ram Goel
Criticism of religion
By religion
Religious texts
Religious figures
Religious discrimination
Religious violence
Books
Movements
  • Agnosticism
  • Antitheism
  • Atheism
  • Cārvāka
  • New Atheism
  • Nontheistic religions
  • Parody religion
    • Related topics
    Modern Hindu writers (1848 to date)
    Religious writers
    Political writers
    Literary writers
    Westerners influenced
    by Hinduism
    Scholars
    Lists
    Portals: Categories: